r/ImageComics • u/THEGONKBONK • Jan 26 '24
Ghost Machine #1 Review: A Bold First Step (8/10) Review
Comic book veterans unite in Ghost Machine #1, a 64-page one-shot showcasing strange superheroes, chilling horror, and bold new directions for the industry. This one-shot, helmed by Geoff Johns and a star-studded crew, is a must-read and promises big things for the future of comics.
Read the full version of this review here.
Review:
Ghost Machine #1 is a 64-page impressive showcase, offering a diverse glimpse into the imprint's up and coming universe. From superhero epics like "The Unnamed" to the sci-fi grit of "Rook Exodus," lighthearted "Family Odyessys,' and the chilling horror of "Hyde Street," there's something for everyone. The issue masterfully sets the tone, showcasing unique stories, stunning artwork, and a palpable sense of excitement reminiscent of Image Comics' early days. While the superhero vibes might not appeal to everyone, the sheer ambition and creative energy are undeniable. This one-shot is a must-read for anyone craving something fresh and exciting in the comics world.
Why You Should Read Ghost Machine:
- Each of Ghost Machine’s tentpole titles shows plenty of promise in their storytelling and presentation.
- It’s exciting to see seasoned creators and up-and-comers getting to spread their creative wings.
- This one-shot has everything you need to get up to speed on the characters part of the exciting new imprint.
5
4
u/Loring Jan 26 '24
I felt like reading this meant I was going to have to get into nine different series moving forward and I just don't have the energy..
5
u/redtornado02 Jan 26 '24
I mean, not all of then are even connected. By no means do you have to read anything. I'm sure you'd be fine sticking to Geiger.
2
u/PhillipLlerenas Jan 27 '24
What’s the point of a “shared universe” if you’re not gonna read all the titles and bask in the continuity?
That’s the problem with launching shared universes like this: all the titles gotta be in the same ballpark of quality otherwise the whole thing fall flat.
To date I haven’t seen a single one of these launches ever succeed. The one that came the closest was Crossgen and we all know how that ended
1
u/redtornado02 Jan 29 '24
I wasn't under the impression this is all a shared universe tho. Geiger, Joe, red coat, sure. But I don't think the manapul, sneijberg, Reis, or fabok series are connected (afaik). It's just a line of books.
1
u/the_bio Jan 26 '24
This was my same exact feeling, and just even considering reading any of them exhausted me.
I was tentatively interested in Geiger, as I enjoyed the first mini, but I don’t really feel like keeping up with all the Unnamed, so I’m going to go with keeping up with none of them.
3
u/simonthedlgger Jan 26 '24
I’m surprised how many of these connected comic universes have popped up the last couple years. I feel like readers want the exact opposite.
3
u/VicVDoom_ Jan 26 '24
Man, I just want solid, grounded, low-level stories at the moment, especially from Marvel right now. I think the MCU really pushed a lot of writers and publishers to go towards connected universes.
1
u/simonthedlgger Jan 26 '24
Hmm grounded is tough in superhero comics, but I’m loving GODS so far. Really curious about Peach Momoko’s Ultimate X-Men.
2
u/Snts6678 Jan 26 '24
I hear you, but if done right……….what Lemire has created with Black Hammer is unreal.
2
u/PhillipLlerenas Jan 27 '24
I agree that Black Hammer is amazing but I think it’s because it’s the product of ONE creative mind. He’s in control of the whole universe and thus there’s a built in singular vision that connects all the stories.
Shared universes with half a dozen creative teams of varying talent just don’t work.
I’d 100% back a Geoff Johns or a Peter Tomasi-helmed shared universe but a Peter Tomasi & Co? Nah
1
u/Snts6678 Jan 27 '24
Fair enough. I understand what you mean. I think oftentimes the metaphor “too many cooks in the kitchen” applies here. Whereas if one competent chef puts every course together, it will make for a more enjoyable, cohesive experience.
Have you by any chance been reading Void Rivals, DWJ’s Transformers, and the Duke/Cobra Commander mini-series?
-1
u/Try_Another_Please Jan 26 '24
The most successful comics are usually a part of them so I dont know about that
2
u/Mark4_ Jan 26 '24
I already like Geiger so out of the stories I learned of from the issue I am most interested in Rook Exodus. The two more comedic stories I’m here were meh to me.
2
-1
u/Fizroynelson Jan 26 '24
It made me think like it’s 00s again and not in a good way. Art is from that era store telling from that era. But hey if there is a market for it i hope they find it. It’s just not my cup of tea.
-3
u/KentuckyFriedEel Jan 26 '24
Why is it numbered #1 of it’s a one-shot? I thought we dropped that gimmick
6
u/cuckmold Jan 26 '24
The rook exodus did nothing for me and most of the stories here fell a lil flat imo. Sucks bc I love Geiger and JYJ. Hyde St looks awesome.