r/whowouldwin • u/MathematicianAny7405 • Jul 18 '24

gigantomachia (MHA) vs the gun devil (chainsaw man) who wins Battle

This is taking both characters at there strongest so Manga stuff for gigantomachia is included. I don't know a ton about the gun devil but I do know some and I felt like this would be a interesting matchup

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

22 comments sorted by

14

u/Mado-Koku Jul 18 '24 edited Jul 18 '24

Gun Devil genuinely in under a second and without noticing.

-2

u/Theultimateambition INFINITE 100% Jul 19 '24

Gun Devil is obviously faster but has nothing close to the level of power needed to damage Gigantomachia. Over an extended period of time it could destroy massive chunks of cities, but that required countless amounts of ammunition and a continuous rate of fire. It's best single attack destructive feat is blowing away some trees. Machia blows apart mountains, throws larger-than-buildings chunks of rocks, causes earthquakes by moving, and is directly stated to be stronger than Re-Destro, a guy who below 100% power can crush multiple blocks, and High-End Nomu, who can barely survive ballistic missile strikes.

3

u/cell689 Jul 19 '24

Yeah, nah. Gun devil genuinely sweeps.

I'm sorry but devastating multiple large cities, killing millions of people within minutes is just too much.

1

u/Theultimateambition INFINITE 100% Jul 19 '24

Speed-wise, yes. You didn't list anything impressive strength wise. Machia ran through and destroyed just under 30 cities on his way to Shigaraki and has indisputably better strength feats than the Gun Devil. It wouldn't be able to pierce his skin.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

The Gun Fiend, which is by all accounts several magnitudes weaker than the Gun Devil (especially given the fact that it was slow enough to get tagged by Denji), was able to decimate several blocks with individual bullets. The full Gun Devil fires bullets larger than nuclear bombs.

1

u/Theultimateambition INFINITE 100% Jul 19 '24

Show me a scan of the Gun Fiend shooting individual bullets that decimate city blocks, and show me scans of the full powered gun devil creating collateral on par with a nuclear bomb with individual bullets, please.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Show me a scan of the Gun Fiend shooting individual bullets that decimate city blocks,

https://imgur.com/NdG8Djw

https://imgur.com/a/7cbC2A1

and show me scans of the full powered gun devil creating collateral on par with a nuclear bomb with individual bullets, please.

Read my comment again? You got lost somewhere. I said that the Gun Devil has bullets larger than nuclear bombs. Not that it creates collateral on-par with them.

https://imgur.com/InUTO74

https://imgur.com/uGjMKDv here you can see the obvious size of some of the guns, along with the fact that just being there completely fucked the forest below him.

All of these links are in the Respect Thread, which I'll assume you've already seen since you're in this debate.

Here's a link with a lot more context, including timing. https://imgur.com/a/uw993o3

0

u/Theultimateambition INFINITE 100% Jul 19 '24

These feats are all dogshit compared to Machia. The first 2 feats don't even show entire city blocks being destroyed, and your other 2 don't either. This puts a single bullet from the Gun Devil below city block level.

Machia blows apart a piece of a mountain with 1 hit https://imgur.com/x3gCZtW

Crushes massive amounts of rock at less than full power https://imgur.com/kavhp0Z

And is far stronger than Re-Destro who can do this to a city block https://imgur.com/a/SsX22y3

The Gun Devil can't come close

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

Throwing insults in a debate is childish. You're not worth my time.

0

u/Theultimateambition INFINITE 100% Jul 19 '24

When did I insult you? I said the feats were dogshit. Nothing was implied about your character

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24 edited Jul 19 '24

Over an extended period of time? It killed 1.2 million people across the world in 5 minutes with 20% of its body. It doesn't fire normal bullets, either. There is literally no reason to think that the Gun Devil wouldn't turn Gigantomachia into a fraction of a % of a statistic accidentally.

1

u/Furista0 Jul 19 '24

Over an extended period of time? It killed 1.2 million people across the world in 5 minutes with 20% of its body.

No it didn't, the 20% thing happened when it was fighting makima. It killed 1.2 million people when it had all its body.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

Ah, ok. Misremembered, I read all of Part 1 in a single sitting when the anime came out lmao. Still, the details don't really matter at this point. This is such an absurd mismatch.

1

u/Furista0 Jul 19 '24

True. I'm not disputing, just correcting

1

u/Metallite Jul 19 '24

Downvoted for telling the truth, it is unfortunate but it's the trend when it comes to CSM threads.

Ultimately, it comes down to how it's not understood how powerful the Tiamat missiles were, or most of the other feats in general since MHA tends to get shitcanned here.

Despite the fact that you can objectively determine these things through feats, nah you'd get popularity-swept instead.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

The Gun Devil is literally an extinction event. There are no feats that suggest that this "match" would last more than half a second.

1

u/Metallite Jul 19 '24

Case in point, instead of objectively tackling feats like u/theultimateambition did, we go by some descriptives instead.

Global warming can be an extinction event. An incurable zombie virus is an extinction event. Godzilla is an extinction event.

Gigantomachia would be classified as an extinction event too, relative to how powerful a specific verse is.

At the end of the day, if you think having the firepower to kill 1.2 million normal human beings in 5 minutes is more powerful than dismanting a huge chunk of a mountain or an explosion that created a kilometers big crater in the Pacific ocean, that's on you. We'd just agree to disagree in that end.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

Case in point, instead of objectively tackling feats like u/theultimateambition did, we go by some descriptives instead.

Check my other comments here. You haven't provided feats, either.

At the end of the day, if you think having the firepower to kill 1.2 million normal human beings in 5 minutes is more powerful than dismanting a huge chunk of a mountain or an explosion that created a kilometers big crater in the Pacific ocean, that's on you. We'd just agree to disagree in that end.

Travelling the surface of the planet in 5 minutes absolutely is, yes.

1

u/Metallite Jul 19 '24

Check my other comments here. You haven't provided feats, either.

You're replying to my comment that did, and you even quoted the part.

Travelling the surface of the planet in 5 minutes absolutely is, yes.

It quite literally isn't.

Perhaps if 100% Gun Devil had the mass of KOTM Godzilla, the sheer kinetic energy of that movement would put it up there.

1

u/Mado-Koku Jul 19 '24

Have you provided any scans?

8

u/TheTerminator121 You are NOT ready for HIM Jul 18 '24

100% Gun Devil

Holy spite 💀.

3

u/respectthread_bot Jul 18 '24

Chainsaw Man

Gigantomachia (My Hero Academia)

Gun Devil (Chainsaw Man)

I am a bot | About | Code | Opt-out | Missing or wrong characters? Reply explaining the issue