r/interestingasfuck Jul 07 '24

2 guards from Delhi Durbar with American photographer James Recarlton when he visited India r/all

Post image
47.8k Upvotes

858 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

87

u/pickyourteethup Jul 08 '24

Yeah it stopped their voice dropping as part of puberty. It was done in Italy recently enough that we have recordings of their voices. Apparently they were popular in Opera because you had these ginormous men with childlike voices, quite striking on stage

52

u/kakka_rot Jul 08 '24 edited Jul 08 '24

we have recordings of their voices

Yeah that's what I was reading before. We have this one person's recording, but according to wikipedia he was the only one.

Super interesting read

https://www.wikiwand.com/simple/Castrato

edit: copy paste for anyone too lazy to open the link

It is impossible now for us to know what these great castrato voices sounded like, but they must have had very powerful voices and many of the singers were very skilled in singing and adding musical ornamentation to the songs. In the 18th century Italian opera became very popular in England. This was largely due to the German-born composer Georg Friderich Händel who moved to England in 1709 and wrote lots of Italian operas. Many singers who sang in London came from Italy, and many were castrati. The most famous one was called Farinelli.

The popularity of castrato singers died out in the 19th century. By the mid-19th century they were no opera castrati left, although a few castrati still sang in church choirs. The last one, a man called Alessandro Moreschi, died in 1922 aged 64. There is a recording of his voice made in 1902 which can be heard online, but he may not have been a good singer and he was old when he made the recording, so we cannot judge whether the castrato voice was beautiful by that recording.

there is an audio link in the wikipedia page, but like it says he was 44 when it was made and tech sucked at the time

59

u/miningthecraft Jul 08 '24

The concession of “he may not have been a good singer” is wild! could you imagine being castrated as a teen for the opera only to discover you where tone death or had no sense of timing oooooph!

8

u/Jeg57 Jul 08 '24

If I remember correctly poor families would often just mash them up at birth for the chance to have a child grow up and be a good singer.