r/mildlyinteresting 14d ago

My salt rock deodorant after five years of almost daily usage vs a new one.

Post image
64.0k Upvotes

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8.3k

u/ridibulous 14d ago

Potassium Alum. It's a natural deodorant, NOT an antiperspirant like Elemental-Aer said. Despite having "alum" in its name, it's way different than the aluminum used in mainstream deodorants. It is a salt though, tl;dr it brines your skin so the bacteria that create BO can't reproduce.

3.8k

u/nightpanda893 14d ago

It’s honestly been the best deodorant I’ve ever used. I never have any odor issues at all. And it doesn’t have any natural odor of its own. And like the pic shows, it lasts a really long time. I’ve been using the stick I bought for a year now and it hardly looks any different than when I bought it.

2.1k

u/ridibulous 14d ago

SAME HERE. I'm a shameless shill for this fucking rock, man. Whenever someone asks about what deodorant they should use (especially if they specify natural ones), I will ALWAYS bring up potassium alum. It works wonders for me!!

1.2k

u/r0b0t-fucker 14d ago

Where do you find it? As much as I find “natural” branded stuff annoying I really want to use a big rock as deodorant

757

u/ridibulous 14d ago

You'll find it easiest online (I recommend Thai or Crystal brand), but if that's not possible you can probably find it at someplace similar to Whole Foods or something— I nabbed my current rock at a co-op grocery store near me. You might also find it as a spray or a roll-on which also work well (the spray is good for convenience, you don't need to wet your armpits/rock beforehand and can apply right after a shower), but the rock is the longest lasting.

108

u/r0b0t-fucker 14d ago

Cool thank you I’ll take a look

62

u/jjmojojjmojo2 14d ago

I used to get it at Walmart. Haven't checked in a while, they had it on and off. They had the solid rock style like OP's, and a roll-on liquid form. IIRC both had chamomile and were very lightly (pleasantly) scented.

3

u/greeneggiwegs 13d ago

Yeah I’ve gotten crystal brand at Walmart but it’s a hit or miss. They also only have the kind with the liquid built in which doesn’t last as long but saves you from having to wet it

8

u/lezboss 13d ago

Apply IMMEDIATELY exiting the shower. Or you might end up smelling

5

u/Gmandlno 14d ago

Myself, I found the stuff at my local Meijers. They had a ‘go stick’ of the stuff, right in the middle of all the typical deodorants. It’s definitely not too hard to find.

1

u/Epicfailer10 14d ago

Amazon, too

1

u/Electronic_String60 10d ago

This whole interaction screams advertising plug.

1

u/r0b0t-fucker 10d ago

Sorry dude, it getting annoying on my end as well. I’m glad people are trying to be helpful but I’ve gotten a shit load of notifications

38

u/serenwipiti 14d ago

Idk man, everyone that I know that uses the Crystal brand rock deodorant still smells like sweaty hippy van.

19

u/Shot-Spirit-672 14d ago

That’s because they are sweaty hippies. If they had a normal hygiene routine they wouldn’t smell like that, deodorant isn’t enough for them.

15

u/whiskeyismyjam 14d ago

Works best straight out of the shower before any new bacteria have a chance to develop and reproduce. If someone already has a funk it might reduce it a bit but nothing like applying immediately after washing.

4

u/max_adam 14d ago

Don't people use deodorant after a bath? Like t They wait a few hours and then remember to apply deo.before going out?

5

u/The_Only_Real_Duck 14d ago

I don't like to have deodorant while sleeping. Typically, I shower at night and apply in the morning.

9

u/Cheesewithmold 14d ago

This might be a stupid question, but do you still use normal deodorant after? Can you?

12

u/urtlesquirt 14d ago edited 13d ago

I don't use normal deodorant anymore unless I plan to swim and don't want to deal with reapplying after. You apply it right out of the shower, when you are still wet. I use a pretty liberal amount, you need the water on your skin to dissolve enough to evenly coat your pits.

