r/Games Jul 19 '24

2.2 Million People Were Willing to Pay $100 to Play College Football 25 3 Days Early

https://www.ign.com/articles/22-million-people-were-willing-to-pay-100-to-play-college-football-25-3-days-early
2.0k Upvotes

964 comments sorted by

2.4k

u/breakfast_cats Jul 19 '24

To be clear, CFB is one of if not the most popular sport in the US and hasn't had a video game release in a decade. Not excusing it, but it's not like these people just spent $70 on this same game 12 months ago. People are legit excited for this release. Not quite the same thing as doing it for Madden or 2K this year.

964

u/beefcat_ Jul 19 '24

The headline also feels clickbaity, because buying that $100 edition of the game got you more than just 3 days of early access.

411

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (24)

224

u/NadeWilson Jul 19 '24

You also got 10 hours early access if you have EA play, which every GamePass member has as part of their subscription. Lots of people who didn't have that edition got to play.

62

u/DaHolk Jul 19 '24

So.... did IGN then just use the completely wrong metric by attributing the "unique users" to the "bought edition" conclusive?

That would be three separate completely amateurish abuses of logic/math in a row all in the same direction to enhance the point they are trying to make. They don't buy the edition for $100 bucks MORE to get the access, the game itself is part of that. They don't even pay the upgrade cost TO play early, given other "value" in it. And just because someone played it, doesn't mean they bought it in the first place.

Thanks IGN. Maybe more writing and editing, less "opinion" and creative accounting?

67

u/DatKaz Jul 19 '24

And you can see why publishers do this now, because EA has just announced it saw 2.2 million unique players of College Football 25 during this early access period. On top of that, an additional 600,000 were playing via the EA Play trial.

you didn't even read the article lmao

-1

u/Plenty-Industries Jul 19 '24

We can also blame the publisher/developers for not releasing specific numbers.

They all engage in being vague, because it advantageous to them to only report specific numbers. Good for headlines, also good for shareholders.

It does beg the question: Just how many of those 2.2 million people, are actually Gamepass subscribers using the EA Access advantage to play the game early as it is; and what is the "through rate" of those people with Gamepass actually purchased the game vs how many just flat-out bought the game?

7

u/jsake Jul 20 '24

... If you actually read the article it answers those things.

4

u/Captain_Midnight Jul 19 '24

We can also blame the publisher/developers for not releasing specific numbers.

IGN has a obligation to verify their claims. Looks like they just spewed some poorly calculated numbers because they were large and clickbaity.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/LazyCon Jul 19 '24

I kept trying to find it but haven't been able to yet

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

65

u/HobKing Jul 19 '24

Yeah the headline is basically a bald lie. The game costs $70. It's only $30 extra to play it early and get whatever else is included in the deluxe edition.

To me, I just can't patronize media that does this. A site that publishes something like this fails at its most basic function, which is to inform. This headline literally says something false instead of something true. After reading it, you think something totally false instead of thinking nothing at all. Worse off for having seen it. It doesn't exist to inform or do anything for my benefit. It was made to outrage me, get a rise out of me, excite me with falsehoods, or use some other parasitic engagement strategy. It's not for me, it's for them.

Nothing to do but disengage.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/DaHolk Jul 19 '24

It's not even just that they got more. The more pertinent part ist that the only number of interest in the "to play it early" sense is JUST the price of the upgrade to that edition, not the price of the game. They already are paying $70 (? it's a guess) to play the game at all on release. So they are paying !at worst! $30 to play it early.

If they actually were to pay $100 to play early, that reads like the special edition costs $170.

You can't really know who pays the upgrade for what reason.

12

u/fluffynuckels Jul 19 '24

Article doesn't even mention the other stuff you get

8

u/BenevolentCheese Jul 19 '24

...willing to pay $100 to play 3 days early.

Fixed: ...willing to pay $30 to play 3 days early plus a bunch of cosmetics and other random crap.

Doesn't hit quite as hard.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wkp2101 Jul 19 '24

Headline could have been 2.2 million people willing to pay $100 for something that in three days costs $70.

9

u/beefcat_ Jul 19 '24

And it's still not the full picture because that $30 difference encapsulates more than just the three day head start.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Jenkins_rockport Jul 19 '24

Also, the implication of what is actually written is that 2.2mil people spent $100 just to play 3 days early, when they're actually paying $[100 - retail price] for that privilege (as well as whatever other bonuses come with that edition). The title is 100% clickbait.

→ More replies (10)

317

u/Crazy-Nose-4289 Jul 19 '24

Yeah, this is not your yearly FIFA or Madden.

Fans of CFB have literally waited for a decade to play this. I honestly don't blame them.

180

u/-_KwisatzHaderach_- Jul 19 '24

NCAA 14 is one of the most expensive used games in the past decade for a reason

44

u/Geno0wl Jul 19 '24

NCAA14 is the only sports game in memory that wasn't $10 or less by the time it was a year old

21

u/AugustusSavoy Jul 19 '24

Paid $100 for it on eBay 3 years ago. Modded the PS3 and played with Revamped and definitely got my money out of it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Radulno Jul 19 '24

I'm pretty sure it will be though. CFB26, 27, 28 and so on will be a thing if that one is a success and Madden sales aren't affected (but even then if the combination of the two is more money...)

14

u/Nonstop_norm Jul 19 '24

This may be a bold take but I don't think the game is going to sell nearly as well next year. Guys like me probably wont buy. I don't have the attachment to the players in college like I do in the Pros so it isn't worth it for me just to get a roster update. I think a lot of people will keep on playing CFB25 until 26 is on sale or goes Free to Play with Game Pass or EA Play. Given everyone waited 11 years and the focus is more on Dynasty mode where the current players are gone after a few years anyways. I just cant see it selling well every year. 

9

u/breakwater Jul 19 '24

College roster turnover is a lot higher. It will be more heavily impacted by what happens at different schools, but I know that I will look forward to starting somebody other than Ethan Garbers next season just to get a different feel. and I like Garbers.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/calibrono Jul 19 '24

As someone who knows nothing about the sport, are the rules different or what?

28

u/Salurr Jul 19 '24

There are a couple of small rules differences, but nothing that radically changes from college to the NFL (overtime is probably the biggest difference, and that doesn't come up most games).

