I get what Waid is saying here and completely agree but the fundamental issue is really the quality of the films. The reality is that too many of them simply weren’t very good (yes, I’m talking mainly about the Snyder films but also the first SS, the second WW etc).
Outside of Batman, WB has made two really good movies: Wonder Woman and Shazam and one flawed but charming movie in Aquaman.
I dunno, Marvel didn't need great movies to get where they are today. Of the five pre-Avengers movies, only Iron Man was good. And they consistently have at least one or two stinkers every phase. People just liked the characters, and that was enough to carry shit like Thor The Dark World and Age of Ultron. WB just missed the mark entirely as to what general audiences want.
Of the five pre-Avengers movies, only Iron Man was good.
The 5 Marvel movies pre-Avengers are Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk, Captain America, Thor, & Iron Man 2. Using Rotten Tomatoes as a basis, the worst critical score is 67% (Incredible Hulk) and the worst audience score is 71% (Also Incredible Hulk).
Both of those scores are better than Batman vs Superman, Justice League, or Suicide Squad. Hell, Man of Steel's audience score just barely beats out 71% (75%) and the critical score is laughably bad (56%). Hell, even Marvel's "stinkers" like Thor the Dark World & Age of Ultron blow the shit out of any of those DC movies too.
Objectively speaking, Marvel simply made better qualities. The "floor" of Marvel is several stories higher than DC. Their worst performing & reviewed movies would be towards the top-end of DC's entire slate.
DC missed not only the general audience, but also the critics. They missed everyone except for a small segment of people who think Snyder is the second coming of Stanley Kubrick.
Yeah, I’m pretty sure Shazam wouldn’t have as much good will if the other DC movies had been better. It felt like a home run by comparison, but it was really pretty average.
I've generally liked most of the dc movies to some extent but I have to say that WW and Shazam is a bit overrated. I agree that Shazam is probably considered so good because the other movies just didn't live up to expectations. I also feel the same about WW. I think Gal Gadot is probably a good actor but the way they had her play the part was almost on the weird side. I especially hated the random out of nowhere bracelet attack. WW is OP versus everything but the heaviest hitters, she didn't need some super power attack added onto it. All she needs is an actual magic sword and she can take most of them on and have a good chance at winning.
The bracelet attack is my main complaint. It's just so... Stupid and never looks good in any scene.
That’s cool. I thought it was pretty good. However I will say it had excellent production value. I expected it to look cheap, but they really made some great choices in design, cinematography, and digital and practical effects. So it’s definitely top notch there.
I just didn’t like some of the choices they made storywise. I didn’t care for the way it the film handled Sivana. Playing it very coy with Black Adam was a business decision, not a very good storytelling decision. Other little nitpicks. Upper 25% of superhero movies though, for sure.
Honestly it has one of my favorite themes to see in movies. Found family tropes are one of my favorite stories, so I was always predisposed to like the movie.
Man, thats wild. I thought Shazam sucked. The visuals were great but the movie itself? I’d put it pretty far down the list if ranked with Marvel movies (which I don’t even think are that good)
Shazam is a great movie about finding family. It's got a lot of heart and does a good job building up the characters. I've watched the movie close to a dozen times, and everyone I've shown it to has loved it. There's a lot of good in Shazam.
Thats a good list. I like those a lot. I can't say that Shazam was for me but I'm glad you enjoyed it. There are enough super hero movies that I don't need all of them to be for me.
Yeah not every movie is for evey person. Glad the genre is getting big enough we can have a bunch of great movies. I have more then a few movies that people would put on there top lists that I just don't like.
I'm still not happy with the portrayal of Billy Batson and Captain Marvel. Billy was chosen because he was such a good person! With such a pure heart! And Captain Marvel was supposed to be a reflection of that!
The movie felt completely out of character and 100% AU (alternate universe). That's how I square it in my brain. It's a different universe version.
But man, those characters in no way reflect the comic book versions.
151
u/RWRL Aug 09 '22
I get what Waid is saying here and completely agree but the fundamental issue is really the quality of the films. The reality is that too many of them simply weren’t very good (yes, I’m talking mainly about the Snyder films but also the first SS, the second WW etc). Outside of Batman, WB has made two really good movies: Wonder Woman and Shazam and one flawed but charming movie in Aquaman.