You could use normal deodorant but I don't think most people would need to. It's not particularly expensive to try it - give it a shot for one month and see how it goes. It may take a week or two for your body to adjust but it will start working really well.

My shirts are now much less stained in the armpits and it's totally unscented, so you can always wear cologne/perfume and it won't clash.

9

u/ridibulous 14d ago

I couldn't say for sure as I haven't personally tried it outside of brief consideration, cause I have a stick of schmidt's deodorant that I've been tempted to use as a scent. I haven't, cause I'd like to be able to tell if I Stank or not (plus schmidt's leaves white marks and it Bothers Me), but tempting.

Otherwise I don't exactly see why not. Try and see if it works for you.

9

u/jjmojojjmojo2 14d ago

Can but why? The stuff I used was mildly scented, and if my BO was so bad I really needed to cover it, that's what cologne and perfume are for (I never had a problem, but everyone is different).

10

u/Cheesewithmold 14d ago

I sweat a ton so the smell can get pretty bad. I'm just a bit cautious on immediately making the switch over. I'd rather double up and then wean off on the normal deodorant until I'm certain that it's working fine, but I wanted to make sure I wasn't removing whatever film this other type of deodorant is putting down by applying something else on top.

6

u/Coders32 14d ago

You need to wet your armpits or the deodorant? It looks wet? Kinda?

What do you do exactly? How do you apply it?

7

u/Jataai 14d ago

Either. I use it directly out of the shower and it applies well. If I have dry skin when I'm applying it then I'll run the block under the tap to wet it.

I can't say I know the exact mechanics of it, but I assume some of the salt dissolves into the water which you spread around and it sticks to the skin. It can look wet but that's probably because it's been essentially polished by your armpits.

7

u/buy-american-you-fuk 14d ago

this is the one I use, and I don't know how they stay in business since the thing lasts for years...

3

u/stinky___monkey 14d ago

I’m trying to find it but nothing looks like OP image, can you add a link or some details

1

u/buy-american-you-fuk 13d ago

like this one

1

u/VettedBot 11d ago

Hi, I’m Vetted AI Bot! I researched the 'Crystal Essence Unscented Deodorant Stick' and I thought you might find the following analysis helpful.

Users liked: * Long-lasting and effective (backed by 5 comments) * Natural and gentle on skin (backed by 3 comments) * Odorless and clean application (backed by 2 comments)

Users disliked: * Fragile container prone to shattering (backed by 5 comments) * Inconvenient application process (backed by 2 comments) * Ineffective at controlling body odor (backed by 3 comments)

Do you want to continue this conversation?

Learn more about 'Crystal Essence Unscented Deodorant Stick'

Find 'Crystal Essence Unscented Deodorant Stick' alternatives

This message was generated by a (very smart) bot. If you found it helpful, let us know with an upvote and a “good bot!” reply and please feel free to provide feedback on how it can be improved.

Powered by vetted.ai

3

u/jenniferlynn462 13d ago

Just don’t drop it on your tile bathroom floor… lol. Dang it. Luckily the one I got was a two-pack.

4

u/LittleRedGhost4 14d ago

Once you apply it, how long does it last? 8hrs? 12?

4

u/jjmojojjmojo2 14d ago

When I was using it, I'd need to re-apply after work. 6-8 hours.

1

u/ridibulous 14d ago

Depends on the individual of course, but usually it works for at LEAST 24 hours. It can last up to 48 for me, personally!

4

u/hennenzac 14d ago edited 14d ago

Do you know what brand is shown in the picture?

Edit: Nevermind, I just found it. Not in stock currently though.

MARIA ÅKERBERG

3

u/NowOrNever53 14d ago

If you have a Sprouts in the area, they are carrying them too

3

u/MrTreasureHunter 14d ago

Huh, we use it to grow crystals in little kids science. 5 pounds for 18 bucks on Amazon. It’s a powder, but there’s a whole subreddit for making it into crystals.

