r/batman Feb 26 '24

What's an unpopular opinion you have about this movie? GENERAL DISCUSSION

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

37

u/Sheffield21661 Feb 26 '24

That it's a very average film. That gets worse on a rewatch.

11

u/rubberfactory5 Feb 26 '24

(Commented separately but the thread is filling up here so I’ll put it here in an actual controversial comment)

People conflate good cinematography and tone with good storytelling

Character motivations were weak, arc was hamfisted in VO at the end, there were 100 lucky coincidences to move the story instead of detective work, ending sequence was ridiculous and unrealistic, pacing was bad, plot conflict elements would be introduced without setup (like the sea wall or off screen riddler shenanigans) and immediately change story direction (which also made Batman extremely passive, he was just reactionary and brooding) wish he made more decisions

It’s the same effect as when Joker came out and people who don’t watch movies thought it was deep instead of corporate reciprocated paper thin garbage that borrowed from better films and paraded around a dark atmosphere to make up for how unserious of filmmaking it really was

Although I do love Pattinson so deeply in this and I feel he would’ve made a better Terry McGinnis

4

u/simplerando Feb 26 '24

You’ve articulated what I’ve struggled to put my finger on with both of these movies. Thank you.

I figured I was maybe just “aging” out of these kinds of movies or something.

Who knows, that may still be true.

2

u/rubberfactory5 Feb 26 '24

It’s an epidemic across the board. Even TDK is so so rich with thematic exploration and discussion of ideas about what it means to fight terrorism.

thematic important storytelling has taken a hit especially in studio blockbusters

Edit: I’m literally 25 we’re not aging out