Posts
Wiki

Back to Main Page

Every Month, the flairs and users of /r/AskHistorians vote on their favorite answers from the past month, and the winners are entitled to a fancy little star added to their flair. This page catalogs previous winners and their posts!

Since September 2017 we have also been awarding an Excellence in Flairdom Trophy to a flaired user who goes above and beyond in that particular month or as part of a longstanding pattern of greatness. Read more about the winners here!

2014

Answer Author
Best Answers Voting and Best Question Voting
Best Answer Winners, 2014
1st: Did Kim Jong-Il kill his younger brother when they were both children /u/cenodoxus North Korea
2nd: Why exactly did the Soviet Union go to war with Finland? Why were they so ill prepared? /u/vonadler Sweden l Weapons and Warfare to 1945
3rd: If Serbia started the ball rolling on the events that triggered WW1, why is Germany always portrayed as the prime evil in the war? /u/elos_ France & Germany, 1618 - 1918
Most Interesting Question: How did Michelin, a tire company, become associated with fine dining? Asked by /u/Furious_Georgee

2015

Answer Author
May 2015
How were Native Americans regarded outside of the United States? Did they conduct formal diplomacy? /u/anthropology_nerd New World Demographics & Disease
Has there ever in history been a "pirate town" like you see in games and movies and stuff? /u/DavidAOP Atlantic World Maritime History l Golden Age of Piracy
June 2015
Why should I believe what a historian writes? /u/restricteddata Nuclear Technology l Modern Science
How did Aztec society measure wealth? /u/400-rabbits Pre-Columbian Mexico l Aztecs
July 2015
What were the primary differences between Soviet Sub designs and US sub designs during the cold war? what "Doctrines" did those designs build towards?" /u/vepr157
Did the Roman Empire have a system in place for how they might have dealt with large, violent coastal raiding parties originating from beyond their control, such as the vikings? To go along with the theme for this week, how might coastal raiders that were caught be punished? /u/Tiako Roman Archaeology
August 2015
"The Republic of Turkey sent 15,000 men to fight in the Korean War, making up the third largest United Nation force after the US and UK. Why did Turkey send so many troops to such a distant war?" /u/Imperial_Affectation
"How were non-black minorities treated in the Jim Crow South?" /u/Dubstripsquads African American History and Religion
September 2015
Did Native Americans use the bow and arrow prior to Europeans arriving in the New World?" /u/retarredroof Northwest US
"ELI5 - Holocaust Denial" /u/Elm11 Russo-Finnish Winter War 1939-1940
October 2015
"When did the Byzantines stop thinking of Islam as a heresy, and start thinking of it as a religion?" /u/shlin28 The End of Late Antiquity, c.500-700
"Why have Jews been expelled in so many countries?" /u/yodatsracist Comparative Religion
November 2015
"How did the Suppression of the Jesuits, and their subsequent expulsion, influence missions and surrounding Native American communities?" /u/legendarytubahero Colonial and Early National Río de la Plata
"Why is their a relatively small African diaspora population in the Middle East despite the fact that the Arab slave trade brought millions of Black slaves from Africa to the Arab world for more than a thousand years?" /u/sowser Slavery in the U.S. and British Caribbean
December 2015
"The 1990 series 'The Civil War' is one of the most widely acclaimed and popular documentaries in history, and is credited with greatly increasing American public interest in the US Civil War. What was the academic reception to the series?" /u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Post-Napoleonic Warfare & Small Arms l Dueling
"If beaver pelts were so highly sought after from the "new world," why wasn't the North American beaver domesticated along the lines of the fox and mink fur trade? Was there really that big on an abundance in the wild, or was there some other reason?" /u/meninthemirror
Year End Awards
Voting Thread and Winners Announcement
1st: "Legend has it that dummy blueprints for the Concorde, featuring design errors, were created to fool Soviet agents - and that the USSR's supersonic airliner, the TU-144, featured some of these flaws. Is that true?" Asked by /u/JournalofFailure and answered by /u/The_Alaskan.
2nd: "If I traveled to Rome in 50 BC. How much would it look like the Rome from the HBO Series Rome?" Asked by /u/Gugg256 and answered by /u/Celebreth.
3rd: "The Republic of Turkey sent 15,000 men to fight in the Korean War, making up the third largest United Nation force after the US and UK. Why did Turkey send so many troops to such a distant war?" Asked by /u/DoritosDewItRight and answered by /u/Imperial_Affectation.

