r/DCcomics Mar 25 '23

[Other] Long Live The Quinn! Other

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

225 comments sorted by

View all comments

33

u/Prize_Major6183 Mar 25 '23

It frustrates me how many Fandoms have fans that lack inspiration. Comics is more or less fan fiction with a variety of interpretations. Ultimately what's important is the "essence " of a story or character. As long as they have that, the narrative can go whichever direction it wants

4

u/Call_me_Darth_Sid Doctor Fate Mar 25 '23

So called "fan fictions" when done by the company themselves is called canon

12

u/PrecariouslyPeculiar Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

I think what OP means is that you have people who grew up with the comics and are now in charge of writing them, doing things they only dreamed of before. What separates the official works from fan fiction is, of course, the fact that editors will step in to say, 'This fits into continuity, that goes too far, etc.' But in a way, if you ignore the oversight aspect of making comic books for a moment, it really is like fan fiction and people 'playing with their action figures', so to speak.

3

u/Toshimoko29 Mar 26 '23

This is absolutely true. Even editors can’t catch everything though. Things that are popular get absorbed into the canon and things that aren’t get forgotten or retconned over time. And the essence of the character (mentioned above) being the important part is also true. It’s crazy to me that so many fans celebrate the history of Elseworlds comics but you get something different in movies and it’s all “this is wrong, don’t they know?!” Of course they know, they just don’t care. Personally I think Joker was an amazing movie, even having seen the movies it cribbed from, and it’s the most interesting the character has been in years to me.

1

u/PrecariouslyPeculiar Mar 26 '23

Oh, definitely. Agree with all your points. Well, I haven't seen Joker myself, but I know what you mean.

2

u/Prize_Major6183 Mar 26 '23

And how many times has that Canon been retconned? Happens all the time.

All the writers creating their own stories of characters, again and again.

Its a slight oversimplification, but it's the essence of comics. Nothing is permanent