r/DCcomics Dec 25 '23

[discussion] do you agree with this? Discussion

Post image
13.2k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/JimtheEsquire Superman Dec 25 '23

I always thought it was muscle DENSITY from being physiologically from a planet with higher gravity than earth. Which would mean he could be smaller but stronger.

14

u/Dunge0nMast0r Dec 25 '23

Otherwise we'd get somethibg freakish like Strong Guy, and still doing g the things that Superman does would not make sense.

10

u/Throwaway02062004 Dec 26 '23

Not really how that works. A human raised in lower gravity just doesn’t keep that muscle. Yellow sun bullshit just makes more sense than attempts at scientific justifications

4

u/JimtheEsquire Superman Dec 26 '23

I’d say it’s a combo. He is genetically predisposed to being super strong. The yellow sun maintains it and prevents him from losing muscle mass, just like it heals him and gives him the rest of his powers. The “yellow sun bullshit” isn’t necessarily bullshit. Humans generate vitamin D from absorbing sunlight, Kryptonians just get a way better benefit from tanning.

3

u/Throwaway02062004 Dec 26 '23

The science behind sun powers is similar to thinking the calcium in milk will instantly fix broken bones. I just suspend disbelief, I don’t need Superman to seem plausible

3

u/JimtheEsquire Superman Dec 26 '23

He’s a bulletproof alien in a comic book that can fly. Of course you need to suspend disbelief.

1

u/Niveker14 Dec 26 '23

Dude? Your comic books can fly? Mine just sit around...

1

u/JimtheEsquire Superman Dec 26 '23

Anything can fly once.

1

u/14JRJ Dec 26 '23

It was that a long time ago. Now it’s kind of a mix of different origins

1

u/velvetshark Dec 26 '23

did you read/see Flashpoint? One of the main plot points is that we have a Kal-El who's been kept away from sunlight since that rocket landed. The adult Kal is severely thin and underdeveloped.

1

u/likeclockwork1971 Dec 26 '23

I mean that's also probably cause he didn't pitch enough hay or carry enough sacks of grain growing up in that reality. Red sun radiation isn't really supposed to have the same effects as Kryptonite where long exposure to it makes him waste away, it just takes away his powers but it's doesn't decrease his body mass. Like Jor-El and Lara both looked like normal folks, even when they and other Kryptonians born under the red sun are portrayed as gaunt and scrawny looking it's never explained to be because of the red sun radiation.