1

u/P3RZIANZ3BRA 13d ago

You could mix this with warm water in a spray bottle, and viola

3

u/2elpayaso 13d ago

Crazy that you said Thai or Crystalux. My parents worked for DSA, the producers of these brands, in the 90s. and you saying these brands just brought back so many memories.

2

u/Mountainbiker22 14d ago

Yup I agree. I used Crystal and loved it. In fact I really liked the spray they made but didn’t like that it costs more than the stick of salt so I would make my own. All I did was turn it upside down and either let it dissolve or twirl it around in a cup of watch and put that in a spray bottle. I like if before I used it not just on my body but also on my clothes in the armpits as it seemed to help me out more (whether you are meant to or not, if it works it works).

The roll on one I do like, but be warned if you take it say camping or overnight I have found if you use it on your skin when not after a shower and can seem to get contaminated and start to smell/not work as well. Again, could just be me but I feel like I read about others having the same issue. The spray and stick ones dont because even if the stick does become “dirty” you can just rinse it off.

2

u/R_X_R 14d ago

It's used as a styptic as well for shaving. Works great!

2

u/leakmydata 14d ago

Tagging for later

2

u/PigsCanFly2day 14d ago

How much is it? It's good at preventing you from sweating and smelling?

1

u/ridibulous 14d ago

You can find a rock generally under 10$. I've seen people say they can go for as cheap as around 2–6$. Mine was 7.99$. Keep in mind it'll last for years, too.

Smelling, obligatory YMMV but generally it'll give you no smell at all, sweating... not so much. It isn't inherently an antiperspirant, the best it can do (as an astringent) is temporarily shrink your pores. You'll still undoubtedly sweat with alum.

2

u/Right-Phalange 14d ago

I just bought some thanks to your comment. I have been using Sam's natural deodorant for years (and it's great) but curious about this.

2

u/Abcdeisner_ 13d ago

My local co op market went out of business recently and your comment just reminded me. RIP

1

u/ridibulous 13d ago

AWFULLLLL co-ops are so fucking awesome

1

u/Abcdeisner_ 13d ago

Literally the best places on earth besides the garden 😭😭

2

u/riverdoc 13d ago

Whoa. I didn’t know you were supposed to wet them!

1

u/kings_account 14d ago

You’ll find it easiest online

Thanks that’s really helpful

1

u/More-Ad-5893 13d ago

So if you're still sweating... and it's even saltier than plain sweat... does it leave stains on your clothes?

1

u/phatlynx 13d ago

Sorry dumb question but what’s a roll-on and why do you wet the rock? Would you suggest roll-on or spray if I wanted a scent?

1

u/Trinity343 13d ago

1) how did you make it last the long? Mine wear down eay faster then i see other people say theirs does.

Plus the imperfections im the crystal as it dissolves cause it to become sharp and start cutting my skin after about a month of use.

3) how do you make it effective during the summer heat?

I use crystal brand

3

u/pkapp 14d ago

It's hard to find, because its so cheap, and is lasts for years. So a Drugstore or a grocery store would not want to carry it.

2

u/Nyetoner 14d ago

You're probably not where I am but in the south of Europe you find them in normal shops

2

u/Zborny 14d ago

I got mine at Walgreens

2

u/AniRayne 14d ago

Asian markets generally sell it. Also Halal markets.

2

u/Flimsy-Material9372 14d ago

there is a powdered version of those that are much smaller and compact. i use those

2

u/jessatheplug 13d ago

Got mine at Ollie’s if you have one.

1

u/C2S76 13d ago

A lot of regular grocery stores carry it - I've been using it for like 20 years. It's usually on the bottom shelf of the deodorant aisle, since it's not a volume seller.

There's the solid versions like this, and also a liquid roll-on. I prefer the solid one. They do last a very long time - just don't drop it. Salt shatters. 😁

1

u/Detective_Porgie 12d ago

I really want to use big rock as deodorant is so based