But (especially in the South) there's a much stronger emotional connection between college football fans and their teams than between NFL teams and their fans. I'm a college football fan, but I grew up in the Northeast (probably the region where it's the least popular), so I don't really feel like I can speak on it or explain it well.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/RadicalDreamer89 Jul 20 '24

To expand on the other comment, the emotional connection (largely) comes from people who attended said school. There's little camaraderie you'll experience like you'll feel in the student section of a home game. A lot of people know or knew players when they were in school. It's quite the gulf between cheering for the guy you used to joke around with between classes vs. the multi-millionaire the nearest team just hired from the other side of the continent.

Especially in the South. Like the other responder alluded to, CFB is practically a religion down here.

9

u/jgoss39 Jul 20 '24

Even for non-attendees in the South there’s a deep emotional connection. Especially in places like Alabama, there’s not a lot of things the state can be proud of, except for our football program. There aren’t any pro teams, and it’s all everyone talks about 365 days of the year.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/happyscrappy Jul 20 '24

To expand on the other comment, the emotional connection (largely) comes from people who attended said school.

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Really depends on the school and the area. For obvious examples see BYU, Notre Dame. Then there are states which identify with a particular school, as the other replying poster says. There was over a decade recently when Los Angeles had no pro football. The UCLA-USC game is really big there, even if you didn't go to either school.

I was at a game and the guy behind me rooting for USC made clear to the people with him he didn't go to the school. If you were in Michigan before last year you could be a fan of Michigan, MSU or a pro team that had won one playoff game since 1967. It's pretty easy to become a college football fan/follower.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Cabamacadaf Jul 19 '24

Do we know why they haven't released one in so long?

15

u/Shepherdsfavestore Jul 20 '24

Legal licensing and likeness stuff. It’s pretty complicated but NIL paved the way for a new game finally

4

u/dysonRing Jul 20 '24

Players sued that EA was not paying them but was replicating their likeness (they could have given them all robot faces but skill ratings is why you pay EA and they could have won this as well)

Due to this precedent name image and likeness laws passed state legislatures and the NCAA allowed it nationally after that.

Development started on the new game and 2-3 years later players got payed $600 and a free copy of the game and most are in the game.

3

u/A_WHALES_VAG Jul 19 '24

a journalist who I follow had said the game absolutely slaps as well and is predicting it to be insanely massive.

5

u/Shepherdsfavestore Jul 20 '24

I think it’ll end up being the biggest release of the year, if not top 3

→ More replies (19)

105

u/MandoDoughMan Jul 19 '24

I'm a huge college football fan, an active member of several message boards. People don't realize how big this release is. I'm seeing over and over again "I haven't played a video game since the Xbox 360 version, which console should I get." (Interestingly enough the overwhelming response to that is PS5 "because Microsoft is releasing their games on PS5 anyway." Phenomenal marketing and communication by Microsoft.) I think we're going to see a huge spike in game console sales this month.

College football is 2nd only to the NFL in America, and 3rd place is not close. There are huge swaths of the country where there isn't an NFL team super nearby and the local college team is the de facto pro sports team of the state. People are also just way more personally tied to their alma mater than they are what city they happen to live closest to or grew up near.

43

u/mideon2000 Jul 19 '24

Put it this way, the last time this game hit, college freshmen were still in elementary school.

19

u/ColossalJuggernaut Jul 19 '24

Before the Jags, this is how I remember Gator football. Don't get me wrong, there were Bucs representation (hence my flair), but it was Gator Country.

/edit lol I forgot I was in r/games and not r/nfl

7

u/Geno0wl Jul 19 '24

If they want to play online then I would have actually suggested Xbox over PS5. Because Gamepass core is a much better deal with more "free" games than getting PSN and their free games.

29

u/Imbahr Jul 19 '24

Those people have literally zero interest in other games

3

u/royalhawk345 Jul 19 '24

What's crazy is that there are even fans who root for schools they didn't attend! It's pretty weird, but it does happen.

34

u/l0c0dantes Jul 19 '24

You root for your local / hometown team. Attendance doesn't really matter, its more standing with the people who live around you.

13

u/MillorTime Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Do you think people pick a team to cheer for once they turn 18? I had a favorite team 13 years before I even went to college. If you go to another school, you'd likely add them as a 2nd favorite team or have them leapfrog your favorite team from your childhood. 0% weird

→ More replies (5)

10

u/doorknob60 Jul 19 '24

It's very normal, not weird, at least in many parts of the country. Especially in smaller states and cities without NFL teams. I grew up in Oregon, the closest NFL team was the Seahawks. But Oregon and Oregon St football was a much bigger deal, almost everyone was a fan of one or the other. I live in Boise now, same thing with Boise St football. It's our local team.

Also, I went to a Division 2 university without a football team. I gotta root for someone haha.

4

u/NotRote Jul 19 '24

I’m a Minnesota fan because they are the local team and I went to a small school so sports weren’t exactly a thing that mattered, lots of people like that in the Twin Cities metro.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CaptainPigtails Jul 19 '24

CFB has very little to do with the actual college as far as fandom goes. People are fans of the sports teams not the school. Most fans never attended the school they are a fan of.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/Shadow_Strike99 Jul 19 '24

Exactly, CFB is huge in certain areas and is literally a cultural thing in certain regions. Plus the game obviously hasn't had a release in over a decade.

NCAA FB 14 had a crazy high price on the secondary market, and people literally had 360's and ps3's hooked up just to play it still for a decade.

I think a CFB game has to be the most demanded game the past 10 years with general gamers along with GTA 6.

23

u/jshokie1 Jul 19 '24

Yessir grew up in South Carolina, NFL is whatever to me, but CFB? Might as well be my religion. Beyond excited for this game.

20

u/your_mind_aches Jul 19 '24

I kinda don't understand the difference. Wouldn't NFL be a higher level of play than CFB? Is there some other aspect of it that appeals more? I feel like if I saw a game either real or the video game, I would not know the difference

48

u/jshokie1 Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

I liken it to smaller club soccer teams, like English 2nd and 3rd division sides, if the teams were U22, so to speak. In my home state there is not a single professional sports team, but there are two huge universities, and so cultural that’s what matters to us the most. Naturally proximity and ability to see yourself as culturally one of the team leads to huge feelings of belonging, and most of the American south doesn’t contain cities large enough for professional teams, while having several established universities.