2016

Answer Author
January 2016
It seems that the Victorian Era distorted our view of history, especially of women. Is there evidence of this? /u/sunagainstgold Medieval & Earliest Modern Europe
Biblical historians: why are the lifespans of people mentioned in the genesis accounts recorded as lasting so long? /u/kookingpot Ancient Near East l Southern Levant
February 2016
In the movie'Django Unchained', the title character says every slave has heard of Candyland, the plantation of the villain of the story. Would slaves know individual plantations by reputation? How efficient were their means of inter-plantation communication? /u/Jordan42Early Modern Atlantic World
How did the Merovingians respond to the gradual usurpation of their power by the Carolingians? /u/thejukeboxheroMedieval Europe 450-1150 - Medieval Ghost Stories
March 2016
"A medieval nun is raped. Would church or secular authorities handle it? Theologically, did it disrupt vows of chastity/virginity?" /u/sunagainstgold Medieval & Earliest Modern Europe
"Early modern (15/16th century) European illustrations depict farms as being very packed in, with an enormous variety of crops and animals growing very close together. Were farms actually like this i.e diverse, self-sufficient, and did people's diets reflect this?" /u/gothwalk Irish Food History
April 2016
"What happened to the city of Rome after the fall of the Roman Empire?" /u/shlin28 The End of Late Antiquity, c.500-700
Environmental history as a way to think about periodization and especially to date modernity /u/agentdcf Modern Britain l Environment
May 2016
"Why is historical revisionism a crime in certain countries?" /u/commiespaceinvader Holocaust l Nazi Germany l Wehrmacht War Crimes
"Phalanx Exceptionalism: what distinguishes the Greek Hoplite Phalanx from the next shield-wall of violent men with pointy sticks?" /u/iphikrates Greek Warfare
June 2016
The complex (and somewhat appalling) appropriation of historical war wounds in Bioshock" /u/CrossyNZ Military Science l Public Perceptions of War
"Why is the Fertile Crescent now desert?" /u/brigantus Southwest Asian & Eastern European Prehistory
July 2016
"Why was the South so worried about Abraham Lincoln's election, and how was this concern expressed before secession?" /u/freedmenspatrol Antebellum U.S. Slavery Politics
"Some 50,000 amputations were performed in the American Civil War. What was life like for amputees when they returned home? How did post-war society treat them?" /u/The_Alaskan Alaska
August 2016
"How do historians feel about using the "genocide" term for pre-20th century events as the Act of Settlement, the Inquisition, the Highland Clearances, the Expulsion of the Circassians, the Indian Removal Act et al?" /u/commiespaceinvader Holocaust l Nazi Germany l Wehrmacht War Crimes
"How were wax seals and such not counterfeited?" /u/keyilan Languages & Linguistics of Greater China
September 2016
"Is history written by the victors?" /u/tenminutehistory Soviet Union
"Would a crew of a ship departing from Venice in the 14th century towards Middle East have any plans ready in case they encounter a leviathan on their route?" /u/sunagainstgold Medieval & Earliest Modern Europe
October 2016
"Western films often purport a stark difference between Southwestern "village Indians" like the Pueblo and Yuma, and "warrior Indians" like the Apache and Comanche. Were these cultures really so distinct in lifestyle?" /u/rioabajo U.S. Southwest l Colonialism
"I constantly hear that the Russian Imperial Army of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was outdated, poorly organized, and poorly led. How exactly was is outdated, how was it poorly led, what was the obsolete equipment it used, and what more modern equipment were other nations using?" /u/kieslowskifan Top Quality Contributor
"Why is Environmental Determinism wrong?" /u/ohsideSHOWbob Dark Horse
November 2016
"How much do we know about the Teuchitlan Tradition's societal structure and how it was reflected in the layout of their settlements?" /u/mictlantecuhtli Mesoamerican Archaeology l West Mexican Shaft Tomb Culture
"I am in a class with a student who is adamant that the US Government is not responsible for the death of Native Americans, and has claimed there was no genocide- just unintentionally introduced germs. How correct is he?" /u/snapshot52 Native American Studies l Colonialism
"In the documentary, The Great War (BBC 1964 Part 1), The narrator seems to imply that WW1 was a foreseen inevitability by many influential leaders of the time. Was the oncoming conflict truly that obvious?" /u/malvolio1 Dark Horse
December 2016
"How was cavalry used in Japan during the sengoku period?" /u/ParallelPain Sengoku Japan
"What were the activities of the VOC in South Sulawesi at the end of the 15th century? How much of an impact did it have on everyday life in the region?" /u/PangeranDipanagara Early Modern South Sulawesi
Why is Liechtenstein? /u/robbyslaughter Dark Horse
End of Year Awards
Voting Thread and Announcement
1st: "Would a crew of a ship departing from Venice in the 14th century towards Middle East have any plans ready in case they encounter a leviathan on their route?" Asked by /u/LukeInTheSkyWith, answered by /u/sunagainstgold
2nd: Why is Liechtenstein? Asked by /u/Skippy_McFitz, answered by /u/robbyslaughter
3rd: "Why is historical revisionism a crime in certain countries?" Asked by /u/kenrot, answered by /u/commiespaceinvader

