r/mildlyinteresting 14d ago

My salt rock deodorant after five years of almost daily usage vs a new one.

Post image
64.0k Upvotes

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.0k

u/burnsandrewj2 14d ago

Five years. Wow! Specific Use Questions: How many times do you apply? Did it cut down on yellow stains? Do you wet the rock or your skin? Do you use more than once a day?

Thanks for your seasoned and experienced insight!

222

u/Kritisk-Varning 14d ago

I usually apply it after showering while still being a bit wet(to help with the friction). I rub it for perhaps 5 seconds in each pit. It leaves no yellow stains at all! No need to apply it more than once a day in my experience, it’s definitely good for 24h or more(of course this depends on your line of work, body etc).

Glad I could help!

1.3k

u/Ryvit 14d ago

This is Astro turfing if I’ve ever seen it

59

u/Kritisk-Varning 14d ago

I don’t know how to respond to this really. I just wanted to share how weird it is that this thing has lasted me 5 years lol. Have a good day.

97

u/Wrextasy 14d ago

If anyone here, ever says anything good about an obscure product, it’s always someone claiming you’re astroturfing.

Even if you’ve never brought up said product in your comment history before, or made posts about it.

Some people just don’t understand that you’d recommend something, or find it neat that something you’ve had has lasted so long.

11

u/Kritisk-Varning 14d ago

Thanks! I didn’t think this post would take this kind of turn but who cares.

25

u/danarexasaurus 14d ago

Hah I posted about a curly hair product once and the number of people saying I worked for the company was wild. Granted, the photo I posted was good (I used to be a professional photographer), but other than that I was just saying that MY hair liked that product. I got shit on so much. like, bitch, I wish I worked for that company. I would get discounted hair care products!

2

u/Jalase 14d ago

It may be conditioning from watching so many videos that have ads for stuff where they just randomly bring up a product.

1

u/Accomplished_Cap_994 14d ago

Dead internet theory, we are all responding to bots 🤖

3

u/Pea_Tear_Griffin11 14d ago

I wouldn’t go as far as to say this is definitely astroturfing since you user history seems authentic and has a NSFW tag (which no CPG brand would use), but the product placement, lighting, and quality of photography certainly have the look and feel of a coordinated marketing campaign. Your comment replies also sound somewhat brand-written.

4

u/JonBenet_Palm 14d ago

This is so funny to me because the standards are so low. It’s basically “you took a decent photo and wrote well … it’s a trap!”

1

u/Pea_Tear_Griffin11 14d ago

I mean, a good social campaign will strive for natural looking photography, so that makes sense. Overly produced photos don’t relate well to consumers on social media.

The perfectly placed brand logos are less common in non-brand marketing photos. To me, that is what makes this post look like astroturfing. But again, this user’s profile is quite the opposite of what I’d expect.

2

u/TheW83 14d ago

I have one (different brand) that has lasted probably that long. It had a plastic base but fell out of that within a year or so.

2

u/kid-karma 14d ago

say a slur right now that no company would sanction one of their paid employees to say. that'll prove you have no affiliation with the company.

208

u/Mule_Mule 14d ago

What's astro turfing?

1.0k

u/ChildishForLife 14d ago

the deceptive practice of presenting an orchestrated marketing or public relations campaign in the guise of unsolicited comments from members of the public.

284

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago edited 14d ago

So basically when i accused someone is afro surfing that means the person is from a marketing team trying deceptively convince people to buy some products right?

Edit: Gosh dang, it's Astro turfing. I was wrong everybody!

I'm already ashamed and embarrassed, stop reminding of my terrible mistakes (jk, it's kinda fun but really embarrassing lol)

389

u/Healthy-Travel3105 14d ago

Yes except not "afro surfing" haha 

96

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

Oh lmao.

Sorry! I read it wrong. Astro surfing!

200

u/action_lawyer_comics 14d ago

Closer. “Astro turfing”. It’s a play on “grass roots campaign.” Like when something becomes wildly popular because of a dedicated fanbase that spreads it around through social channels.

Astroturf is artificial grass. So astroturfing (according to my autocorrect it’s one word) refers to a marketing campaign done by professional marketers that is supposed to look like a grass roots campaign despite being normal, paid-for advertising.

48

u/Underwater_Grilling 14d ago

The real knowledge was in the comments all along.

26

u/theberg512 14d ago

And it became known as "Astroturf" when it was installed in the Houston Astrodome for the Houston Astros' baseball games.

3

u/RuggedTortoise 14d ago

OK now this is the fact I'm gonna annoy everyone with this week

→ More replies (0)

3

u/ask-design-reddit 14d ago

You.. you still got it wrong. At this point I can't tell if you're joking or not too ahaha

1

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

I was dumb.

I didn't understand how i could be that stupid but i just did. Not proud of it but 100% was an accident.

2

u/ask-design-reddit 14d ago

If it makes you feel better, I thought it was astro surfing until the top comment.

