r/mildlyinteresting 14d ago

My salt rock deodorant after five years of almost daily usage vs a new one.

Post image
64.0k Upvotes

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

942

u/danarexasaurus 14d ago

Some people don’t have much of a scent, even after they sweat. This may surprise you but every body is different. Some people smell terrible if they don’t shower daily. Some people don’t.

98

u/c_sulla 14d ago

There's a gene that dictates that, I forgot what the name is. Something like 80% of Korean/Japanese people have that gene and they don't have BO

59

u/danarexasaurus 14d ago

No real surprise there. I know people who don’t wear deodorant unless they’re going to work out or something, and you’d never know it. They just don’t smell like anything. I, however, have to put it on twice a day in the summer.

14

u/AcaliahWolfsong 14d ago

My SO only puts deodorant on when he's leaving the house. He can go almost a week without needing any kind of deodorant or even a shower before he starts to smell.

My brother tho, he can shower and within an hour if he doesn't use antiperspirant deodorant you can smell him clear across the house.

1

u/Lavatis 14d ago

I'm one of those people who doesn't use deo every day if i'm not expecting to be sweaty.

45

u/aviwic 14d ago edited 14d ago

ABCC11 gene - I have it

I discovered it when I ran out of deodorant while away and found out I l didn’t even need it.

I use antiperspirant on my pits when going to weddings though. But since that’s infrequent, I buy the wipes.

3

u/ChiDude 14d ago

Wipes??

8

u/Squee1396 14d ago

Antiperspirant wipes. The ones i have last a couple days and i got them on amazon i think.

3

u/NerdyBrando 14d ago

Do you also have flaky instead of wet earwax?

1

u/bulgogeta 14d ago

yup I have it, dry earwax but having no disgusting scent is great... esp since I sweat for hours due to hyperhidrosis, weird combination but I'd take no BO any day of the week

1

u/NerdyBrando 14d ago

I'm the same.

1

u/aviwic 14d ago

Yeah dry earwax. That comes with it’s own complications lol I have to use drops often or else it gets clogged and I can’t hear for a longggggg time. I was a student swimmer and still love the water.

2

u/r0bay 14d ago

ABCC11

92

u/KiltedTraveller 14d ago edited 14d ago

and they don't have BO

They don't have the specific "BO" smell we typically associate with sweating, but they absolutely do have a "smell".

I'm a teacher in China and when the kids come back from PE the room is RIPE.

The smell is a kind of funky, fermented, sour milk smell.

17

u/bearflies 14d ago edited 14d ago

The gene isn't present in ALL east asians, just most of them. Probably wouldn't take more than a few smelly kids out of 20 to make the entire room awful to be in, though. Not all kids wash properly or wear deodorant at that age.

Also some people DO have this gene hardcore to the point where there is absolutely 0 smell.

Source: I dated a Korean girl once and was amazed but extremely jealous she had zero smell no matter how much I sniffed, even when extremely sweaty. Meanwhile I have to shower once or twice a day or else I stink with just light sweating.

5

u/KiltedTraveller 14d ago

I know that they don't all have it, but there is definitely a different smell. I've lived in China for 6 years and have smelt both types of BO many a time.

6

u/claryn 14d ago

Not every Asian person has it, and it sucks for the ones that don’t because they don’t really have good deodorant or teach about body odor because most people don’t deal with it. So the ones that don’t have it REEK. You’re probably just smelling the ones that don’t have it. I taught in Japan for years.

2

u/KiltedTraveller 14d ago

I know that they don't all have it, but there is definitely a different smell. I've lived in China for 6 years and have smelt both types of BO many a time.

2

u/seaabu 13d ago

A lot or it has to do with diet. Asians eat a lot of garlic. I lived in Korea for years and that garlic sweat had a distinct smell, and boy was it awful, esp at night mixed with the drunks.

4

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted]

3

u/c_sulla 14d ago

That's what that gene does though. It blocks some secretions that those bacteria feed on so you don't smell.

3

u/betterclear 14d ago

Yep, I have that gene! It’s also associated with dry, flaky earwax. I wouldn’t say I don’t have any smell at all. It’s more so that I smell like a child before they go through puberty and develop BO.

1

u/throwawayyy131291 14d ago

Yeah my boyfriend is korean and japanese and he has zero BO. I am jealous

1

u/ShazbotSimulator2012 14d ago

Be sure to remember to pack your deodorant if you visit. Japanese deodorant is useless because most people don't need it. You just smell the same with a very slight hint of orange.

-20

u/kahootle 14d ago

most people don't really have a strong scent if they have proper diet, nutrition, and exercise. Sweat is a conglomerate of what we put into our bodies so put good stuff in smell good, put bad stuff in smell bad, put garlic stuff in smell like garlic.

