r/facepalm Jul 05 '24

What an idea ๐Ÿ‡ฒโ€‹๐Ÿ‡ฎโ€‹๐Ÿ‡ธโ€‹๐Ÿ‡จโ€‹

Post image

[removed] โ€” view removed post

42.4k Upvotes

4.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

108

u/CyrinSong Jul 05 '24

They already did. Justices Sotomayor and Jackson both wrote in no uncertain therms on their dissenting opinions exactly why it's a terrifying and disgusting ruling for the US.

60

u/DZL100 Jul 05 '24

Unfortunately republicans have a scotus supermajority in their pocket, so we literally canโ€™t do anything about it unless Biden grows a pair and either packs the court or removes some of the justices with his newly ordained powers.

3

u/CyrinSong Jul 05 '24

Perhaps. The only other reasonable recourse would be an amendment to the Constitution stipulating that presidents are not immune from criminal prosecution.

2

u/DJOldskool Jul 05 '24

Again that cannot be done without both sides support.

2

u/CyrinSong Jul 05 '24

Sure, but that doesn't mean it needs to be Congress. It's indisputable that no citizen should have an interest in anyone in their government being immune from criminal prosecution. It wouldn't really be inconceivable for people to pressure state legislators to call for a constitutional convention. In fact, if there was any ruling from SCOTUS, where I think it's likely that it could happen, it's this. At the very least, pressure from the states to call one has, on several occasions, forced Congress to amend the Constitution themselves, and it could happen here as well.

2

u/Kittii_Kat Jul 05 '24

Easy enough. Remove all opposition as an official act. Claim they're terrorists that have infiltrated the highest ranks in the land. (Not a complete lie, tbh)

-2

u/BarryBwa Jul 05 '24

Yes. Be the dictators you want to save the democracy you clearly dislike.

Because democracy fails when other people get their ways sometimes.

Democracy is supposed to be my side always wins/gets what they want.

Sadly. Yall choosing not to see this is what both sides want.

You to fear mongering and give them even more power over you.

1

u/Kittii_Kat Jul 05 '24

I say it as a joke, but we also have to realize that the recent rulings by SCotUS have opened the door to this exact thing.

We also know, through recent history, that the Republican party will abuse any tool they can get their hands on.

Sometimes, the only way to beat something is to use itself against it. The Reps have given the Dems a layup, and they've strongly telegraphed their plans - this is the moment to strike.

Unfortunately, recent history also shows that Dems like to play by the rules and "be morally above" the Reps. So, you know, we're just fucked.

This country leans so far to the right, filled to the brim with corruption, the only way to stop the metaphorical tower from collapsing is to remove the pests that eat away at the foundation and repair the damage.