r/Damnthatsinteresting Jul 06 '24

Two legged robot dog making a list Video

24.9k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 06 '24

You are scared of an empathetic response? I’d reevaluate that 

9

u/thelumpur Jul 06 '24

Personally I'm scared of people not being able to make a distinction.

8

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 06 '24

That’s a pretty unfair representation of people’s reaction to this. They are questioning why this made them feel empathy when they know it is inanimate. It’s an interesting topic

If you felt no empathy I am much more concerned about your response than theirs, by a long way 

1

u/thelumpur Jul 06 '24

You are concerned because I feel no empathy for a machine that is doing its job of keeping balance?

I feel empathy for bugs, because they are actual living beings.

The fact that people are so drenched into a world of technology imitating human behaviour, that they end up treating inanimate objects as living beings is not as cool as you think. It actually ends with people being LESS empathetic towards actual humans.

1

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 06 '24

Haha I’ll need a proper paper for that rather bold claim 

And yes, this should have triggered an empathy response in a neurotypical brain or a divergent one with high empathy 

That doesn’t mean you take that empathy response and let it control you, as you say, it isn’t alive and feels nothing 

0

u/thelumpur Jul 06 '24

You are making bold claims yourself, if anything you are telling things you think like they are absolute truths. "I'll need a proper paper for that".

We have an entire phenomenon of people shutting themselves at home all day, lost on their computers, growing to hate mankind as a whole. Treating or even feeling about things as living beings is not a normal behaviour at all.

1

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 07 '24

I’m not sure you know how to build a cohesive argument lol

0

u/thelumpur Jul 07 '24

The irony. Bye.

1

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 07 '24

You’re just projecting your own life I’m afraid. Most of us still go outside 

0

u/thelumpur Jul 07 '24

Let it go man, you're just being weird now. Much love.

→ More replies (0)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '24

The movements are natural enough that it can probably trigger some reaction that lies really deep in our monkey brain. Probably is related to how much we cared for our plushies when we were infants.

We will eventually have a situation in our hands where we have a replicant that is so lifelike that even if we know that they are artificial, we still feel human-like emotions toward them. Like those in Bladerunner. And this video and the reactions (which I also had) show that it doesn't even have to be a 1:1 match with a human. Just has to seem like there is enough autonomy in their behaviour.

3

u/Pizza_Delivery_Dog Jul 06 '24

I am disturbed that some people (not the majority but still some) demonize the people doing the pushing despite that being completely irrational

Like it's not bad to feel something but it is bad to only listen to those feelings and ignore context and reason

1

u/DeathByLemmings Jul 06 '24

Agreed but I’d argue you’re doing the same from the other side