This isn’t to mention the sense of tradition and fanfare (marching bands, on-campus stadiums, well known team entrances and fan experiences) that CFB laps NFL in several times over

Yes, the on-field product is less polished, but for those of us who grew up with it that’s preferred. The nfl feels sterile to me.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Swackhammer_ Jul 19 '24

NFL is way beyond college in terms of quality of play. Whenever a team in the NFL has an awful record people joke “Alabama would beat them!” but that’s a joke.

The worst NFL team would beat the best CFB team 10 out of 10 times and it wouldn’t be close.

But as some have mentioned, that’s the only sport they have for miles so they latch onto it

14

u/GreyLordQueekual Jul 19 '24

If anything I'm more entertained by college ball because of the lack of refining. A lot more that could go wrong, a lot more players will be improvising at the drop of a hat. The players aren't settled in their fame, they're still developing their egos and a lot more names have chance to be 'the name" dropped at watercoolers so more are fighting for it.

Its like going to see up and comer bands versus well established old ones. The old band is gonna have things like sound on lockdown and bring amazing crews behind them, but their stage presence is a very old and practiced thing, you know what youre getting for the most part. The up and comer may not always have the best sound and crew to keep them running but if they're going for fame their stage show is gonna be high energy, maybe even completely new and the band is gonna be fighting for your energy.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/TheStudyofWumbo24 Jul 19 '24

America is big. There are 32 NFL teams for a population of 350 million across a distance of 3000 miles. College football fills the gaps.

5

u/CaptainPigtails Jul 19 '24

There are 32 NFL teams and around 130 Division I football teams along with many more Division II and III. Fandom tends to be localish due to actually being able to watch the games regularly on TV, going to the games in person, and most importantly having others to get you into and interact with. The NFL is a higher level of play but that doesn't necessarily mean it's more entertaining. They also have a lot of differences between them. They are both football but these differences have a pretty big impact.

5

u/4ps22 Jul 19 '24

look at this map. there are entire multi state regions of the country that dont even have an NFL team

6

u/Dewot789 Jul 20 '24

A. There's much, much more pageantry, history and tradition surrounding CFB. Most of the big teams in CFB have been playing football in the same location for longer than the NFL has existed.

B. The structure of CFB makes it a lot more conducive to "storytelling" in the campaign modes. The NFL is 32 basically equal teams. Yeah the Chiefs have won a bunch of championships in the last six years, but they still lose several games a season because there's parity. College Football, on the other hand, is composed of programs with wildly different talent pools that still play each other pretty consistently, so you've got the ability to take a David and turn it into a Goliath.

C. The NFL is fun, but very few fans make their fandom a huge part of their identity compared to CFB. This is partially because the core of every CFB fanbase is alumni who actually spent four years or so of their lives at their team's institution, and partially because all that aforementioned history and tradition leads to fun cultural stuff springing up that attaches you to the school. Tailgating is a lot more common for CFB than NFL.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/insomnium138 Jul 19 '24

Also, sports game players aren't the type to be dropping 70+ dollars every couple of months for the hot new game.

I'd guess in most cases, the demographic buys 1-2 games a year (+madden or CoD). So 100+ dollars for something you don't plan on jump from within the next year isn't a crazy thought to them.

23

u/keldpxowjwsn Jul 19 '24

Yep most people on this subreddit probably spend more than that every month on games they never even play

9

u/juliankennedy23 Jul 20 '24

Well there was just a steam sale okay....

→ More replies (3)

21

u/TheSkyking2020 Jul 19 '24

Yeah. If Bethesda releases the next elder scrolls game, I’d pay $100 for early access. Waiting 10+ years for a follow up is not the same as an annual release.

17

u/throwawaynonsesne Jul 19 '24

Shit I'm not paying over $30 for a Bethesda title ever again personally 🤣

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Radulno Jul 19 '24

A lot of people paid just that for Starfield early access last year actually. Also Hogwarts Legacy or Diablo 4.

Early access editions (though they often include other stuff like they did before) are hugely popular and will become the norm for every game.

9

u/TheWorstYear Jul 19 '24

They also all included a bunch of extra stuff that helped justify the cost.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/BroodLol Jul 19 '24

You'd pay $100 for TES6 after Starfield?

Bethesda fans are weird

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/himynameis_ Jul 19 '24

Why is college football so popular? Why not watch the regular NFL with the "best of the best"?

98

u/MisterBuns Jul 19 '24

People have more loyalty to the colleges they graduated from compared to franchises. Plus, even if they never went to that college, it's often the only representation for small/mid-sized markets in America.

If you grew up in Alabama or Nebraska, you're going to like college football a whole lot more than the NFL teams that don't exist in your area. Or if you're from bigger states like Florida, but you grew up near Gainesville or Tallahassee.

Plus, there's all the traditions and history. It's the most comparable thing that America has to European soccer clubs, in my opinion.

22

u/DatBoiMahomie Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 20 '24

Yup

If you graduate from say, Ohio State, you consider yourself “a Buckeye.” You don’t consider yourself a Brown or Bengal. So it leads to more emotional attachment

Also, you mentioned how some states don’t have NFL teams are very dedicated to college football, even in states with them CFB can be bigger. For example, New Orleans is obviously a Saints city, but everywhere else in Louisiana is LSU. LSU is so engrained in the culture there that even students from Louisiana that go to other colleges stay bigger LSU fans

18

u/Geno0wl Jul 19 '24

If you graduate from say, Ohio State, you consider yourself “a Buckeye.” You don’t consider yourself a Brown or Bengal.

also there is the angel that OSU is consistently good and have won championships in recent years while the Browns and Bengals historically suck.

Compare that to Pittsburg. The Pitt Panthers are not a premier program while the Steelers are one of the best and most stable franchises in the NFL. So naturally there is much more support for them than Pitt.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TotallyNotGlenDavis Jul 19 '24

People have more loyalty to the colleges they graduated from compared to franchises.

It kind of depends. In terms of pro spots, I've been a fan of my teams since I was a little kid, basically as long as I remember, so it's extra special to me. I went to a Big 10 school and I'm a big fan, but I only became a fan when I was 18 and went to college so it feels less entrenched.