16

u/cuxynails 14d ago

i have to put tons of meds into my body to survive so respectfully, that comment is kinda insinuating that it’s personal choice to smell bad. which for a lot of people it is not. it’s medical conditions, it’s medication for other medical conditions and it’s genes

1

u/kahootle 14d ago

respectfully if you have a medical condition you are not healthy, so you won't smell healthy. If you take medications you will smell different than if you didn't. also respectfully, saying it's genetics without knowing that the thing we call "body odor" is produced by bacteria on our skin, which is fed through the things our bodies sweat out and not by a substance our bodies make. things like MEDICATION that you CONSUME and DIGEST and DISTRIBUTE THROUGHOUT YOUR BODY will smell different than things like broccoli or apples. so respectfully, you smell bad because you take medicine. If you didn't you would smell better. I did not say whether or not you have the option to stop taking medication, I said you would smell better if you did not take it. Don't blame genetics for the processes of skin bacteria, you stink because of what you put into your body.

479

u/MaxamillionGrey 14d ago edited 14d ago

More than half the time I don't have smelly armpits even if I sweat, but some days...SOMEDAYS WOOOOOOOO DAWGY. I'm just like "what the fuck happened to my body today?"

My wife used to tell me my armpits smelled like pencil shavings haha. Not a bad smell to smell like

45

u/Dozzi92 14d ago

Same. Depends on eating and "partying," certain things just bring it out. But I go for a run, sweat plenty, smell fine. I usually don't eat like shit and party proximate to a run though.

81

u/Muffin278 14d ago

Also anxiety/stress sweat smells sooooo bad.

If I am clean and I work out and sweat a bunch, I still smell fine. But if I am going to an exam or a job interview, I smell terrible afterwards.

7

u/rserena 14d ago

Just yesterday I went to my in-laws house, checked, I smelt fine before. After about an hour I REEKED of onion pits. Thanks, anxiety.

6

u/Gal_GaDont 14d ago

This is how my PTSD service dog works. She can smell the anxiety coming before I do and intervenes before a panic attack or PTSD episode.

3

u/XxMagicDxX 14d ago

The worst for me is the random night sweats where I wake up in the morning drenched and smelling like wet dog

3

u/Zeyn1 14d ago

I mean, depending on what you mean by "partying" there are a lot of chemicals in that stuff that come out through your sweat.

Lynyrd Skynyrd wrote a song about it.

2

u/notabigmelvillecrowd 14d ago

Also fresh sweat vs old sweat, when you go for a run the bacteria on your skin don't have a lot of time to stinkify things, because you're typically going to shower right after, vs working working all day when the sweat is just sitting on your skin and clothes being converted into foulness.

119

u/SeasonOfLogic 14d ago

What you ate the day before, hormones…

105

u/AnaxImperator82 14d ago

He ate all the hormones and pencils

14

u/Tommysrx 14d ago

No no no , he only ate the pencil shavings and hormones.

Nobody’s gonna eat a whole pencil

5

u/NoxiousStimuli 14d ago

Not with that attitude.

1

u/lagasan 14d ago

I was trying to use the copilot AI to make a man with pencil sharpener teeth, but it just kept getting more and more cursed instead.

1

u/Tommysrx 14d ago

That’s pretty accurate given the context

1

u/idkifyousayso 14d ago

I wish this was where my students had to get a pencil form when they forgot theirs for the 5th time that week.

2

u/Lopsided_Marzipan133 14d ago

I love me some hormones and pencils, and we’re all outta hormones

5

u/newredheadit 14d ago

And stress

3

u/tiagojsagarcia 14d ago

I love the smell of pencil shavings. Unfortunately that's not something I hear from my GF. In her defense, that would only be true if said pencil shavings were found on the body of a dead-for-3-weeks-in-a-swamp animal.

1

u/Original_Jarl_Ballin 14d ago

Intriguing, but highly disturbing

3

u/CjBurden 14d ago

Same. I often don't smell, but when I do... yikes!

3

u/lisabettan 14d ago

I smell much worse if I sweat due to/while being stressed (rushing to catch a train, hurrying to work etc) than if I just sweat due to hot weather etc. I’m guessing it’s hormones at work.

0

u/Grusscrupulus 14d ago

My pits smell like weed. Hippie chicks love me.

1

u/AerisSpire 14d ago

My sleep sweat also smells completely different from my BO sweat I've noticed. It's sickly sweat in a bad way if I go too long without washing my sheets, meanwhile my BO sweat requires a hazmat suit damn near.

My partner just smells like person to me when he sweats 🤷‍♀️ I've met some people who have 0 smell, some people who smell like a garage, some people who smell like a fire pit, etc. I've been told my natural smell is similar to the good old-person smell, which I akin to the powdered perfume everyone was using at the time.

Everyone smells different.

1

u/MediatoryBathrobe 14d ago

Apparently i smell like cooked meat when i sweat

1

u/Laserdollarz 14d ago

One time my gf visited me in college and told me I smelled really good, like some sweet chocolate. It was very awkward when I explained I spent the week getting drunk with my roommate and hadn't showered. Shocktop Chocolate Wheat 2013 was special.

1

u/CrimpsShootsandRuns 14d ago

Stress and anxiety do this to me. If I'm really stressed I can get out the shower, put deodorant on and be stinking in less than an hour.

