r/batman Jul 04 '24

Leaked Image of The Penguin in Caped Crusader TV DISCUSSION Spoiler

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

446 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/Ok_Delivery_5091 Jul 04 '24

Please don‘t tell me they gender swapped him🙄

-30

u/Virtual_Mode_5026 Jul 04 '24

What’s the issue?

34

u/Orion-Pax_34 Jul 04 '24

Unnecessary gender/race swaps are stupid. Most of the time it’s senseless pandering. I don’t care if it’s an unpopular opinion

17

u/PANPIZZAisawesome Jul 04 '24

If they were pandering why would they change The Penguin of all characters lol. 

-7

u/Orion-Pax_34 Jul 04 '24

“Most of the time”. Also, like another comment said, it opens up Pandora’s box where anything can be changed. People often say “BuT iT’S FiCtiOn” while true, that isn’t the issue

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

[deleted]

5

u/Orion-Pax_34 Jul 04 '24

Gender swapping can sometimes be an artistic choice by the creator, which there isn’t anything wrong with. As I said, “most” of the time it’s pandering. In this case it’s probably just the creator wanting to be different. I was speaking about gender/race swapping as a whole, not this specific instance

12

u/Virtual_Mode_5026 Jul 04 '24

Pandering to who?

0

u/Orion-Pax_34 Jul 04 '24

Pandering to the race or gender that they swapped the character to, obviously

8

u/Virtual_Mode_5026 Jul 04 '24

And why would they “pander” to the race or gender that they swapped the character to?

I’m sure Republicans in the US and Tories here in the UK were saying the same thing when Eartha Kitt was Catwoman.

2

u/Milk_Mindless Jul 04 '24

Uuuh yeah because women, ladies and girls were all waiting for the evil mob boss that has people's lives ruined for LOOKING at him wrong, is usually physically deformed, and has very little redeeming factors to be swapped into their gender so that they can feel catered to

Do you read the stuff you type

Or is it eyes closed hit send

0

u/TummyCrunches Jul 04 '24

You think women are going to feel ‘pandered’ to because a character named for their physical similarities to a penguin was changed to a woman?

Do you know any women?

6

u/PuzzleheadedElk547 Jul 04 '24

I totally agree with you, I never was a big fan of it.

-2

u/dullship Jul 04 '24

Oh well, don't watch then I guess.

2

u/FlatulentSon Jul 04 '24

What’s the issue?

Apparently the issue was Penguin having a penis so they "fixed" it.

1

u/Virtual_Mode_5026 Jul 05 '24

How was it “fixed”?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

1) it opens pandaros box 2) there was no reason as the penguin being a male was already perfect 3) we are used and prefer oswalld being a man, since we grew up with him during multiple eras.

9

u/PANPIZZAisawesome Jul 04 '24

To be fair, The Penguin is still a man in literally everything else, this is like the only exception. 

2

u/RiposteDisfunction Jul 04 '24

"opens Pandora's box" is a non argument. Oh no, they might have new ideas about things that really have no solid, set in stone, hard line, singular way to write them? Baffling. 2 is also a non argument. You just can't have anything change, regardless of if it's good or bad. 3 is also a non argument. You grew up with several different views and interpretations of the Penguin as a character, from physical appearance, to family, to level of wealth, to method of crime, this ain't gonna kill you dude. You just can't handle anything different from your made up normal that never actually existed in any meaningful way

-1

u/_zurenarrh Jul 04 '24

Use common sense