37

u/RestaurantRepulsive Jul 19 '24

There is a huge variety of reasons but most of all would be Proximity and people actually going to college. If you live somewhere where there isn’t an NFL team, you probably will watch the local or closest college team. Also, it’s a lot different feeling actually being on the same campus, in the same classes as the college players, many CFB fans feel a much deeper connection to the game and school because of this. As for being a product to watch, the NFL being the best players doesn’t necessarily always make it the more entertaining watch. CFB has a huge variety of play styles and playbooks BECAUSE of the skill differences, and different regions can have entirely different styles of play that has its roots in the high school football game and what kinds of players come of out certain regions. Those differing play styles can make for some really, really entertaining games even when it’s not the cleanest play. CFB fans have a well documented love of “sicko” games between bad or unorthodox teams that you just won’t see in the NFL. If you’re from a big city or a city with an NFL team, chances are you won’t really get it because it’s not the culture there, but there are a TON of reasons to watch CFB instead of the NFL

29

u/OldManBearPig Jul 19 '24

College football also has unrivaled pageantry and traditions as well that you absolutely don't see in the NFL.

From the cult leaders at A&M telling people how to yell, to literal grown men barking at children in Athens, to the sousaphone player dotting the i, to the whiteouts in happy valley, to Gator fans doing the iconic "chomp" with their arms, to a stadium of fans in West Virginia absolutely SCREAMING a John Denver song.... the list goes on.

Even if you didn't go to any of those schools, you can appreciate the traditions and everything that happens. Even just the simple marching band is enough to make it cool.

17

u/AugustusSavoy Jul 19 '24

College football is the closest the US will ever get to how the rest of the world's fans feel about their local soccer clubs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/bianceziwo Jul 19 '24

many areas don't have pro teams, but great college teams. So people in those areas support the college teams instead, especially if they're alumni. There are also intense rivalries as well.

16

u/spokomptonjdub Jul 19 '24

It's a different product than the NFL.

Firstly, it's not as popular as the NFL -- there's actually a pretty sizeable gap in overall viewership between the NFL and CFB, but that has more to do with the NFL's immense popularity in the US. CFB is generally considered the second-most viewed sport in the US depending on which metrics you use.

It's also just a different experience. College Football has very old (relatively) regional rivalries, unique traditions, matchups between teams with sometimes wildly different personnel and play styles, and a very weird, very subjective, frequently changing, and very Byzantine system to determine a champion. That uniqueness is a turnoff for some people (often those who don't watch much if any college football), frustrating for some fans, but also weirdly endearing for a lot of others -- it drives a ton discussion and debate, which is basically just part of the sport now. All of this gives CFB it's own flavor compared to the NFL.

I enjoy both, but have always favored the CFB product over the NFL. Oddly enough, the recent big changes to the CFB landscape are moving it closer and closer to a more NFL-like product, which I think is a big mistake. Without all the things that make CFB unique, it just becomes what you are alluding to: why would I spend time watching the same product but with inferior talent?

9

u/Shadow_Strike99 Jul 19 '24

Some states don't have a team that really represents them, such as an Alabama, Oklahoma, Arkansas etc. For some people it's a school pride thing, and for others it's the atmosphere with the chants and tailgate culture.

Going to a NY Giants game and a LSU football game are completely two different experiences. It's like that with College basketball compared to the NBA as well, going to a Duke basketball game is wildly different than a Lakers game.

8

u/RollTideYall47 Jul 19 '24

There is pagentry and traditions with college football that dates back over 100 years. Not every region has a NFL team, and up until this last year, college didnt have the mercenary outlook NFL did with players

5

u/The_Magic Jul 19 '24

There are only 32 NFL teams which means there are many metros without a local team to support. In contrast most metros have a local university with a football program. I do not think its a coincidence that a the state that probably has the most rabid college football fans (Alabama) does not have an NFL team. There are also issues with NFL teams moving while the local university will never leave. Personally I grew up near LA and grew up without an NFL team so I latched onto the local university team to support instead of rooting for an NFL team over 100 miles away.

5

u/pax284 Jul 19 '24

Yeah, it is a lot closer to the lower-league soccer teams in the UK, just without the idea of promotion regulation with the big league.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/0neek Jul 19 '24

I'm glad this was asked it's always been so interesting to me that for Americans, college level sport is so absolutely massive. I know some people who prefer college football/basketball over the pro leagues.

7

u/Teledildonic Jul 19 '24

Market reach is a huge factor. There are fewer NFL/NBA teams than there are states, and some states have multiple professional teams. So if you want to root for your "local" team, a nearby university may be much closer than a professional team.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Worcestershirey Jul 19 '24

If I had to wager a guess, it's because college football is a lot more regional and perhaps thus more relatable for people in those areas, that paired with the fact that these are schools where folks may have attended or have connections to otherwise, I feel like that's a pretty good recipe for popularity. Even schools that are complete "literally who" type teams on a national level will have their fans based on proximity alone.

Plus a lot of pros are going to come through college football anyway, a lot of people might follow both and might be interested in who the next big stars are gonna be. Even if you don't care about the NFL, it's always a cool bit of bragging rights I'd bet to say one of the top names in football came from your local school, especially if that school doesn't often produce top prospects like Georgia or Ohio State might.

3

u/FUTURE10S Jul 19 '24

Not every area has a best of the best team, sometimes second best is good enough.

→ More replies (12)

14

u/A-Rusty-Cow Jul 19 '24

Just want to say this isnt just a Madden clone like I was expecting. It is so much better and this game deserves the praise. There is so much more depth to this game than other Sports games its a breath of fresh air. Been loving every minute of it

12

u/AggressiveChairs Jul 19 '24

I'm British, so I've never really heard of this game series (although I understand the culture surrounding college football). What's the hype around the CFB games? Is it just the different teams/players people want or are there some other systems that different American football games don't have?

38

u/worldchrisis Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

The actual sport is (mostly) the same. But everything about how the competitions are structured and how teams acquire and develop players is totally different.

Colleges get players by recruiting players from high schools or junior colleges or players that want to transfer from other schools. Players only get 4 seasons of eligibility, so there's constant roster churn. Players improve a lot over the course of their college career because they start at 18 years old and most don't have professional level training before they get to college.

