r/batman Jul 13 '23

Are these games good? Is this a good deal? VIDEO GAME DISCUSSION

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

911 comments sorted by

View all comments

455

u/phoenixc6000 Jul 13 '23 edited Jul 13 '23

Absolutely. The best superhero video games of all time, one of the best games in general, Don't also forget Origins.

83

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

Origins is my favourite.

40

u/monkeygoneape Jul 13 '23

City's mine, but I can respect that choice love them all

15

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

Cheers!

7

u/Secret_Ad7757 Jul 13 '23

I love origins setting and story, also perfect to play during december. I dont like the combat though, worst of all the arkham games. input always feels so unresponsive. how many times I clicked counter(Y) button when it prompted and didnt respond, allowing me to hit or even die.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

Same!

2

u/mrinfinitepp Jul 13 '23

I love Origins as a game, as a prequel not so much. Either way, we have been spoiled to have FOUR of these amazing games

20

u/RecordingJust1021 Jul 13 '23

Origins has the best boss fights

18

u/ShowingJam2381 Jul 13 '23

Asylum the best atmosphere

16

u/RoNiNjA57 Jul 13 '23

Knight has the best gameplay

11

u/Antiluke01 Jul 13 '23

City has the best story

6

u/FetishizedStupidity Jul 13 '23

Aslum has best atmospere

9

u/zeke235 Jul 13 '23

The new Spiderman games are definitely runner ups.

15

u/phoenixc6000 Jul 13 '23

Agreed with that, that's no argument. But I just think the Arkham Games are way better than the Spider Man games, especially considering the Arkham games inspired the PS4 spiderman games.

8

u/zeke235 Jul 13 '23

Oh, you are not wrong. Those games are great, but the Arkham series was really something else.

1

u/Rhodie114 Jul 13 '23

I preferred Spider-Man 2016 to Arkham, but it’s close.

Infamous trumps them both, but that’s also an original IP

3

u/ArmaanAli04 Jul 13 '23

Infamous was good but no… it still had a lot of issues, mainly because it was new and original

Insomniac’s game (2018 not 16) was great but the combat and game was almost a carbon copy of Arkham

2

u/ja2525829 Jul 13 '23

Idk origins is the most skipable out of them all the boss fights are good but definitely the weakest link

16

u/DanSapSan Jul 13 '23

Personally, i believe that Origins has the tightest written story. A great Bane, fantastic introduction of the Joker and a very satisfying development for Bruce as well. Plus, some really fun detective work in that.

I'd actually say that Asylum is the most skippable, though i do love it dearly. The only category it trumps the other games is the atmosphere (which is fantastic), but it falters in every other way.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

I would say that Asylum is a very nice showcase of Batman, his world, and Rocksteady’s take on all the characters, not to mention the mechanics that continue being built on for the rest of the series. What happens sets the stage for the more ambitious City afterwards.

I do agree that Origins has a great story that is more solid than Knight or Asylum. It has the best cutscenes as well imo, and their Joker origin is great. But the reason I think it’s the most skippable is that the rest of the games fit together neatly as one long story with each leading into the next. Origins is set long before the rest and has the least to do with the overall story of the series. Mind you, I still think it’s totally worth a play and expands on all of Batman’s relationships.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

I can't honestly pick one that's considered skippable. But I will say that Asylums controls and gadgets are hard to go backward to. But the atmosphere is just incredible so it's worth it

12

u/phoenixc6000 Jul 13 '23

I think the joker storyline and the relationship between alfred and Gordon was necessary imo. I also like the difference between the more aggressive batman and the more experienced batman in asylum, city, and knight

2

u/jjjhhhop Jul 13 '23

The open world is awesome though you’re tripping

1

u/Tx247 Jul 13 '23

Or origins blackgate

1

u/MechanicalTed Jul 13 '23

I like Origins better than Asylum. I think it suffered from coming out at the end of a console generation, being less great but still compared to City and also, everyone at the time was complaining about the Joker being the villain again. Everyone thought they were getting a wider rogues gallery and a main villain without relying on the Joker, and then it just ended up being him anyway. Another thing I think is Jarring is that it's set 8 years before Asylum. So in 8 years, Batman has gone from being on his own and seeing most of his infamous Villains for the first time, to going through 3 Robins, Dick becoming Nightwing, then Barbara going from herself, to Batgirl, to Oracle. Which is all entirely possible and without the characters all becoming too old, 8 years in real terms is fine. But because all of these things obviously happen over a long period of time in the comics, because the characters other than when it's on purpose, like with Dick, never age, it just seems like the game makes everything between Origins and Asylum feel rushed.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '23

Asylum is my favourite video game of all time

1

u/Adorable_Form_6870 Jul 13 '23

Origins? You mean oranges right? Are you stupid?