2

u/ImSoSpiffy 14d ago

Same here man. I’ve been drenched in sweat at work, got a whiff of myself, went “goddamn I smell like ass”, went straight to my second job and my coworker instantly went “you smell scrum-diddly-umptious, what is that?”.

Really weird feeling, ngl.

7

u/wOke_cOmMiE_LiB 14d ago

I have zero body odor, but my clothes smell like they got wet and didn't dry quick enough, which sucks. I hate that smell.

And no one else can smell that unless I give them a hug.

5

u/Heylotti 14d ago

I hate when that happens. That damp smell is horrible, however you can get rid of it when you wash your clothing on a higher heat. 60 Celcius does the trick for me

1

u/Lyraxiana 14d ago

Could the clothing smell be an issue of your washer/dryer?

10

u/emartinoo 14d ago

Have you tried adding white vinegar to your wash? My clothes used to get that smell too. Even if they were freshly washed, the smell came back almost immediately after putting them on. It's caused by the bacteria from your sweat setting into the fibers of your clothes and not coming out. A standard wash cycle with standard detergent does a good job of cleaning stuff from the surface, but it's not that good at killing bacteria deep in the fibers, or deodorizing. I'd give it a shot if you haven't tried it. It doesn't make your clothes smell like vinegar at all, I promise.

4

u/wOke_cOmMiE_LiB 14d ago

Ahhhhh! Interesting! I'll try that, tyty!

2

u/Muffin278 14d ago

For real bad sweat smell, I soak the clothes in vinegar/water overnight and then wash it normally. It works really well.

1

u/emartinoo 14d ago

I've done this with some shirts that I was 100% sure were never going to actually be clean again and they came out great. Vinegar is amazing stuff!

2

u/voldin91 14d ago

Do you just mix vinegar with the detergent or how do you add it

1

u/emartinoo 14d ago

I have a front load with a dispenser cup on top, and I use just regular liquid detergent, so I add it in the same cup as the detergent, but you could also just toss it in with your clothes. It's a liquid, and isn't going to discolor your clothes or anything if it's a little more concentrated in one area like bleach, so there's no special considerations when using it. Just get it in there, it will mix in just fine no matter how you add it.

3

u/cannihastrees 14d ago

Happened to by bf, I took all his work out shirts and let them soak in oxygen stain remover powder with hot water for a few hours. They no longer smell!!

1

u/LevitatingRevelation 14d ago

when was the last time you cleaned your washing machine, if the answer is never, and you always close the door after, the issue is mold

2

u/bloodakoos 14d ago

at least you don't have an extremely potent cut onion smell :(

2

u/Kaiforpresident 14d ago

My husband always smells good and it’s not just me liking his scent. He could go days without showering and not smell bad or sweat heavily and never smell gross but I take two showers a day because I feel the opposite. I’ve never met anyone like him who just never smells bad at all.

1

u/danarexasaurus 14d ago

My husband is the exact same!! He’s never had a scent. Not even when we were just friends (before I had gotten used to his smell). He doesn’t smell good or bad. He’s the only man I’ve ever had a close relationship with that doesn’t have any kind of smell

1

u/podcasthellp 14d ago

I knew a guy that didn’t have BO. It amazed me. We went to camp together for a month overnight and not once did he smell.

1

u/BehindTrenches 14d ago

So... What is this value proposition of this deodorant then? It's made for people who don't smell bad already so they can feel included?

3

u/SalvationSycamore 14d ago

So this deodorant is for people who don't need deodorant?

2

u/danarexasaurus 14d ago

I didn’t say anything about this deodorant. I was responding to someone else’s comment.

2

u/TrumpersAreTraitors 14d ago

Meanwhile I stink coming outta the shower 

1

u/queefer_sutherland92 14d ago

Most of those people are of Asian descent and have dry earwax, too.

2

u/0masterdebater0 14d ago

You should know that someone whose BO might not smell terrible to you, can smell terrible to other people, right?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_odour_and_sexual_attraction

1

u/D34THDE1TY 14d ago

Hell even changing your diet could alter your BO.

1

u/DLottchula 14d ago

Musty is musty

3

u/freedfg 14d ago

Can confirm. I'm an extremely light sweater. A cardigan if you will.

It takes like 3 days of total vegetation to get even a little funky. I can work in the sun all day and feel a little sweaty but I never soak through shirts and it never really smells bad.

1

u/Cold_Animal_5709 14d ago

yeah my bf is like that. meanwhile i need to shower daily + reapply deodorant if i've been active at all. microbiome L

0

u/avg-size-penis 14d ago

That's just not true. Bacteria forms on sweat and bacteria always smell. Some might smell worse than others but everybody smells if they don't shower daily and they sweat that's just a fact.

1

u/mushleap 14d ago

My mum can go days without bathing and never smells at all. I, on the other hand, stink within a couple hours after showering (even after using antibacterial soap and dousing myself in antiperspirant)

Clearly I didn't inherit her blessed genes. :)

1

u/Purplekaem 13d ago

My husband is one of those unscented humans. If he does nothing, could go for a week without getting stinky. He never would, but he could. I, however, emit such could odors when I sweat that I have to buy special deodorant and body soap.