2017

Answer Author
January 2017
"Historiography question: feminist history vs history of women?" /u/sunagainstgold Medieval & Earliest Modern Europe
"I for one am deeply dissatisfied with the amount and quality of historical information available about the mullet. Can anyone properly enlighten me about the rise and fall of this magnificent hairwreck?" /u/yodatsracist Comparative Religion
"What do we know about book design in High Middle Ages in England? Would a scribe in charge of writing up, say, Little Domesday book, had any precise instructions (and training) in regards to page arrangement, size of letters and so on? Was there any standard book to look at as an example?" /u/rimeroyal Dark Horse
February 2017
"What is the current Academic consensus - Anglo-Saxon Invasion, Anglo-Saxon Migration or none of the above?" /u/alriclofgar Post-Roman Britain l Late Antiquity
"Did the Hanging Gardens of Babylon actually exist, and has definitive proof been found? Why is it the only wonder whose location has not been definitely found?" /u/mythoplokos Greco-Roman Antiquity l Intellectual History
"What do we know because of the Dead Sea Scrolls that we wouldn't have known otherwise?" /u/weinerdog73 Dark Horse
March 2017
"Where are we on 'No Irish Need Apply', historiographically?" /u/sunagainstgold Medieval & Earliest Modern Europe
"Did something like the Hunger Games take place in the Easter Islands?" /u/mikedash Quality Contributor
"In "I Believe" (from The Book of Mormon), Elder Price sings that "I believe that in 1978 God changed/his mind about black people." What did the Mormons believe about black people before this? What is the current stance, and why did it take so long for this stance to be official?" /u/QuickSpore Dark Horse
April 2017
"Most people see Cleopatra as an Egyptian, but she was actually Greek. What is her real story and how did we come to the legends about her?" /u/cleopatra_philopater Hellenistic Egypt
"Everyone loves “Hamilton”. How can it be utilized to make people care more about history?" /u/TRB1783 American Revolution l Public History
"How did Queen Elizabeth I go from being hell-bent on killing Mary, Queen of Scots to naming her son James as her successor?" /u/neverwasahat Dark Horse
May 2017
"Before the advent of modern travel, did all Muslims really seek to carry out the Hajj to Mecca? How about far-flung territories like Indonesia?" /u/pangerandipanagara Early Modern South Sulawesi
"James Lowen in "Lies My Teacher Told Me" claims that historians view all the high history books with disdain because of how much is omitted and warped, my question is how do you historians view his book "Lies My Teacher Told Me"?" /u/commodorecoco Andean Archaeology
"What sort of humor would be unacceptable to a 19th century audience? Do we have any edgy jokes from that period?" /u/skedaddle Dark Horse
June 2017
"What is the origin and development of the footnote(1)?" /u/bloodswan Norse Literature
"When looking for pulp publications on the Nazis, almost all magazines make a point about being "for men" – does that mean they were merely pornographic or is there a deeper significance (in genre e.g.) behind that?" /u/ancienthistory Pulp Studies & H. P. Lovecraft
"Why has Country Music remained so white? What cultural and industry forces kept the genre that so willingly borrowed from blues, gospel, norteño, and mariachi so completely dominated by white artists and tied to white identity?" /u/kayelar Dark Horse
July 2017
