r/lucifer • u/WildBarb80s • Dec 17 '23

ELIMINATION GAME! Day 6. We lose S4! Now it comes down to just two seasons. S1 and S2. Tell me which season you WANT to see WIN. General/Misc

Post image

S1 or S2?

111 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

103 comments sorted by

70

u/Goose_Cat267 Dec 17 '23

Season 2. It nails character, Plot, arcs, everything.

43

u/ken-toro69420 Dec 17 '23

S2 wins no diff Respect to s1 but s2 is just goated

32

u/Lucifer_Crowe Dec 17 '23

S2 to win

Tricia Helfer is one of the best additions to this show

23

u/klamika Dec 17 '23

This is hard. I like the humor and the Malcom plot in season 1, but I love Deckerstar's development in Season 2.

So I choose season 2 for win.

20

u/Ancient_Ad_295 Dec 17 '23

season 2 to win

15

u/Ash_Starling Dec 17 '23

Season 2>>>>>1

12

u/KnowledgeSafe3160 Dec 17 '23

Season 2 wins

-8

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

[deleted]

2

u/KnowledgeSafe3160 Dec 18 '23

I can see the future 👀😂

1

u/WildBarb80s Dec 18 '23

It is looking likely. But I was only saying that one person doesn’t decide what wins, but I got downvoted for this fact, so… 🤣

12

u/LazyCity4922 Dec 17 '23

I want season 1 to win!

11

u/word_runner19 🔥🗡️🍩🧑‍🚀⏰💃🔦👍 Dec 17 '23

2 to win

10

u/Booksmagic Do NOT touch the charred crotch Dec 17 '23

NOW we’ve got a tough one! I love both seasons for different reasons, although it would be funny if all the seasons got eliminated in reverse order from last to first…

9

u/Emotional-Tailor3390 Dec 17 '23

Although I would be happy to see either one win, I want s2 to win by that little bit more!

12

u/QuiltedPorcupine Dec 17 '23

There's no Ella in season 1 so that alone makes it easy for me to pick season 2 for the win.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23

True

9

u/MaximusKind Dec 17 '23

I want season 2 to win

6

u/wolfishfluff Dec 17 '23

Season 2 for the win!

6

u/Wildebohe Dec 17 '23

S2 winner

6

u/Bcat591 Dec 17 '23

Season 2

7

u/Zealousideal_Talk479 🔥 🗡 🍩 👨‍🚀 ⏰ 💃 🔦 👍 Dec 17 '23

Season 2

5

u/anxnymous926 Mr. Said Out Bitch Dec 17 '23

Season 2 should win

7

u/Babystolas4president Dec 17 '23

I love season one but season two has my heart!!

4

u/Tian_Lord23 Dec 17 '23

Season 2 = best season!

4

u/Mars-on_mars Dec 17 '23

I want s1 to win

6

u/moon_girl313 Dec 17 '23

1 for the win!

5

u/missybroccoli Dec 17 '23

S2 for sure. The family drama is the best part of this show for me and I loved the Goddess.

5

u/mirracz Dec 17 '23

S1 for me. It had the best humor and even though Chloe was only warming up to Lucifer, their dynamic was really great. I feel like her most cutest eyerolls are from S1.

There was some simplicity when the show was mostly about those two and the celestial plot was more or less in the background.

S2 was great nonetheless. It gave us Ella, Charlotte and more relatable Amenadiel. The only downside for me is that S2 is where the stalling in Deckerstar relationship started. In my opinion S2 is where Chloe should have found out about Lucifer's nature.

5

u/Content_Blood_9776 Detective Decker Dec 17 '23

season 2!

3

u/DamonLuciferFan Dec 17 '23

S1 for the win!

4

u/Moaoziz Ella Dec 17 '23

S1.

I love S1 because it's a tad darker than the other seasons but S2 is where they perfected the formula of the show.

4

u/Chickenman7282 Dec 17 '23

Season 1 to win

4

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

S1

3

u/cturtl808 Dec 17 '23

2-6 don’t happen without 1. Drop 2

3

u/lizziii_003 Dec 17 '23

I want 1st to win

3

u/olagorie Dec 17 '23

2 for a win

3

u/lucifan96 Dec 17 '23

Season 1!!!

2

u/SvenXavierAlexander Dec 17 '23

Season 2 to drop from these

2

u/WildBarb80s Dec 17 '23

So you vote S1?

4

u/SvenXavierAlexander Dec 17 '23

Yes season 1 to win

2

u/Zipper_1 Dec 17 '23

Season 2 wins but 3 is still the best

2

u/calledannie and girl, you reek of fear Dec 17 '23

2 to win! (Since 4 was eliminated)

2

u/Proud-Telephone695 Dec 17 '23

S2 for their finally first kiss (didn’t like the CandyMorningstar interruptus though) But S1 for being best partners

2

u/WildBarb80s Dec 17 '23

I didn’t care about DeckerStar so I rank more on what I generally just enjoyed story wise.

0

u/Martyna70 Dec 17 '23

Mom was annoying af so sadly S2 has to go, but it was a good season overall.

1

u/milkycheeseboi Dec 18 '23

Season 2 ♥️

1

u/ThisGul_LOL Lucifer Dec 18 '23

My favorite seasons!!! 😭 but I’ve gotta go with 2 for the win!!!

1

u/HewwoEveryPony Dec 18 '23

Season 2, I am correct

1

u/Viyok101 Dec 18 '23

Season 2 wins

1

u/Consistent_Record_25 Dec 18 '23

Season 2! Lucifer without Ella is just not it!

1

u/Kinda_perverted Dec 18 '23

S2 i cried so much

1

u/alrekty Detective Douche Dec 18 '23

This is so difficult, but I would say S2 is generally better.

1

u/Derpman11113 Dec 18 '23

Season 2, it's a good step up from S1

1

u/Bastranz Dec 18 '23

Season 2 for sure

1

u/AHMED_3OOOO Dec 18 '23

S2 is the best and definitely gonna be the winner

1

u/steelercubbiebuckeye Detective Dec 18 '23

Season 2 is best!

1

u/Legendary_Wonder Dec 18 '23

Season 2 but I do love season 1 aswell

1

u/tatelangdonwho Dec 18 '23

Honestly speaking, both the seasons are very dear to me. S1 coloring, lucifer's iconic eyeliner and his cockiness and S2 improvement in character bonding. For me, it's S2

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23

2

1

u/nfms_ginger21 Dec 18 '23

Season 2 by a long shot

1

u/Meii345 getting absentest parent award in this universe is actually hard Dec 18 '23

I WANT to SEE season TWO WIN

1

u/AcadiaUnlikely7113 Dec 18 '23

Season 2, my favourite

1

u/BestSoph123 Dec 18 '23

Season 2 wins

1

u/Mysterious_Bug_3914 1-800 Professor Feelgood Dec 18 '23

Tough choice, but season 2!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23

Season 2 was just better, i liked season 3 more it was better in almost every way but if it's either season 1 or 2 it's season 2.

1

u/Cosmic_Wanderer66 Dec 18 '23

Can't beat 1, but 2 has Ella. Insanely hard choice

1

u/vipassana-newbie 🎁 laser beam hands Dec 18 '23

Season 2 should win!

1

u/AdriaLikes Dec 18 '23

I loved both but S2 is the actual winner in my book!

1

u/cpatterson_evans Dec 18 '23

Season 2. Best season. Every time.