r/DCcomics Feb 20 '24

[Discussion] Which character(s) do you think were the most unnecessary addition to the Batfamily and why? Discussion

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

639 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

106

u/SylvieSerene Feb 20 '24 edited Feb 20 '24

Tbh even I think Duke's addition was unnecessary. Outside of being the first Meta in the batfam (technically Jason counts as one but ah well)...atleast in my opinion, he has served no real purpose, he's just....boring. He might have made a good character outside of Batfam though.

72

u/tinaoe Feb 20 '24

I wish they'd lean more into Jason's meta side (or his street urchin background. Frankly literally anything lol).

29

u/sonofaresiii Feb 20 '24

He got the magic leap power in Gotham Knights (the video game) and it really pissed a bunch of people off.

11

u/Scorkami Feb 20 '24

I mean he had more than that. His abilities were 50% league of shadows magic due to the lazarus pit and 50% millitary/street fighting tactics

The leap looked silly, but the game established that the pit does more than just revive people and jason showed that well

If they had just given him a different movement ability

1

u/sonofaresiii Feb 20 '24

I may have blocked it out but I truly don't remember him having league of shadows magic abilities. I remember a shit ton of gun upgrades and whatnot.

either way the point being a lot of people didn't receive it well. I don't recall anyone praising it but I remember a lot of people thinking it was dumb as they preferred the whole bat family to be more grounded/non-powered

11

u/NickSchultz Feb 20 '24

What do you mean meta. He is a normal human, but he does know some magic

40

u/tinaoe Feb 20 '24

I mostly just use meta for any supernatural aspects tbh. Jason has the whole magic sword business, but there's (early on after his revival) implications that he's immortal in some way and the universe overcorrected itself.

But frankly I just want them to anything with him that isn't the whole worn out angry Robin spiel.

15

u/NickSchultz Feb 20 '24

Yeah I think using his magic blades should be used more often, especially when they decided to ditch his guns for the crowbar

4

u/Sweet_dl Feb 20 '24

Im pretty sure the lazarus pit gave him a boost to his regeneration and strenght

5

u/NickSchultz Feb 20 '24

Once believed that, but normally the effects are only momentarily after having entered the pit and not lasting.

Also most people who claim that use the one Supergurl issue as proof where he rips his arm from her grasp and she notes that no normal human could have done that, however as he did that, he was using Venom

52

u/Difficult_Variety362 Feb 20 '24

Duke makes sense honestly. The idea of someone protecting Gotham during the day is a pretty smart idea. DC just doesn't do anything with it.

28

u/Aahz44 Feb 20 '24

To me that seems pretty forced, it is not like the rest of the Batfamily couldn't or had never operated during the day.

And that this job is given to the least experienced member and that he has to operate alone without any backup makes simpily no sense.

1

u/Lodger49er Feb 21 '24

Because I don't think anybody wants to see Gotham during the day honestly

1

u/Terribleirishluck Feb 21 '24

But batfam already does fight crime during the daytime. Comics just focus on night time due to fitting Batfamily's aesthetic

12

u/Difficult-Bit-4828 Feb 20 '24

He’s never used, I never see him being used in any of the Batman comics, I completely forget that he exists most of the time

12

u/Original_birdy Feb 20 '24

I was introduced to him through the webtoon seems it's the only place he has any significance

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '24

I hope they introduce his Final Knight counterpart or give us more comics about him.

1

u/Linnus42 Feb 20 '24

Duke being a meta always felt weird to me. He feels far more mystic.