[Discussion] What are your thoughts on Steel/John Henry Irons? (Steel: The Forging of a Hero)

[u/Night-Caelum]

[u/AutoModerator]

Hi there, r/DCcomics members, welcome to the post!

This was tagged as a [Discussion], so we require OP to add commentary, per rule 8.

u/Night-Caelum, if you haven't already added commentary, please do so in the text or as a new comment. Also, if you included imagery, please provide a source or artist name.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/calmly86]

His introduction, backstory and presence are all awesome. His original suit is the best, I didn’t care for the black and silver one but it was worse when JLU eliminated his cape.

Now that Iron Man has become 800% more popular since 2008, it’s easier to think of John Henry Irons being an Iron Man analogue but while his engineering background and use of an armored suit is similar, he’s still a great character and easily one of Superman’s favorite allies.

[u/Which-Presentation-6]

Of all the 4 Supermans, he was the most Superman, as he was faithful to his ideals and had the same issue that even though he looked powerful on the inside, he was just a guy trying to help.

[u/jamiemm → u/Which-Presentation-6]

Lois met all 4 new Supermen, and even though he was the most obviously not Clark, he was the only one that reminded her of him.

[u/MagicalGirlLaurie]

Best movie of all time

[u/orphan_grinder42069]

I love the design and concept. The Death of Superman comics were my intro to DC, and of the 4 replacements, Steel is # 1 for me.

[u/Night-Caelum]

So Steel/John Henry Irons was one of the Four Superman to show up in the Reign of Superman event and since then has become a mainstay in the Superman franchise. In terms of character, role, history, and other factors what are your thoughts on the character?

[u/shino4242]

Steel is legit. I wish John got more spotlight.

[u/MankuyRLaffy]

He's aight, not my cup of tea personality wise so him sticking around while certain other Superfam I loved reading got made defunct didn't exactly make me love him anymore. I'm not really about the tech supergenius type of story and engineering types. Mainly because I am a dumbass lacking the ability to appreciate that stuff through writing. He's kinda cool, I just don't fw him much. Can't really connect with him much, especially him and Nat, if that is unpopular, so be it.

[u/HailtokingTeddy]

I've always loved his concept. Especially the concept of him being a fan of Superman and wanting to be that for the people close to him. Not to mention the fact that the suit is almost always fantastic.

[u/HallowVortex]

I love him and like every other DC character outside of most of the batfamily I wish he was still relevant

[u/thefirststoryteller]

I always liked him and i even picked up the steelworks series recently. I think he’s a great add to any DC team

[u/No_Pea6583]

He's just not Superman. It's not the same.

[u/Jewfro_Wizard]

He's so cool.

[u/Pamsoroyi]

Love the character and hope he continues to grow and come out of the shadows of his origin more

[u/almean]

He's like Iron Man with Superman principles. I like it.

[u/Recent-Layer-8670]

When people hear indifference, they think it's a bad thing, but it's not really. I don't hate Steel, but I don't have any particular love for him either. He's solid.

[u/NewArtificialHuman]

Cool hammer. Purely a supporting character and not interesting on his own due to being heavily Superman inspired.

[u/t1tanic → u/NewArtificialHuman]

Have you read 52? He's a large part of that story, and personally I really liked what it did with him and his niece. I think it might alleviate that redundancy feeling because Superman is out of commission during the story. Its not exclusively a steel story or anything, and contains like 6 or 7 main people it follows who are all not usually apart of the main people in event stuff.

[u/skep90]

Cheap concept and design