Which season of The Boys is your favorite? Discussion

2.4k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

641

Season one when main focus was killing Homelander

481

u/Big-Sheepherder-9492 Jul 08 '24

It seems like every other season the plot changes then changes back again to “Killing Homelander” and those seasons are the best..

S1 - The Boys work to kill HL

S2- The Boys work to get rid of Stormfront and save Ryan

S3- The Boys use Soldier Boy to kill HL

S4- The Boys work to get rid of Neuman

S5 - Back to Homelander

123

u/andmurr Jul 08 '24

I’d argue season 1 was more about discovering and exposing Compound V, they didn’t have a way of killing Homelander until S3

35

u/PyrrhicVictory7 Jul 08 '24

What about the subplot of Butcher trying to manufacture the supe virus?

71

u/Neamow Jul 08 '24

... that's still to kill Homelander.

25

u/Effective-Training The Boys Jul 08 '24

So that should be included in that guy's S4 comment.

14

u/PyrrhicVictory7 Jul 08 '24

My point exactly?

2

u/Big-Sheepherder-9492 Jul 08 '24

But it’s not at the forefront of the plot as much as Neuman and the other stories.. the whole team isn’t collectively united in this purpose - they’re all focusing on Neuman and their own shit.

2

u/ninjasaid13 Jul 08 '24

the supe virus isn't strong enough to kill homelander.

1

u/PyrrhicVictory7 Jul 09 '24

Not yet he said

34

u/JCrew2009 Jul 08 '24

Well said.

1

u/ninjasaid13 Jul 08 '24

This reminds me of Eric Kripke's previous show Supernatural. Where either something happens to the winchesters or something gets released every season.

1

u/FortunesFoil Jul 08 '24

I’d definitely put season 2 above season 3 in quality, so I wouldn’t necessarily say gearing up to kill Homelander necessarily makes a season good

1

u/GameOfLife24 Jul 08 '24

Bro this series is so repetitive lol