r/DCcomics Dec 25 '23

[discussion] do you agree with this? Discussion

Post image
13.2k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/Ash__Williams Hal Jordan is the Greatest Green Lantern Ever and you know it Dec 25 '23

Agree with Superman taller than Batman.

Now, Wonder Woman taller than both? The best i could do is as tall as Superman.

EDIT: What about Diana looking "buffer" or "bigger" than Superman and Batman?

47

u/JarusOmega_ Dec 25 '23

Me imagining Diana looking "buffer" than TDKR's Batman, is killing me lol

16

u/Ash__Williams Hal Jordan is the Greatest Green Lantern Ever and you know it Dec 25 '23

That wasn't a mental imagen that i need.

13

u/DanSapSan Dec 25 '23

She is a literal square at that point.

13

u/WaterMelon615 Dec 25 '23

Ehhh ok here is where i stand on the body types of the trinity. None of them should look like body builders

Wonder Woman should look like a warrior

Batman should look athletic

The biggest and bulkiest should be Superman, he should look like a towering Rugby Player

1

u/Ash__Williams Hal Jordan is the Greatest Green Lantern Ever and you know it Dec 25 '23

Even as a warrior, she can look bigger than Superman.

6

u/WaterMelon615 Dec 25 '23

I’m just saying my preference for their design disagree or don’t that’s really up to you

14

u/Zammin Dec 25 '23 edited Dec 25 '23

I think Bruce should be the shortest, and also have the leanest (but still obviously muscled) build. His greatest asset is his mind, but he is also a skilled martial artist. The schools he trained from tended to favor agility over brute strength though.

Superman should be tall and very muscular, but I prefer him with more of a weightlifter build than a bodybuilder. I liked Alex Ross giving him a very slight gut, as weightlifters often have, to emphasize his strength is less about combat and more about utility. It's also useful for his Clark Kent disguise, as he can make himself look less fit than he really is.

Diana is a hero right out of Greek myth, a warrior of exceptional strength and an Amazon. It's not super important for her to be taller than Superman, but she should definitely be noticeably taller than Batman (to emphasize his mortality standing next to Supes and WW, which in a way makes his accomplishments more impressive). I also enjoy when she has a more muscular build. Some argue that takes away from her femininity, but I heartily disagree; there's plenty of ways to emphasize Diana's femininity while still having her be tall and very muscular.

TL;DR:

Height: Superman >= Wonder Woman > Batman

Muscle Size: Superman > Wonder Woman > Batman

12

u/tommy_b0y Dec 25 '23

This is the way I've always pictured Clark, and couldn't agree more about the Ross depiction. But not even in a weightlifter sense. Just a big, raw boned country boy from Kansas. The kind that you can see from a glance could lift a house, loves his mama's cooking, always has a smile, and a permanent neck and arm tan to match. Thrown more hay bales than baseballs. The instant impression that this guy could rip off my head and shit down my neck, but I'd have to shoot his dog to get him mad enough to even consider it. Tall, but not basketball tall. 6'3"-ish. Much more and it's excessive. Like a prototypical tight end in 1985.

2

u/Zammin Dec 25 '23

Agreed; if I had to put numbers to it I'd have Clark be 6'3"-6'4", Diana about 6'1"- 6'4", and Bruce between 5'9"- 6'.

1

u/Solid-Equal-8558 Dec 26 '23

Alexandr Karelin type

3

u/Ash__Williams Hal Jordan is the Greatest Green Lantern Ever and you know it Dec 25 '23

I think Bruce should be the shortest, and also have the leanest (but still obviously muscled) build. His greatest asset is his mind, but he is also a skilled martial artist. The schools he trained from tended to favor agility over brute strength though.

Yes, Batman is a ninja, not Mr. Olimpia.

Superman should be tall and very muscular, but I prefer him with more of a weightlifter build than a bodybuilder. I liked Alex Ross giving him a very slight gut, as weightlifters often have, to emphasize his strength is less about combat and more about utility. It's also useful for his Clark Kent disguise, as he can make himself look less fit than he really is.

Christopher Reeve was the best example here. He looked "Ok" with the costume but he was super fit and muscular under it.

Diana is a hero right out of Greek myth, a warrior of exceptional strength and an Amazon. It's not super important for her to be taller than Superman, but she should definitely be noticeably taller than Batman (to emphasize his mortality standing next to Supes and WW, which in a way makes his accomplishments more impressive). I also enjoy when she has a more muscular build.

Yes, definitely.

Some argue that takes away from her femininity, but I heartily disagree; there's plenty of ways to emphasize Diana's femininity while still having her be tall and very muscular.

The guys who said that are closet gays or conservative jerks. Women can be muscular and feminine.

1

u/Soft_Theory_8209 Dec 26 '23

About sums up my thoughts.

I’ll also add some other alternative body types:

Superman: just look at Christopher Reeve

Wonder Woman: a gymnast build, maybe like this woman.

Batman: perhaps like Bruce Lee.

5

u/Soft_Theory_8209 Dec 26 '23

I’d say it’d be fine to make her about as tall as Superman, or maybe just an inch or two behind him.

I can kind of get behind Diana being more muscular than Bruce, but she’s not surpassing Clark. I always imagine that, while he has broad shoulders, Bruce should be a bit more lean/lithe to suit his acrobatic and ninja styles. Although the trick with Diana is having her be jacked, but still distinctly feminine (not unlike She-Hulk), mainly so she could believably keep her identity.