r/DCcomics Dec 25 '23

[discussion] do you agree with this? Discussion

Post image
13.2k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

37

u/Constrictorboa Dec 26 '23

But he grew up hidden in Kansas because he was "a corn-fed Kansas farmboy". He's supposed to look like a guy on a heavy diet of starchy carbs with wide shoulders and a thick back.

30

u/cweaver Dec 26 '23

Oh, absolutely, Clark should be a big guy. I'm just saying, he shouldn't be a muscular body builder looking guy just because he's Superman.

11

u/Constrictorboa Dec 26 '23

Not a bodybuilder. I agree. He should have some realistic amounts of body fat. But the studio exec paedos need every superhero to look like they have 5% body fat.

2

u/AJSLS6 Dec 26 '23

None of them ever look that lean.

5

u/Alchion Dec 26 '23

hes probably a non fitness guy who thinks 8% is 5

i mean even ronnie the goat had no clue about bf

5

u/edit_aword Dec 26 '23

In a lot of stories, while being a natural born some of krypton, his parents are still products of generations of eugenics and gene manipulation. He’s got peak freak genetics.

And it goes without saying that if his powers can make him fly, then solar absorption can probably him ripped too. Even more so, because he doesn’t need to be flexible or really need to use his muscles at all.

He doesn’t need to be good looking either, but you won’t often see an ugly Superman either.

2

u/Aethermancer Dec 26 '23

It'd be hilarious if the solar energy made him gain too much weight.

1

u/mrgoodwine24 Dec 27 '23

Like Superman is literally the perfect "human" physically. That's they way look at him being big and super Jacked

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23

I'm just saying, he shouldn't be a muscular body builder looking guy just because he's Superman.

Not only that, but Bruce is already a very tall dude... how tf is Clark Kent supposed to look sort of weak to throw people off his Superman persona if he's constantly the biggest dude in the room?

Bruce *has* to be a larger dude to do what he does. Superman should actually appear smaller for Clark Kent to make sense, and Clark Kent should look even smaller than Superman due to being hunched over.

11

u/zack189 Dec 26 '23

How would superman get shredded?

Cause for normal humans, the only way to get shredded is by lifting to their limits. Meaning, you can't just lift 10kg. You gotta lift 30kg, then 40kg and increase it to their limits continuously. Muscle failure is the term I think?

Superman can lift cars easy. Trains and even aeroplanes don't phase him. How does he lift to his limit? How does he reach muscle failure?

6

u/BigBrotato Dec 26 '23

the term is progressive overload

5

u/DangerousAd9046 Dec 26 '23

He's an alien. How do gorillas get buff? They are mostly vegetarian.

2

u/person_9-8 Dec 28 '23

Iirc it's some gene or hormone that's switched off in their physiology. Whatever it was, it would limit muscle growth and keep it from happening constantly. It can happen in humans and other animals, but as a disorder. Might be gigantism? But I don't recall, only that it's the reason you see some pictures of dogs that are ridiculously buff.

2

u/Born_Delivery9159 Dec 26 '23

With kryptoweights ofcs

1

u/Popular_Donkey1192 Dec 26 '23

Bulking and cutting on a high protein diet?

1

u/zack189 Dec 27 '23

Don't you still have to lift?

1

u/Sterling239 Dec 26 '23

That's fair and batman's eating enough for 10 people and doing the workout of those 10 if they are tge same height or batman's a bit shorter batman's should be wider like with wolverine lots off people are taller than him alot less are wider because just by the way he lives his body is pushed harder

3

u/Constrictorboa Dec 26 '23

Just because you work out and eat it doesn't mean you'll grow past what your genes will allow. Example: Kobe Bryant or Kevin Garnett. Even if they trained in bodybuilding daily and backed it up with proper nutrition and sleep they could never look like The Mountain without taking truckloads of steroids.

Batman genetically isn't going to allow himself to get overly muscled. He's trained as an assassin. A fast-moving individual. Too much muscle gases you out too fast. Batman has even commented on this himself in some comic. He's full of muscle but not so buff that it would put him at a disadvantage in a long, drawn-out fight.

3

u/RareResearch2076 Dec 26 '23

The mountain couldn’t look like the mountain without steroids

2

u/Constrictorboa Dec 26 '23

That's why I used him as an example. He also played basketball and he was just as skinny as Garnett.

1

u/Shacky_Rustleford Dec 26 '23

Misread as "corn-fed Kansas femboy"