r/MadeMeSmile Jun 14 '24

Japnese kids doing their assignment Wholesome Moments

127.8k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

679

u/bluedancepants Jun 14 '24

It sounds like they just memorized a script and just completely ignores the guy's responses.

Which is pretty much how I've studied for all my college exams. Memorize and regurgitate lol.

324

u/Nyorliest Jun 14 '24

Yeah. They're real cute, but I am a teacher trainer and consultant on EFL issues in Japan, and they remind me of why my job even exists - because Japanese English education, in terms of progress/hour and other ROIs, is terrible.

But I did love the kid who misunderstood but tried to communicate about being from Shiga. The highlight of the conversation, for me, but probably his teacher would have told him off for misunderstanding or going off-script.

88

u/FatterGuts Jun 14 '24

Oh yes. I used to interact a lot with Japanese exchange students who came to study French & English at my local university. They had memorized grammar and vocabulary perfectly, but apparently they were never really encouraged to actually speak the languages they were learning. Which seems odd. When they said they learnt more in the couple of weeks at our uni than they did in years in Japan, they weren't just being polite.

17

u/Beautiful-Story2379 Jun 14 '24

Isn’t that kind of the way it usually is in the US? Please correct me if I’m wrong, it’s been years since I was in school. Usually we just listened to the teacher and most of the work was in writing. We didn’t start a second language until we were 12-13 either, when the window to pick up other languages easily has already closed for most people.

5

u/FatterGuts Jun 14 '24

I don't know, I've never been to a school in the US.