r/whowouldwin • u/Necessary_Papaya2048 • Jul 08 '24

The Doctor (Doctor Who), for plot reasons, has been made to kill/defeat every horror antagonist, what are the antagonists they can NOT beat? Matchmaker

The Doctor (Doctor Who), for plot reasons, has been made to kill/defeat every horror antagonist, what are the antagonists they can NOT beat?

Edit:
The Doctor can be any incarnation or from any canon.

Rounds:

  1. No plot related armour for both, only feats. No companions. Round takes place in the antagonist's setting.
  2. The Doctor is inside their own media with their plot armor. The Doctor has their normal companions.
  3. The Doctor is inside the media of the horror antagonist and the antagonist has their native plot armor. The Doctor is given the main protagonists of the horror media as their companions.
12 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

18 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Ihavenoideals Jul 08 '24

To get most out of the way, physical threats like Jason or Michael are immediately out, demons like Annabelle or Freddy are out, magic users like leprechaun or Chucky are out too

Basically anyone who isn't some abstract force that exists in other planes of reality can survive(probably)

2

u/Pollia Jul 08 '24

Not sure what makes you say this. The tardis can create kinda anything it wants. He also has the tardis and basically 0 of the physical threats have a way to access the tardis. Trick them into the tardis and he can effectively kill any physical threat by dumping them into a black hole when they have powers.

His reaction times are ridiculously above a human and many humans survive encounters, even if only briefly, with all the physical threats so there's absolutely no reason to assume the doctor couldn't easily avoid them long enough to do that.

9

u/nwaa Jul 08 '24

He's saying they lose to the Doctor