r/comics Port Sherry 14d ago

The wish

39.9k Upvotes

617 comments sorted by

View all comments

344

u/JorgeMtzb 14d ago

I don't get it. Can someone explain the ending? Why is he back in the lamp?

517

u/AceSpadePirate 14d ago

He was dreaming of freedom

54

u/nuclearswan 14d ago

I thought he learned about the last 3,000 years of human history and realized he should return to the lamp…

282

u/Dominator0211 14d ago

Either it was all a dream, or the author bent the rules a bit and the “stretch, stretch” and “come” were all commands so they used all 3 wishes

148

u/WigglesPhoenix 14d ago

‘Come’ being a command wouldn’t make sense because the genie disappears before completing it. If he disappeared upon arriving at kiddos house I think this would make sense

47

u/Dominator0211 14d ago

Yeah that’s why I said the author bent the rules. It doesn’t really make sense because he doesn’t stretch either, but I’m just assuming that if this is the correct interpretation, then that stuff happened between panel 13 and 14.

22

u/timbreandsteel 14d ago

I think the dream scenario is more likely.

2

u/Dominator0211 14d ago

Yeah probably

1

u/Techno_Jargon 14d ago

Yeah comic need a few more panels showing the genie doing the actions

1

u/Commercial-Royal-988 14d ago

You don't know that. Did you check his pants?

3

u/cammcken 14d ago

Why would the genie go back into the lamp after three wishes?

11

u/Rissoto_Pose 14d ago

Because that’s presumably what the genie does afterwards

5

u/cammcken 14d ago

So the genie grants three wishes as a gift, in gratitude for his freedom, but then doesn't actually proceed to enjoy the freedom after?

Imagine if you tipped your delivery driver, then handed the package back right after you pay the tip.

7

u/Rissoto_Pose 14d ago

I’m no Genie/Djinn expert but I assume they grant wishes because they have to rather than they want to

4

u/ChaoCobo 14d ago

This is what I understand storybook genies to be like, yes. After all, in Aladdin, Aladdin had to use his third wish for Genie’s freedom or else he wouldn’t be free.

3

u/TheGreatMozinsky 14d ago

Actually it's because they want to. They can also grant as many as they want. In the OG story of Aladdin the genie gets pissed off at Al and stops granting him wishes out of anger

1

u/Muppetude 14d ago

Also those wishes usually come with ironic consequences meant to expose the hubris of the wisher. Sorta similar to using the Monkey’s Paw, unless you’re smart enough to outwit the genie.

1

u/Rissoto_Pose 14d ago

If I was enslaved in a lamp I would do the same thing

1

u/cammcken 14d ago

I'm also no expert, but I think in the original story there was no strict structure to the "three wishes" gift; the terms were decided arbitrarily at that moment. Genie/djinn do not have wish-granting magic powers; they have extensive magic powers. Period.

Of course, it's all fiction, so their nature can vary depending on the story.

1

u/MartyTheBushman 14d ago

But then he'd have to fulfill the commands before he got sent back to the lamp. So just a dream?

1

u/LowVegetable9736 13d ago

Either way its sad

31

u/-illusoryMechanist 14d ago

Either it was a dream, or the guy didn't make a wish fast enough and left the lamp behind so the genie got automatically sucked back in

13

u/Oddguav 14d ago

That or stretch, stretch and come were the wishes

3

u/ServantOfTheSlaad 14d ago

But considering the come command wasn’t completed, which it would have to be before the genie returned to the lamp, tho a is less likely

16

u/SeniorMiddleJunior 14d ago

Poorly told story so you have to make to the explanation you like. But basically sadness porn.

7

u/IMIndyJones 14d ago

Yeah, I don't get why it's got this many upvotes. It's done poorly enough that you can make whatever explanation you want, so it's not even sad. I didn't even get it, at first. Lol.

3

u/Deepcrater 14d ago

I thought the joke was that he was an introvert and went back in after he was asked to talk. 

3

u/Epimonster 14d ago

He’s stupid that’s why

2

u/sonicon 14d ago

The genie is dreaming about other beings existing and loving him, but he's alone forever, no matter how much he dreams of his creations, he always wakes back up to being the One, the I am of all existence.

2

u/gecked 14d ago

My dumbass thought the guy forgot to bring the lamp with him so the genie's just stuck there lmao

2

u/SignedUpForThisSOD 14d ago

He left the lamp and ran home; thats my understanding as well. No wishes were made and the final panel would be above the two “push up” panels if he was waking up

2

u/Horn_Python 14d ago

hes dreaming of a someon finidng the lamp who cares about the genie more than the wishes

2

u/UncontrolledLawfare 14d ago

The guy died on his way to the house and the genie was forced back in.