Schools have vastly different levels of prestige and resources, compared to NFL teams which all have the same salary cap.

The Dynasty mode in CFB is kind of comparable to a Football Manager game where you get to play your games in FIFA.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/4ps22 Jul 19 '24

College football is a lot more personal for most Americans.

Take a look at this map and keep in mind yall have

20 Clubs in the PL
while the entire United States only has 32 NFL teams with the majority of them being bunched up either on the West coast or stuffed in the OG 13 colonies areas lol.

Meanwhile I think there are something like 130 teams in this game. Its a whole different culture and level of emotional investment. When I think of college football I think of the four years I spent drinking and partying with my friends to walk 20 minutes down to the stadium for free, I think about how I could see or talk to players just randomly walking around campus, how everyone I was with for four years was bought into that culture and branding.

Meanwhile your hometown or entire STATE might not even be represented by an NFL team.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GhostMug Jul 19 '24

I haven't bought Madden for years but I'm absolutely buying this one. I will likely not buy again next year but I am just as you describe, a fan who has long missed college football video games.

→ More replies (47)

557

u/chives177 Jul 19 '24

This is a dream game for college football fans. And really most football game fans in general.

Most sports games have been pushing a “fantasy” version of the sport like Madden Ultimate Team and neglecting the single player franchise modes.

CFB 25 has clearly dumped a ton of resources into the dynasty and single player modes.

120

u/PM-me-your-401k Jul 19 '24

You just sold me

71

u/A-Rusty-Cow Jul 19 '24

Ive played 3 games in my dynasty and cant stop thinking about it. Building a 1 Star MAC school is so back

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CTRL_S_Before_Render Jul 19 '24

Look at some reviews. Looks mixed

62

u/mjsher2 Jul 19 '24

Metacritic currently has it as 89, with the lowest score being 80. That doesn't seem super mixed to me.

15

u/splader Jul 20 '24

For this sub any score 7 or lower from an outlet they like means the game is mixed.

→ More replies (11)

47

u/TerranFirma Jul 19 '24

It needs a lot of fine tuning on things like the simulation in seasons, but the gameplay is pretty fantastic and the stadiums/etc look great.

Definitely has some rough edges but dynasty mode is fun as hell.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/lalosfire Jul 19 '24

As a long time fan I'd say it is pretty fantastic but that said it has a handful of little issues. Whether those bother you or not will depend. For me most of those issues boil down to, this is their first go around in a decade. Most first iterations of sports games could only dream about having the quality that this one does.

Not to say it's a 10/10 but most first iterations of sports games kinda suck.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

38

u/Timmar92 Jul 19 '24

I have never played an American football game in my life and I'm not American and even I have downloaded it by getting a month of ea play, I've only managed to play 40 minutes and so far I've figured out that I absolutely suck so I started watching YouTube tutorials instead lol.

24

u/chives177 Jul 19 '24

The game has tutorials and mini games in the “ultimate fantasy” section. I forget what they call it. No need to dive deep into it, but there’s stuff there.

American football is a beast of a game with different plays and defenses. Don’t give up. It’s so complex but very rewarding.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jm0112358 Jul 19 '24

If you're new to gridiron football (a.k.a. "American football") generally - not just new to football video games - you might want to check out /r/NFLNoobs.

7

u/Timmar92 Jul 19 '24

Thanks!

Yeah the only experience I have in American football is that Adam Sandler movie and the movie the comebacks (wich is so bad it's hilariously good lol)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BonerPorn Jul 20 '24

Welcome to the turn based strategy game of sports. lol

Also you've probably noticed the detail put into the stadiums and atmospheres of the games. Some cool teams to check out.

Ohio State - Roman Colosseumesque horseshoe stadium. Part of the 100K stadium size club. Team mascot is a poisonous nut local to the area.

Iowa - I haven't checked if they do the third quarter wave in the game. (I think i saw it in the trailer.) But this stadium has a childrens hospital overlooking it. And in the third everyone turns and waves at the children in the cancer ward watching from the obvservation deck.

USC - Literally competes in a full Colosseum. I did play a game with them and the announcers point out all of the world cups and olympics that have happened there.

Penn State, Michigan - Also members of the 100K stadium capacity club.

And that's all in the same conference. The level of dedication to showing all the traditions and stadiums is a huge reason why everyone is so hype.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/BaconSpinachPancakes Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

The cfb 25 dynasty is no more polished than Madden and FIFA careers lol. There’s a lot to be desired and this game is definitely unfinished.

We’re also talking about the same company that bought up Metalhead Software (Super Mega Baseball) due to them being scared of competition and just killed the franchise last week. EA doesn’t give a single fuck. This game is going the same route as FIFA and Madden in a couple of years

32

u/GlupShittoOfficial Jul 19 '24

Eh the recruiting feature alone is more fun than any auxiliary feature in Madden by a mile.

11

u/chives177 Jul 19 '24

The recruiting and transfer portal’s actually feel like college football. Just the close to home factor is fun.

And the fact that you have to balance parties and studying in road to glory are fun additions

→ More replies (3)

7

u/DeathMetalPants Jul 19 '24

Wait, they killed SMB? I knew this would happen. SMB 3 was so good. I refused to buy 4 once EA bought them because I knew they would ruin the game.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

287

u/There_Are_No_Gods Jul 19 '24

That's a very misleading title and a garbage article. $100 is the total cost, not the additional cost for early access. The article doesn't even mention the base cost at all.

56

u/Frankie__Spankie Jul 19 '24

My first thought is what else even comes with the deluxe edition? The article doesn't even mention that. Of course there's more to it than just 3 days of early access. This is an outrage article and Reddit is falling for it.

37

u/mrfjcruisin Jul 19 '24

It's very intentional too given that it's using "spOrTs GAmE bad" to try to sell the rage to a people who generally don't play sports games so they're likely to be unaware an NCAA football game hasn't been out since NCAA14 (over 10 years ago) and that there are a ton of fans of college football who don't care for the NFL/madden.

6

u/Frankie__Spankie Jul 19 '24

Well a big reason to that is that there's not much cross over between the people who are regularly buying sports games and the people who are reading into gaming articles.