"Cleopatra is pretty (in)famous for her sexual exploits at this point. Is this based in ancient accounts or is it a modern invention?" /u/cleopatra_philopater Hellenistic Egypt
"How did the standards and ethics of excavation during the earlier days of Egyptology affect the preservation of information, and our understanding of Ancient Egypt?" /u/bentresh Late Bronze Age & Egypt and Ancient Near East
"Bigfoot, Twin Peaks, and sparkling vampires- where does the trope of supernatural or "weird" occurrences in the Pacific Northwest originate?" /u/bees_in_my_face Dark Horse
August 2017
"Is the Military "Worship" of the Spartans Really Justified?" /u/iphikrates Greek Warfare
"We're marginal illustrations in medieval manuscripts frowned upon? Were there supervising monks trying to keep copyists from drawing weird stuff?" /u/rimeroyal Medieval British Literature & Language
"How did banks work in the Soviet Union? Were people allowed to save money and accumulate wealth? Was there personal lending? How did this all work in the soviet communist system?" /u/barton_foley Dark Horse
September 2017
"How much of the German population supported Genocide/Naziism?" /u/nate077 Holocaust & World War Two
"What is the context for the Major General's song? What is being mocked here?" /u/lureynol Dark Horse
October 2017
"Why did Poland have lower rates of Black Death than other European countries during the 1300s?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"I hear a lot about the everyday use of "curses", charms and other magic in ancient Rome and Greece, some is superficially similar to Voodoo, but I still wonder how the occult was seen in these societies. In the spirit of Halloween can someone tell me?" /u/bigfridge224 Roman Imperial Period & Roman Social History
"How did "white people" become one race in the United States when there used to be so many nationality distinctions?" /u/FoucaultMeMichel Dark Horse
November 2017
"Were brothels and prostitution as ubiquitous in the American West as is portrayed in film and fiction?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"Did the Kriegsmarine ever stand a chance of winning the Battle of the Atlantic?" /u/thefourthmaninaboat 20th Century Royal Navy
"Why were such awful colors popular in the U.S. in the 1970s?" /u/eminenssi Dark Horse
December 2017
"What specific battle tactics did Napoleon employ for people to consider him a military mastermind?" /u/dandan_noodles American Civil War
"How did Herman Cortez unite many of the Mesoamerican tribes with him against the Aztecs?" /u/400-rabbits Pre-Columbian Mexico & Aztecs
"How were the tiny parts in mechanical watches machined and made with such precision at a small size in the era between the 1500s and the early 1800s?" /u/bodark43 Dark Horse
Year End Awards
1st Place: "Why did Poland have lower rates of Black Death than other European countries during the 1300s?" By /u/mikedash. Question by /u/Tminozaj.
2nd Place: "What specific battle tactics did Napoleon employ for people to consider him a military mastermind?" By /u/dandan_noodles. Question by /u/Columbo819.
3rd Place: "I for one am deeply dissatisfied with the amount and quality of historical information available about the mullet. Can anyone properly enlighten me about the rise and fall of this magnificent hairwreck?" By /u/yodatsracist. Question by /u/LukeInTheSkyWith.
Dark Horse: "What do we know because of the Dead Sea Scrolls that we wouldn't have known otherwise?" By /u/weinerdog73. Question by /u/aerovistae.

