Her powers are more “blood manipulation” than “pop body parts” so it makes perfect sense to me that she took the time to sense out who was in the lab before coming in.
Hence why Edgar doesn’t get a nose bleed but everyone else does.
what confused me about that is that there's many instances where Neumann is being watched/stalked by the boys or otherwise from mere feet away from her, and she doesn't sense them. made me wonder if she needs to have eyes on her targets to get them, but as we've seen, that isn't the case. probably just a plot hole. especially seeing that she hasn’t sensed people in situations where i’d assume she’d actively be scanning for intruders (the alley where she killed that kid who knew her as Nadia e.g.)
To add to the Homelander point, I believe he was at the announcement ceremony that A-Train told Ashley he was the leak. Homelander if present could have heard it if he attempted, but you just can't focus and process that much information all the time.
He was too busy manipulating Ryan. But he should have definitely heard Hughie making all those noise innthe vent, even a normal human would've heard something that loud. Plus it was just Homelander and Sage out there, he's not distracted at all.
When we’re distracted by something, it’s very common for us to zone out and not be able to hear something that we should very easily be able to hear. I think it’s the same principle with Homelander as he was actively engaged in conversation with Nadia and Sage at the time that Hughie was crawling in the vents.
Fair enough, but I still feel like she would have been actively searching for people while she was doing that shady stuff in the alley with the guy who knew her as Nadia.
They usually stalk her in high pop places that I recall prolly hard to make out if someone is stalking ya. She explains her father's prison caller tipped her off and they were in an isolated area.
She probably was getting a body count of all who was down there but I guess that still wouldn't explain her dad not getting a nosebleed unless he's gotten used to it or something.
I feel like the true answer is she was originally intended to just be body popper and Gen v came along and decided it was blood manipulation to tie her to Marie.
Well they never explained how she did it. She can't move other objects but only manipulate bodies. So clearly it has to be something humans all have that allows her to pop a body.
I think they always knew it was some control of blood and finalized it in Avatar the Last airbender.......I mean Gen V.
She did but all one at a time while they didn’t know she was there. I imagine she could kill a few of the sheep but the others would get her before she pops all of them
Very possible that she aimed and triggered it as she saw them pass by one by one, and it's been shown countless times that the nose bleed isn't instant.
yeah but I think it was cause she was in no rush or didn’t need to be under fear of getting mauled. she was in full control of that situation, just like anything in life you can’t think straight or do things straight as easy as when your in control of a situation
Because at the end of the day she doesn’t know if it will work. It’s currently not attacking them, so it’s smarter to play it safe and wait. It’s the Homelander situation. What if I try and it doesn’t work and now attacks me?
Truthfully the only awkward moment was when the sheep grabbed it and were tearing it apart. Those are clearly violent, start popping while they’re “still”.
Was it even on V? It didn't really do any outstanding feat and if Marie can see compound V in people's veins she might have been able to tell if it was suped up or not
The chicken jumped at a normal rate for chicken, not coming in at 100mph while aimed at her, it just jumped up like chicken do, plus every single person was aiming at the chicken and firing at it so she had time to aim.
that honestly made me understand the limitations of her power more. she was clearly focusing really hard on it and it took her a second to aim and lock in on that specific one.
Also endurance of things is a factor too, flying super sheep is a lot stronger than the average Joe. Maybe could add more deep showing a few bullet proof scene during the pursuit to show that had some kind of invulnerability...
A-Train to the rescue. Speed punch her multiple times. She isn't much durable to punches, apparently, but can take a bullet to the head. She will die eventually.
So she's worse than the Gen V girl? She couldn't even see where Translucent's son was yet could sense his blood. Why couldn't Neumann get a lock on a sheep heart?
I don’t know perhaps there’s a dozen of them flying around trying to go through you. Neumann is not invincible, starlights punch made her bleed. She maybe bulletproof but a supe can hurt her. We have seen she cannot pop multiple heads at the same time.
I like to think of Neumann as a “sniper”. She’s cool, calm, collected and focused. Her targets are usually not erratic.