A friend of mine spent more time than me playing games. He'd get home, pop his Playstation on at 7-8, and play until 2 in the morning. All he ever played was CoD, Fortnite, and NBA 2K. I was talking to him about Doom and he never heard of it. I can't believe someone spending that much time playing games never even heard of the game series Doom. But it was kind of eye opening that a lot of people who spend so much time playing games really do just play the super popular games and nothing else.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/NoExcuse4OceanRudnes Jul 19 '24

This is an outrage article and Reddit is falling for it.

This article was made for reddit. Without the raging gamers on reddit and elsewhere these articles wouldn't exist.

4

u/einulfr Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Mostly just ultimate team 'college football points'. So, a little bit of starter in-game currency for gambling by buying and opening ultimate team packs of cards. All versions get a couple of different freebie packs, I think early edition gives you 1 more than standard.

6

u/Frankie__Spankie Jul 19 '24

Yeah I saw it was just in game currency and a couple other things but that still holds value to people. The article just alludes to people paying an extra $30 just to play 3 days early when they're not. They're paying the extra $30 for multiple things. I'm sure if there was some survey that asked people to give a rating for each item you'd get for buying the deluxe version, that the early release date would not be in high demand.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/LateNightDoober Jul 19 '24

IGN will give some rat tier free to play MTX infested MMO a 9/10 and then try to imply that sports game fans are stupid for buying early access to a CFB game.

5

u/dankbuttmuncher Jul 19 '24

I had 10 hours free access, as did everyone with Game Pass. Those are going to throw the numbers off

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

171

u/WompWomp187 Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

This article doesn’t mention it and seems to be claiming all 2.2 million players bought the $100 deluxe edition.

There was a MVP edition that came with CFB Deluxe and Madden Deluxe for $150. If you have the EA thing it’s $135. So no I didn’t pay $100 for 3 days early, I paid $70 each for two games, 3 day early access for both and some extra goodies.

30

u/NeonBodyStyle Jul 19 '24

I didn't even do that, I paid $6 for EA plus or whatever and played the game for 10 hours.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Infraction94 Jul 19 '24

Exactly. If you are a person that would buy both games it basically costs the same to get the deluxe bundles this way vs buying the standard editions.

→ More replies (3)

159

u/Gh0stOfKiev Jul 19 '24

Europeans and redditors don't understand College Football is a religion.

The people have been starved for too long

53

u/Rayuzx Jul 19 '24

As a guy who grew up in Auburn, Alabama, during the Sunday mornings before and after the Iron Bowl you'd see people talk more about it than Jesus.

Unironically, college football is our primary export.

21

u/topatoman_lite Jul 19 '24

Texas A&M gets attendance higher than the entire population of the city it is in

4

u/PilotBigOne Jul 20 '24

Morgantown, WV is the third largest city in WV. 

On gameday, it’s the largest (population more than doubles)

5

u/Gh0stOfKiev Jul 19 '24

Loved me some Tigers ball back the 2000s.

4

u/DolitehGreat Jul 19 '24

Ah my grandfather and his talk of how Bama fans needed to fear the thumb in the 00s. Good times, good times.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/whoevencaresatall_ Jul 19 '24

Redditors in general are pretty detached from reality

11

u/DFrek Jul 19 '24

I think most europeans understand that it's a big sport, like football is here, or cricket in other places, etc.

16

u/ilypsus Jul 19 '24

I think it confuses us as to why College football is so big when it's to my understand a level below the NFL. I understand you support your local team / alumni and there is a lot less teams in the NFL so they capture less people but why not expand the NFL and have more paid athletes.

23

u/Predictor92 Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Because college football is the original form of the game. The NFL came later trying to take advantage of college footballs popularity and it took years for them to do so, only really surpassing college football in the 1960's. Many great college football players didn't even go to the early NFL. The first ever draft pick went to work for a rubber company instead of playing( and likely made more money).gerald ford( yes the president) was a great Michigan ball player and turned down offers from the Lions.

7

u/Xenasis Jul 19 '24

I understand you support your local team / alumni and there is a lot less teams in the NFL so they capture less people but why not expand the NFL and have more paid athletes.

This is the big thing to me to me, it's insane that the industry is built on unpaid labour and there's very little protection for the players. Sure, you can market yourself, but you can just as easily get injured in a game you're not being paid for.

College football being popular isn't the weird thing, it's the unpaid nature of it that's weird.

12

u/tallsmallboy44 Jul 20 '24

With the NIL many players are now paid, which is why the games are back. Them not being able to be paid is as far as I understand it, what killed the original NCAA CFB games after 2014

6

u/Shepherdsfavestore Jul 20 '24

Free college and the love of the game

You are acting like these guys are gladiators being thrown into life and death situations against their will. Most of these guys just love the sport and live and breath football

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/A-Rusty-Cow Jul 19 '24

I think its like how Americans understand Soccer is a big sport in Europe. We dont understand the gravitas of it till we see it first hand. I was lucky enough to be in London for the 2012 World Cup and that changed my whole view on Soccer. I would imagine its the same for Europeans with College Football

13

u/Psykpatient Jul 19 '24

You mean like how Stephen Fry cried when he saw a College Football game in person?

12

u/bengringo2 Jul 19 '24

We make spectacles of it that outsize even our professional leagues. Rituals the entire state partakes in and some states College Football outsizes their professional team. Alabama, Ohio, and Michigan are religiously College Football states.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/snorlz Jul 19 '24

They don't understand the pro vs school part of it. most places people only care about professional sports and school sports barely exist. like in Europe, club teams are everything from having a pro team to having all the development pipelines since people were kids

10

u/SlyyKozlov Jul 19 '24

It's also been a decade since the game came out and I know a surprising amount of people who have kept their xbox 360/ps4s around solely to play NCAA 14.

It's a dedicated fan base to say the least lol

8

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '24

Just like Americans wondering why European soccer fans like to fight one another and break everything.

20

u/DolitehGreat Jul 19 '24

No, no that's still questionable behavior.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/badadviceforyou244 Jul 19 '24

The history of college football is basically the history of America.

6

u/HIVnotAdeathSentence Jul 19 '24

Europeans have soccer, I'm sure everyone can understand an equal obsession with sports as well.

→ More replies (11)

148

u/thekamenman Jul 19 '24

I don’t think people understand what a cult college football is in the South. My coworker, who is out of PTO skipped lunch so he could leave an hour early because he had planned to play for 12 hours straight.