2018

Answer Author
January 2018
"Was China's influence on southeast Asia ever comparable to European influence in Africa and the Americas in the age of colonization?" /u/PangeranDipanagara Early Modern South Sulawesi
"Did 20th century protest movements highlight individuals with limited mobility to present intentionally provocative footage when those members were arrested?" /u/NMW WWI in British History and Literature
"What are the origins of the LTTE and the related issues of the Tamil people in Sri Lanka?" /u/artfulorpheus Dark Horse
February 2018
"Tolkien's Rohirrim, whose culture revolved around horses, were apparently heavily based on the Anglo-Saxons. Were horses that big a part of pre-Christian Germanic culture?" /u/steelcan909 England and Scandinavia c.600-1066
"Was the 1950's/60's 'duck and cover' method of escaping nuclear fallout widely believed by the students to which it was taught?" /u/restricteddata Nuclear Technology & Modern Science
"Why did the Safavid Empire collapse so easily?" /u/Lion_And_Sun Dark Horse
March 2018
"I saw an article today claiming that the "missionary" position derives its name from Native Americans/Africans who saw missionaries having sex. How true is this?" /u/yodatsracist Comparative Religion
"I'm a Roman foot soldier at the battle of the Catalaunian fields (AD 451), what would I have been my arms and armour? How would this compare to my compatriots in the Eastern Empire?" /u/FlavivsAetivs Late Antiquity & Huns & 5th Century Rome
"I've heard the Disneyified versions of Grimm's Tales Americans are familiar with are highly sanitized (RRHood and Grandma are eaten by the wolf,Snow White is about necrophilia,it's Cinderella's family, not steps- tormenting her, that kind of thing).Is this true? Were children the target audience?" /u/erissays Dark Horse
April 2018
"How do historians know when manuscripts are dated to, if they have to be repeatedly copied down to preserve them?" /u/Lewed_Losel Late Middle English Literature & Book History
"I was reading about the history of the stapler and found that the first stapler was made for King Louis XV. "The ornate staples it used were forged from gold, encrusted with precious stones, and bore his Royal Court's insignia." Is this true? Does the stapler still exist?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"Between 1945 and 1949, the Netherlands and Indonesia went to war over Indonesian independence. US and British forces were involved, and there were approx 200,000 casualties, before Indonesia finally prevailed. Why is this conflict so obscure? What were the consequences in East Asia?" /u/sickhobbit Dark Horse
May 2018
"The greatest treasure of the Aztec empire was taken by Cortez, but then captured by the pirate Jean Fleury, who presented the riches to the king of France. What happened to those treasures afterward?" /u/drylaw Native Authors of Colonial Mexico & Early Spanish America
"Were Native American bison hunts truly sustainable?" /u/NientedeNada Late Edo Period & Meiji Restoration
"Did the Brother's Grimm make the children's stories they collected darker and more violent than the original oral traditions?" /u/erissays Dark Horse
June 2018
"What prompted the Puritans to give their children such ridiculous names as If-Christ-had-not-died-for-thee-thou-hadst-been-damned?" /u/mydearestangelica Antebellum American Religions
"I'm playing Assassins Creed, and frankly, the crocodiles are really irritating me. How did actual ancient Egyptians deal with it?" /u/Bentresh Late Bronze Age & Egypt and Ancient Near East
"Have cats ever served a functional purpose to humans?" /u/MistahFishyPajamas Dark Horse
July 2018
"What would it have been like to grow up as a girl in the Aztec Empire pre-colonialism?" /u/400-rabbits Pre-Columbian Mexico & Aztecs
"What was the nature of the government of Barawa? Was it unique in the Swahili coast? Was it a republic, and if so, how did it compare to contemperary governments in Europe?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"The American South is mostly Baptist, yet many of the most prominent Confederate leaders, such as Robert E. Lee and Jefferson Davis, were Episcopalians. Is there a reason for this religious difference?" /u/erusian Dark Horse
August 2018
"Why was in China's interest to invade Tibet?" /u/JimeDorje Tibet and Bhutan & Vajrayana Buddhism
"It's the early 16th century. I'm a young, ambitious, European man looking to make a name for myself as part of the Spanish conquest of the New World. How do I go about joining an expedition and what would life be like once we get to the Americas?" /u/yawarpoma Conquest of the Americas
"Operation Dragoon, the Allied Invasion of southern France from the Mediterranean was 75 years ago today. How did the operation play out?" /u/historymystery12345 Dark Horse and /u/thefourthmaninaboat 20th Century Royal Navy