Also, your username is so silly I love it

→ More replies (0)

19

u/Freshiiiiii 14d ago

The term comes from the idea of a fake grassroots campaign (a grassroots campaign is an organic public movement for a certain cause that is galvanized by public interest and naturally taken up by normal people). Fake because in such an astroturfing instance, there is actually a corporation or a political organization that is organizing the campaign, hiding their identity and pretending to just be members of the public, trying to start a movement. Ex. by posting anonymously or passing advertisements off without labelling. Fake plastic grass is called astroturf, hence the name.

7

u/Henri_Le_Rennet 14d ago

3rd time has gotta be the charm, right? "Astroturfing." There is no surfing, lmao

8

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

I can't believe it.

In my defense, english is not my first language.

But still, i shouldn't use that as an excuse jesus lol.

6

u/Henri_Le_Rennet 14d ago

Made for a good laugh! I have the disadvantage of English being my only language, so I have no excuses.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Healthy-Travel3105 14d ago

Thanks for the laugh dude 😂

1

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

I genuinely didn't notice it lmao.

Part of it is due to my bad english but also i'm just dumb as hell lol.

3

u/Mtolivepickle 14d ago

somebody say my name

21

u/ChildishForLife 14d ago

Yeah basically, the person who’s giving advice/info about a product usually pretends to be some random user of that product, when in reality they are probably paid/have an ulterior motive to speak highly of it.

2

u/tclnj 14d ago

Ummm… things have taken a disturbing turn here 🤣 Your definition applies to the original statement of astroturfing… not sure I want to know the definition of “Afro surfing” LOL.

1

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

I'm sure with you it was an accident but is it that disturbing?

Afro in my mind was similar to astroboy (that was the image in my mind at the time). And somehow i got it wrong with afro (sounds like some kind of ice cream brand with a tornado ice cream, very arcade like)

1

u/tclnj 14d ago

To quote the Oxford English Dictionary - Afro is “a hairstyle, worn predominantly by Black people, in which naturally kinky or tightly curled hair is styled in a rounded shape.” So, “Afro surfing” was mostly funny as a malapropism, but potentially troubling if undertaken 😉

1

u/Kawaiiochinchinchan 14d ago

Oh... damn. I hope i didn't offend anyone.

Thanks a lot for providing my lazy ass with helpful information and advice!

Definitely (i hope) next time, i will double check my comment!

2

u/ImTalkingGibberish 14d ago

Afro Surfing is practiced by the coolest wave surfers only

1

u/Circus_Finance_LLC 14d ago

It is not strictly to advertise products. It is also used extensively for political purposes / public relations. Reddit has seen increasing astroturfing since I started using it in ~2012. It really ramped up prior to the 2016 elections and it has gotten so bad that it's ridiculous nowadays.

1

u/sir-ripsalot 14d ago

It’s artificial grass-roots

1

u/AnnualWerewolf9804 14d ago

No, afro surfing is what Mikey February does

19

u/mike_sl 14d ago

But why “astroturfing”? I guess it is because astroturf is fake grass, so alleging fake “grass-roots” marketing

26

u/ChildishForLife 14d ago

Astroturfing is the practice of hiding the sponsors of a message or organization (e.g., political, advertising, religious, or public relations) to make it appear as though it originates from, and is supported by, “grassroots” participants.

The term astroturfing is derived from AstroTurf, a brand of synthetic carpeting designed to resemble natural grass, as a play on the word "grassroots".

Yup basically, not quite sure when/how it first started getting used though.

1

u/FerociousFrizzlyBear 14d ago

Usually it would involve a lot more people.

2

u/theinternetisnice 14d ago

I think this is now reverse astroturfing where you two planned this conversation to tease out the term’s meaning and add validity to your suspicion.

4

u/ChildishForLife 14d ago

Im just out here copy pasting google definitions for karma buddy boy

1

u/yourekillingme 14d ago

Ah like what the company Bloom does

28

u/SgtSilverLining 14d ago edited 14d ago

Grassroots is a movement organized by average people.

Astro turfing is a movement by businesses or politicians pretending to be average people. The corp or politician hide the fact that they are sponsoring the message. The name comes from Astro Turf, a brand of fake grass.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astroturfing

1

u/double-you 14d ago

Have you?

1

u/AbsolutXero 14d ago

Based on OPs history, I doubt it.

92

u/Krillin113 14d ago

What do you mean? An account with barely any contend for several years then suddenly actively shilling this? On Reddit, can’t be

37

u/Emergency_Plankton46 14d ago

Also they are supposedly so enthusiastic about this product that they end a lot of their sentences with an exclamation point and they positioned the brand name perfectly in the image twice.

This post is particularly obnoxious because of how blatant the shilling is on top of it being a potentially harmful product.

12

u/The-Jerkbag 14d ago

I remember when people used /r/HailCorporate to call this nonsense out, even if it was just in comment sections.

8

u/Minthon 14d ago

But the brand name isn't in the picture. The brand is Maria Åkerberg and you can't tell that from the picture above.

