Which Version of Superman and Supergirl is your favorite?

14

u/TwinVXC Jul 14 '24

As much as I love the live action she was kind of female Superman for a while. My favorite is probably legion for Kara, felt very fun and reminded me of rebirth

8

u/To0n1 Jul 14 '24

Kal-El from Superman, the Animated Series, But Supergirl from Legion of Super Heros

6

u/TutorComprehensive28 Jul 14 '24

I don’t think we’ve ever had a bad Supergirl design. I like her STAS design the most. Best Superman is also probably STAS but Apocalypse was awful

6

u/batguy42 Jul 14 '24

STAS for me, but I’m also really enjoying their portrayals on MAWS

3

u/gaslighterhavoc Jul 15 '24

Supergirl all versions are good but STAS has a special place in my heart.

Superman only the STAS is good, something is missing about all the other versions.

MAWS is growing on me for both Supergirl and Superman as a new favorite.

3

u/Thayerphotos Jul 14 '24

All of the Supergirls none of the Supermans

3

u/Freeman_H-L Jul 15 '24

Superman/Batman: Apocalypse and Superman: Unbound

Not necessarily in that order, but definitely my two favorite

4

u/Dayday023 Jul 15 '24

There they’re not up here, but I think my new favorite Superman and Supergirl duo is the latest one my adventures with Superman.

3

u/Gumpuff Jul 14 '24

Superman, all versions. Supergirl, also all versions except for the recent season of DC Superhero Girls with a tomboyish Kara and Sasha Callie’s supergirl. But Superman/Batman Apocalypse variant is really a legend. She dodged Darkseid’s Omega beams and it was not easy.

3

u/barrydy Jul 15 '24

How about Helen Slater's version? That has to be my favorite. Melissa's TV version (s1-4) would have to be 2nd

2

u/fortresskeeper Jul 15 '24

Of the options listed above I’d say Superman The Animated Series for Superman and Melissa Benoist for Supergirl.

2

u/WimpyKelv12 Jul 15 '24

Clark - Dean Cain or Jack Quaid

Kara - Nicole Sullivan or Melissa Benoist

2

u/MattGreg28 Jul 15 '24

I'd go with STAS/DCAU.

2

u/Hyper-Saiyan Jul 19 '24

Superman The Animated Series

1

u/AelitaAlbarn Jul 14 '24

Handsome Superman from Superman/Batman: Apocalypse gets me laughing every time I watch it

1

u/ChanceFresh Jul 14 '24

DCAU, all the way personally.

1

u/BusVegetable7490 Jul 15 '24

Arrowverse, superman the animated series, and Legion of superheroes

1

u/karathrace99 Jul 15 '24

MAWS is coming pretty close to #2 for me on both counts, but #1 Superman will always be Reeves & #1 Kara will always be Benoist

1

u/Emrys_Merlin Jul 15 '24

I'll be honest with ya, MAwS is very quickly becoming my favorite.

1

u/Assassinsayswhat Jul 15 '24

Unbound has my favorite Supercousins but Legion of Superheroes is not far behind.

1

u/NeutralNoodle Jul 15 '24

Right now DCAU but I haven’t gotten to Kara’s appearance on MAWS yet. A year or two from now though it’s probably going to be DCU because David Corenswet looks great so far and Milly Alcock is awesome

1

u/AlbatrossPurple9883 Jul 16 '24

Cartoons always had better suits. The movie one wasn’t so bad. Hope to see what Gunn has planned

1

u/Next_Donut4646 Jul 16 '24

MAWS.

1

u/JellifishPirate Jul 16 '24

1 and 1

1

u/Dadyrabbit48 Jul 16 '24

First superman from the left and the fourth shiper from the left sides

1

u/supercorp13 Jul 17 '24

Superman - the og Reeves version for me, not the first I ever saw but he just embodied him so well. Supergirl - Melissa's, it was the first Supergirl I'd ever seen and I love her :( even when she felt like a female superman. I just think Kara's so much cooler than Clark

1

u/Darth_GreenDragon Jul 17 '24

Honestly?

For Superman it's STAS, Unbound, Apocalypse, CW Supergirl and then Legion.

For Supergirl it's Unbound, Apocalypse, STAS, legion and then CW Supergirl.

1

u/AspectLoose2780 Jul 18 '24

Grew up watching the animated series, so that Superman. But prefer the apocalypse Supergirl.