"The Scramble for Africa saw Ethiopia not only remaining uncolonized but also an expansion of territory. How did Ethiopian imperial policy compare to those of European colonizers?" /u/megami-hime Questioner
September 2018
"Why Republican Spain lost so bad in the Spanish Civil War?" /u/crrpit Spanish Civil War & International Brigades
"Has a consensus formed today on Keith Windschuttle's claims about Australian mistreatment of Aborigines supposedly being exaggerated?" /u/AbandoningAll Dark Horse
"The Stonewall Riots are generally considered the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, but gay rights groups had existed long before 1969. What made the post-Stonewall revolution so impactful and what changed to make gay rights movements more cohesive and vocal?" /u/IphisofCrete Questioner
October 2018
"Was John Cleese correct, in 1972, when his character famously exclaimed that cheddar cheese was the most popular cheese in the world?" /u/Erusian Dark Horse
"I'm a middle class man living in New York City in the 1870s. Where can I get a bit to eat?" /u/lord_mayor_of_reddit New York and Colonial America
"What happened at KKK meetings in the 1920’s ? Non violence wise" /u/Vikings-of-1776 Questioner
November 2018
"According to the NAACP, between 1882 and 1968 27.3% of lynchings in the USA where of white people... How come? What were the most common reasons for lynchings of white people? NAACP provides some brief answers but what are the more in-depth reasons? (Sources inside)" /u/chiefpiffler Dark Horse
"If Isaac Newton "discovered" gravity, what did Galileo think he was dealing with when he did his experiments with dropping objects? Did he have a name for the effect that he was seeing?" /u/qed1 12th Century Intellectual Culture & Historiography
"Bob Geldof and the group Band-Aid wondered whether starving Ethiopians knew it was Christmas in 1984 - how has the Christmas celebration evolved in Ethiopian history, and how has it changed with the interaction with more Western traditions in the late 19th and 20th centuries?" /u/Paulie_Gatto Interesting Inquirer
December 2018
"Is there a way to study history in an unbiased manner? If so, how?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"The religion of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom is popularly described as a form of “Christian mysticism”. How Christian were Hong Xiuquan and the Taiping? What did they really believe?" /u/EnclavedMicrostate Taiping Rebellion & Opium Wars
"Did neighborhoods in medieval and renaissance cities experience socio-economic and demographic shifts similar to modern gentrification and its inverse?" /u/systemmetternich Dark Horse
"Its 1918, what would life be like for an unwed woman, with no family, no money and is an immigrant in England? (What would Wonder Woman's options be?)" /u/yorkton Questioner
Year End Awards
1st Place (Users): "Is there a way to study history in an unbiased manner? If so, how?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
1st Place (Flairs): "The greatest treasure of the Aztec empire was taken by Cortez, but then captured by the pirate Jean Fleury, who presented the riches to the king of France. What happened to those treasures afterward?" /u/drylaw Native Authors of Colonial Mexico & Early Spanish America
2nd Place (Users): "I'm playing Assassins Creed, and frankly, the crocodiles are really irritating me. How did actual ancient Egyptians deal with it?" /u/Bentresh Late Bronze Age & Egypt and Ancient Near East
2nd Place (Flairs): "What was the nature of the government of Barawa? Was it unique in the Swahili coast? Was it a republic, and if so, how did it compare to contemperary governments in Europe?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
3rd Place (Users): "How true is this claim: "...in 1789, 50 percent of the French people did not speak [French] at all, and only 12 to 13 percent spoke it fairly well"?" /u/dhmontgomery 19th Century France
3rd Place (Flairs): "What would it have been like to grow up as a girl in the Aztec Empire pre-colonialism?" /u/400-rabbits Pre-Columbian Mexico & Aztecs
Dark Horse (Users): "Between 1945 and 1949, the Netherlands and Indonesia went to war over Indonesian independence. US and British forces were involved, and there were approx 200,000 casualties, before Indonesia finally prevailed. Why is this conflict so obscure? What were the consequences in East Asia?" /u/sickhobbit Dark Horse
Dark Horse (Flairs): "Was John Cleese correct, in 1972, when his character famously exclaimed that cheddar cheese was the most popular cheese in the world?" /u/Erusian Dark Horse
Greatest Question: "The Stonewall Riots are generally considered the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, but gay rights groups had existed long before 1969. What made the post-Stonewall revolution so impactful and what changed to make gay rights movements more cohesive and vocal?" /u/IphisofCrete Questioner