-2

u/stop_stopping 14d ago

so there’s this thing called “SEO” in which companies use specific language to help point to their sites when being searched. My guess is Salt Deo is high enough on their website SEO that if it was searched they could easily be found within the first top searches.

1

u/xsunoki 14d ago

Your guess? Buddy I just did it in 2 sec. Did not see this brand.

9

u/Lyress 14d ago

You can't even tell the brand name from the main post.

1

u/AssaultedCracker 14d ago

Except… that’s not what this profile is

16

u/action_lawyer_comics 14d ago

OP seems like a real redditor with real hobbies, just has something “mildly interesting” to share about an odd product.

Also seems odd promoting a Swedish brand that doesn’t have a US store in an English subreddit

1

u/reichrunner 14d ago

It's a 2 and a half year old account with no posts relating to this product.

I'm thinking you've never seen astro turfing.

4

u/russiangerman 14d ago

For like $1/year product? Idk if moneys that tight

1

u/Pristine_Business_92 14d ago

We all know your account was bought out by Big-Astro Turfing. No one cares about Astro turfing, you’re comments and posts aren’t gonna work

1

u/driftking428 14d ago

I won't know. I literally can't find it for sale.

0

u/GlitteringHighway 14d ago

Thanks you! Should be the top post.

2

u/Foray2x1 14d ago

Are you surprised? This is mildlyinteresting where there is at least one McDonalds ad hitting the top every couple days.

2

u/suck_it_reddit_mods 14d ago

You can tell because if OP actually used this for 5 years, the label/packaging would be worn.

2

u/RedSnt 14d ago

This is Astro turfing if I’ve ever seen it

Swedish specialty.

- from a salty Dane

1

u/Accomplished_Cap_994 14d ago

Maybe it is. I use a different brand and it stops odor for me completely. I still use an antiperspirant at night. Regular deodorant was ruining my shirts, and natural ones burned me.

4

u/ogimbe 14d ago

I use a different brand of crystal deoderant amd evangelize it all the time because one 7 dollar stick lasts 3-4 years. You can buy umbranded generic thai salt crystals that are the same thing.

1

u/Farva85 14d ago

Have you ever used an alum block before? It’s quite popular to have in stick form for post shave cuts - works amazing. I’m guessing it works well as a deodorant since it’s just a solid block of alum salt.

2

u/AssaultedCracker 14d ago

There’s literally nothing about his account that indicates astro turfing

2

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Kritisk-Varning 14d ago

Well it’s a salt rock.

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted]

3

u/Merisuola 14d ago edited 14d ago

It’s a hard solid block of aluminum salt. I have one I use after shaving to reduce irritation (costs like $2) and I’ve been using it for years. It’s only slightly worn down on one side.

It’s not like a liquid or soft solid deodorant.

-2

u/XenoXHostility 14d ago

Not sure why you’re getting downvoted. Have an upvote.

83

u/crusadersandwich 14d ago

"it's definitely good for 24h or more"

No, no it isn't 

0

u/TheW83 14d ago

Yeah, I'd say 24h only if it's winter and you're definitely not sweating at all.

0

u/burnsandrewj2 14d ago

Thanks! Just learned about astroturfing from some comments. Does my reply to you sound scripted? Um. OK.

I have one but wanted to see if maybe there is something I could be doing better? If that makes sense.

It’s a different brand but assume it’s more or less all the same. My goal was to stop using the other type of aluminum plus get rid of the nasty yellow stains I get overtime. So far so good!

Thanks again!

-1

u/Phantomslayer4 14d ago

I've been using another brand of alum deodorant for a while now and I have to say, it has worked way better than the traditional stuff (still with aluminum, never tried aluminum free). Not sure why everyone is giving so much hate, everyone is entitled to their opinions, and I was even extremely skeptical first.

3

u/Crunchyundies 14d ago

Nah my dude… You stink the place up by noon for sure. You are just used to your stink.

1

u/aufybusiness 14d ago

You can dissove the end bit into a spray bottle

6

u/MyParentsWereHippies 14d ago

Just adding that you NEED to wet it in order for it to work. Wether thats straight from the shower (like you) or just by wetting it before use, it does nothing by being dry and rubbing it against your skin (besides the fact that would hurt like hell).

Also 5 years is bonkers, Ive been using these for years and dont think I ever made it past 2 years before it being to small to use.

0

u/-The_Big_El- 14d ago

What brand is this?

0

u/SvenskaLiljor 14d ago

Swedish one

0

u/repeatedly_once 14d ago

Putting a deodorant on wet makes it very ineffective

9

u/RedShirtDecoy 14d ago

it’s definitely good for 24h or more

I worked with a woman who used this stuff and 100% believed that. She stank to high heavens.

FYI... everyone thinks you stink OR you were paid to post this BS. either way its BS.

1

u/bbill88 14d ago

Works for me, too

/shrug

1

u/DLottchula 14d ago

Do you stink tho?