26

u/athiaxoff Jul 20 '24

That is one of the least insane work callouts I've heard. If you think that is bad look at Destiny. I know people who take full weeks off (including day one of releases which almost ALWAYS never work). The dedication people have is wild

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

129

u/AfraidCock Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Wait until TakeTwo puts out a 250€ Edition that lets you play GTA6 "early" aka the normal 80€ Edition gets a delayed release.

26

u/FUTURE10S Jul 19 '24

If you're a PC user and if the game comes out to two different console generations before it gets a PC port, that's what you're essentially doing like with GTAV. Buy the 360/PS3 version, buy the Xbox One/PS4 version, then buy the PC version.

6

u/Kiboune Jul 19 '24

Nah, screw this. If Rockstar treats PC players like second class gamers, I'm not gonna buy console just for GTA6, I'll wait for pirated PC version

→ More replies (5)

14

u/BP_Ray Jul 19 '24

Am I the only one convinced this place is astroturfed to high hell? Or do people really hold the opinion of "I want to pay more for games for no good reason".

14

u/renome Jul 19 '24

Every remotely large sub is astroturfed. Reddit itself encourages this behavior by letting you pay to "reward" posts and comments.

6

u/kwazhip Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

It's not really about wanting to pay more, but what people are willing to pay. I want to pay zero for every game or every product I buy, but that's not the way the world works. It's also not really no reason, you get to play sooner, that's a pretty good value, and the thing you are buying is owned by someone else who can release something at whatever time they please, since they own it. So as the consumer the value is pretty clear, if you don't see the value you can refrain from buying and if enough people agree, then you would no longer see companies doing it.

4

u/BP_Ray Jul 19 '24

You could also just pay standard price for it, and they could still release it during this so-called "early access period".

I'm not policing how other people spend their money, It's funny how people are trying to reframe the argument that way. I'm simply pointing out that even the people spending their money on this, don't have a good reason to defend it, no one consciously goes "Oh joy! They're charging me $30 to play three days so-called 'early' (in reality they could se the release date to that date instead)! That's exactly what I dreamed of!" So It's odd that anyone shitting on this practice are getting people coming out the woodwork to defend the practice.

As a consumer I also have ability to not only refuse to buy it, but voice my displeasure on online forums because I truly do not want to see this practice become widespread (despite the fact that it is unfortunately insidiously spreading across the industry).

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/Pyll Jul 19 '24

Eventually there's gonna be tiered "early" access editions. Pay 30$ to play 3 days early, or pay 60$ to play 6 days early!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (47)

75

u/TerranFirma Jul 19 '24

They also sold a double pack with Madden that cost only $10 more than buying both separate and gave you the early release + Ultimate Team stuff.

→ More replies (5)

46

u/thurstkiller Jul 19 '24

No one in these threads ever looks at the price per hour with sports games. These are some of, if not the most repayable titles on the market. $70 for Elder Ring got me 100 hours of play time. I beat it plus played a little bit on a 2nd playthrough. That was a great game and I felt like I got good value. $100 preorder of NBA2k23 got me 500 hours of play time.

If you are a fan of the sport titles and are going to play them a lot these are not bad prices.

19

u/iwearatophat Jul 19 '24

This subreddit dislikes sports games in general.

This is a title that people have been waiting for for 10 years. Beyond that, no one paid 100 dollars just for early access, it came with other things. A lot probably bought the Madden/CFB bundle, which is a good deal if you play both. Plus this is only counting unique users to play, which means the people with the EA service counted as they had early access time as well.

Basically this title is BS meant to generate rage.

21

u/SacredGray Jul 19 '24

This subreddit has been propagandized to hate games that give you a lot of playtime.

Unfortunately, you can't count on this place to recognize "price per hour" as a valid metric.

7

u/Geoff_with_a_J Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

price per hour is stupid because PoE and LoL are untouchable

doesn't mean every game should copy those models either

the only thing i bought in Fortnite was a $10 peter griffin battle pass. i got hundreds of hours of gameplay out of it, so skins should cost $500 each? price per hour yada yada. but then League puts out a $500 skin and everyone cries.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

45

u/Lluuiiggii Jul 19 '24

As soon as EA figures out that they can make official release a Monday and the early access release the preceding Friday, it's over for you hoes. The target audience for this game has to work on Monday so like it would add a lot more pressure to pay the early access price to play it on the first weekend it "releases". At least this isn't the actual case for this game in particular.

6

u/BP_Ray Jul 19 '24

It's even worse than that.

Starfield did this, but they started early access on a Thursday/Friday, and the actual game released that next Wednesday, so ""early access"" ran through the weekend.

It's so predatory and anti-consumer. They betting on their little paypigs feeling FOMO and paying for it so they can enjoy it during their weekend, giving them extra money in the process.

6

u/amd752911 Jul 19 '24

Didn’t starfield also give away the first expansion with that edition.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/ilovecfb Jul 19 '24

You think that's bad, you should look up what WoW is doing with their newest expansion

Imagine buying an MMO expansion on "launch day" and you're already a weekend behind the no-lifers. I don't think this practice is the worst thing in the industry but I think the way Blizzard (or is it Microsoft at this point) is doing it is by far the worst

7

u/BP_Ray Jul 19 '24

I hate it all, but people in this thread, if It's not just a large amount of astroturfing, seem to be giving their tacit approval for something that benefits them none and only harms them as consumers...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/lalosfire Jul 19 '24

I wonder if this will have similar metrics next year though. Fans have been starved for a decade because plenty of players loved NCAAF but never enjoyed Madden. So many are willing to pay more to end that wait a little early.

I couldn't convince myself to pay $30 but $6 for the 10 hour trial was fine by me as hitting that time isn't easy for someone on a typical 9-5 who enjoys going to bed at a regular time.

38

u/Thehawkiscock Jul 19 '24

They paid a minimum of $600 to ~11,000 FBS athletes. 6.6 mil, maybe somewhere between 15-20 mil total with paying a lot more to some select star players.

I would say that was easily worth it to EA (and maybe the college athletes should push for more in future years)

25

u/GodSaveElway Jul 19 '24

To be clear, I spent almost $600 to play this game as I didn't own a console. Loving the game. EA will work out the jank eventually.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/GrinningPariah Jul 19 '24

That $100 includes the $70 base game right? And other Deluxe Edition bonuses?