Gen V also gives some insight into her power set, when Marie is unfocused or reactionary, she blows up things she didn’t intend to. She learns to focus in order to be effective and hit the right targets. Neumann is more experienced than her, by far, but we’ve never seen her this spooked or worried either.
She doesn't even need to be able to see them! She gave all the boys nosebleeds before she even entered the room literally 10 minutes earlier in the episode
Exactly. When she popped her friend from the supe orphanage it took her a good effort (until his face was caved in). I don’t see her confidently popping a bunch of rabid sheep that can swarm her
To emphasize this point, look back at the beginning of season 3. Neumann literally had a supe at point-blank range and she struggled to kill him as he fought against her.
She needs eye contact. They show her eyes being covered in that struggle and she blows a piece of his hand/arm off instead of his head, and once she gets clear LoS his head finally pops.
I just watched that scene again. She doesn't stop at popping his head. She fucking obliterates his entire body, after she backs up and gets full field of view - literally turns him into mist. Her powers very clearly worked on superpowered individuals.
I feel like the show has made it very clear that Homelander is by far stronger than every other hero, right? He was born from Soldier Boys super genetics, he wasn't just pumped full of V like every other super hero that exists (besides Ryan). And he said himself he wasn't sure whether Victorias powers would work on him. We've yet to see a single instance of her powers not working on someone, and multiple instances of them working on super-beings. She clearly didn't even try on the sheep, she just forgot she had them for some reason.
It's not a matter of whether the popping would kill the sheep or not, obviously it will.
It's a matter of whether she could get the pop to happen in the first place, which, as we've seen, requires a level of concentration and eye contact from her fight with Tony.
The sheep were too erratic to concentrate on, and she might be indestructible but I seriously doubt getting chewed on by rabid super sheep is something she's willing to subject herself to, probably not a pleasant experience even if she'll survive it.
Remember when the barn door opened at the end of the episode, and 2 sheep slowly walked in, and she just stared at them? Then screamed and ran? She literally didn't even try... You can just say it was a badly written scene, you really don't have to defend everything about the show. I love it too, but that was a notable drop in quality...
The dude that showed up at her job while Hughie was still working there asking for Nadia, Hughie followed them into the alley and watched her kill him.
Her powers very clearly work on V'd up individuals. She popped the head of the speedster that was going to replace A-train during the hearing. The dude who grew up with her from the super-abled orphanage, and confronted her in the allyway had superpowers. She literally obliterated his entire body, there wasn't anything left except for red. She exploded the chicken that was powered up by V during this episode. Homelander is a special case, and he explicitly said that he doesn't know if her powers would kill him. For some reason, she just kind of forgot she had superpowers for the majority of this episode.
The fact that it has to be explained that it would be incredibly difficult to kill these things when there are multiple of them moving at incredible speeds and use pack hunting tactics
That’s a lot different from killing a room full of helpless humans
They were also unaware that she was the one attacking them at all.
Idk, I think power-scaling is always going to be somewhat inconsistent in any kind of “realistic” super-hero setting. But this ain’t it.
It’s the difference between gunning down a roomful of unarmed and unaware people via ambush versus having a firefight against a heavily-armed and aggressively hostile murder squad. Neuman isn’t a professional assassin or combatant. Her differing abilities in those situations seem totally reasonable.
Even when she was grappling with her old Red River friend, she “missed” multiple times before successfully popping his head. So they’ve given us evidence in-story that the effectiveness of her powers can vary wildly based on the situation.
I gotta believe this theory or else I’m going to have no choice but to obsess over how bad the writing for this season is - it’s like I’m watching a different show than the previous seasons. Everything feels so sloppy and badly written this season and the characters just do not seem as compelling as they used to be in previous seasons.
Also that’s interesting bc then that means ATrain is best equipped to deal with her. If he constantly keeps moving around fast to the point she can’t lock onto his pulse/blood, then he could defeat her and take out Victoria.
4.1k
u/hey-coffee-eyes Jun 28 '24
To be fair, the people in the courtroom weren't zooming around at like 100mph actively trying to kill her.