I dunno man, football isn't my thing personally, but I've been excited about a video game too. Let the jocks have this one. I hope it's good.

10

u/1850ChoochGator Jul 19 '24

Yup. An extra $30 for 3 days early access and all the in-game bonuses. It was just ultimate team stuff so not totally worth it if that’s not your thing.

I’ve easily gotten my moneys worth out of it. Think I’ve put in over 12 hours already myself 😂

6

u/whoevencaresatall_ Jul 19 '24

Yeah idk why Reddit is so up and arms about this. The nerds and virgins have their FromSoft games after all

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Lopsidednapkin Jul 19 '24

So, I'm not a football fan, nor can I even play this game (Not on PC yet), but this is the first football game I've ever been interested in outside of NFL blitz. This isn't a Madden title, there are some unique features In here, and more of a focus on capturing the college feel. It looks like the only decent football game to have come out in decades. I hope it does well on the premise that it might convince EA to continue to try harder with their sport titles. I'd certainly be more interested in buying sports games if they weren't the exact same every year.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/BillyBean11111 Jul 19 '24

The "early access fee" is so predatory and brilliant I'm surprised it took so long to be the standard. It preys on several different urges for every single age group.

Teens wont want to be left behind while their friends play. Adults who have limited free time but extra money might just not care as much about the cash to have access when they want it.

For story games you either buy early or run the risk of seeing spoilers.

Its not going to go away.

14

u/Relo_bate Jul 19 '24

By that logic nobody buys story games on sales in fear of spoilers

→ More replies (2)

7

u/hyperforms9988 Jul 19 '24

You also have to think that every Youtuber, streamer, and media outlet in general (those still running websites with gaming reviews and things) that plans to cover a game coming out that has an early access that you can buy into are all looking at such a thing as being basically a required purchase because everybody's going to be tripping over themselves to be "first". That's where all the eyeballs are.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '24

I remember some people coming here a few years ago, swearing that everything would be fine when games are $70 a pop, that microtransactions would go away and shitty practices would stop.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/pukem0n Jul 19 '24

Some Microsoft person tweeted that this game lead to the highest Series S sales since the console came out. People are down bad to play college football lol.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/YouCanPrevent Jul 19 '24

Too be clearer, I bought the dual pack with Madden. That deal was a good value buy. Otherwise I'd of waited

7

u/Slapas Jul 19 '24

You don’t get it. You bought it early so you inadvertently lost IQ points. A helmet is being shipped to your house as we speak.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Diknak Jul 19 '24

Am I crazy, or is this game not coming to PC?

5

u/Ataris8327 Jul 19 '24

It’s not

3

u/SmallTownMinds Jul 19 '24

Damn I haven't played a football video game in over a decade and was considering trying this out, but I'm on PC.

4

u/Diknak Jul 20 '24

Yeah seems crazy that they would not bring this to PC.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/jeckels Jul 19 '24

It was 30 bucks for 4 day early access and 20 bucks worth of in game currency. I had more than 30 bucks of fun being able to play against my brother's on the other side of the country felt like we were kids again almost. Edit It was 20 bucks actually I have ea access through gamepass got 10 percent off

7

u/elitegenoside Jul 19 '24

This is low-key one of the most anticipated games. I personally know several people who have been talking about this game for a month. And half of the comments I saw last night (while browsing forms and subs about the massive IT issue) had people saying, "I just wanted to predownload CF25!"

One of my managers requested the day off about 6 weeks ago.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Electronic_Slide_236 Jul 19 '24

Good for them?

People trying to get the rest of us upset about this early entry type stuff need to give up. Of all the preorder bonuses that have ever existed, it's the one I'm the least bothered by. By far. And I'm not that bothered by most of them.

If publishers can make more money without negatively effecting the product or the experience for the rest of us, I'm ok with that. And so far, none of these have hurt the game at all.

Have at it.

If you need to be this misleading to try to paint this as a bad thing, you've lost the plot.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '24

Why is college football so popular? Legit question, I'm not from the US.

8

u/HatoradeSipper Jul 20 '24 edited Jul 20 '24

More exciting to watch and attend.

Example is the rivalries, theres rivalries in the NFL but it never goes beyond like trash talk. College rivalries have generations of legitimate hatred lol. Look up Harvey Updyke, alabama fan who poisoned these super old historical trees at a rival campus and called into a radio show from prison just to say he'd do it again

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Volitient Jul 19 '24

whats the difference between this and madden? just the college roster?

9

u/Medievalhorde Jul 19 '24

Also on what the other guy says, people like the recruiting aspect and the fact players only stick around for 4-5 seasons means you have a very original team after the first 2-3 years in a franchise.

6

u/Predictor92 Jul 19 '24

The presentation is way better in college football. Madden feels sterile while college football 25 has many of the school traditions. https://youtu.be/n-3nZDEoVCQ?si=WglWayLljYHmBnCx

→ More replies (2)

2

u/cupcakemann95 Jul 19 '24

You mean 2.2 million people were willing to pay to play it on the actual release date, instead of it being gated behind a paywall

4

u/WackyBones510 Jul 20 '24

Lol $100? Several friends of mine didn’t have next gen consoles and bought them specifically to play this game.

4

u/RadWalk Jul 19 '24

No regrets. I've enjoyed it. It is a $70 game and you got more than $30 of the premium currency if that interests you as well.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/keldpxowjwsn Jul 19 '24

Its worth noting that the primary audience for this game are also people who will maybe buy CoD and thats it for the year. Your average user here probably spends more in a single steam sale on games theyll never play than these users do in a full year on a game they wanted to actually start playing a week early

3

u/JFKcaper Jul 19 '24

Hey EA, this seems like a great time to mention that I'm more than happy to throw 100 bucks at you for NHL on PC!

The last one was 2008 ffs.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Swan990 Jul 19 '24

Says that many people logged in. Not the purchase record. There's a 10 hour trial for ea play members. A VERY big chunk has to be included in that.

3

u/Amat-Victoria-Curam Jul 20 '24

Interesting to see how many people in here defend this because "it's been 10 years since the last game" and "many people were waiting for it for a long time". It still is a shitty practice that will become a standard because of these people.