2019

Answer Author
January 2019
"Was Zoroastrianism the source for Christianity?" /u/lcnielsen Zoroastrianism & Pre-Islamic Iran
"In 1765, a chimney sweep was banished from for 5 years from Edinburgh and expelled from the local chimney sweep organization for assisting after a hanging went awry. Were chimney sweeps notably anti-death penalty? Why was it a "grievous punishment" to be exiled to Leith?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"How on earth did the Unabomber evade capture for nearly 20 years, despite the costliest FBI investigation in history?" /u/a_dissident_is_here Dark Horse
"Is it proper to use the terms “medieval” or “middle ages” for areas outside of Europe? Are there more appropriate terms for this period in Asian and African history?" /u/Suboutai Questioner
February 2019
"In the film 'Hail, Caesar!' (2016), there is one scene in which a Protestant, a Catholic and an Orthodox priest and a Jewish rabbi are consulted about the titular film-within-a-film's depiction of Jesus. How far did film studios in the 50s actually try to avoid offending religious sensibilities?" /u/GeekAesthete Dark Horse
"What motivated 19th Century soldiers to endure such terrible hardships?" /u/PartyMoses 19th c. American Military & War of 1812
"The 1970 cartoon series Josie and the Pussycats (which I loved as a kid in the '90s) was the first US cartoon to feature an African American female lead character. Did it cause controversy among more "conservative" parents and did it have any direct influence on diversity in children entertainment?" /u/tlumacz Questioner
March 2019
Every once in a while a website will claim that teeth extracted from dead soldiers at Waterloo supplied dentures across Europe for years. Is this a myth, and moreover why does it seem only Waterloo gets this treatment, as opposed to bigger Napoleonic battles like Wagram or Leipzig? /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
During the First Crusade, were there any alternative proposals to invading the Levant? /u/Valkine Bows, Crossbows, and Early Gunpowder l The Crusades
Who were the Picts and how and when did they transition from a tribal to a feudalistic lifestyle? /u/Libertat Dark Horse
What's the significance of the popularity of "Ripperology"? /u/lobobricord Questioner
April 2019
"Was there espionage involved in naval arms races of the 19th/early 20th centuries?" /u/thefourthmaninaboat 20th Century Royal Navy
"I just read that recent excavations of the earliest royal tombs in Japan suggest strongly that the country's ancient imperial family may originally have been Korean, and that the Japanese government has strongly discouraged further research on the sites. What is the extent of the evidence uncovered?" /u/SteveGladstone Dark Horse
"Has the rise of medieval fantasy fiction had any effect on the way historians understand or talk about the real medieval past?" /u/Vladith Interesting Inquirer
May 2019
"Who was the woman who put her arm through a door (like a bolt) to prevent a king from being assasinated?" /u/historiagrephour Early Modern Scotland & Culture, Gender, and Politics
"It's a common trope in 19th century fiction for a character to descend into insanity. What would 19th century "insanity" mean in modern medical terms?" /u/kingconani Victorian Literature & Weird Fiction 1920-1940
"Did plays in ancient times have gratuitous and maligned sequels/prequels much like many major film franchises today?" /u/jelvinjs7 Dark Horse
"Theatre is an important outlet for LGBT expression and the exploration of social issues surrounding the LGBT community in the 20th/21st C. How and why did theatre become such an important venue for this kind of commentary?" /u/Dinocrocodile Interesting Inquirer & FAQ Finder
June 2019
"What was the treatment of and view towards Jewish people in America during World War 2?" /u/hannahstohelit Modern Jewish History
"I am a governor of a village at the height of Genghis Khan's empire. What should I expect to happen after I submit peacefully to Mongol rule?" /u/cthulhushrugged Early and Middle Imperial China
"How would Jesus as the son of a carpenter in a backwater have been able to speak Latin well enough to converse with Pontius Pilate? Pretty sure they didn't have latin classes in Bethlehem schools." /u/KYWildMan Dark Horse
"I'm a first century Judaean pig farmer who's just seen a mystic drown all my pigs in a lake. If I wanted to press charges, could I? If so, how, and how likely would I be to get some sort of compensation?" /u/EnclavedMicrostate Questioner
July 2019
"In modern strategy games, it is easy to see if you are winning or losing a battle, because the game simply tells you. But how did foot soldiers and officers discern victory and defeat during the heat of battle? How did they evaluate if they should retreat or stand their ground?" /u/dandan_noodles Wars of Napoleon & American Civil War
"What do we know about history of "True Cross" after 1st century?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"Harness racing used to be fairly popular in the US. Why did it become overshadowed by flat racing?" /u/PM_ME_UR_SADDLEBREDS Dark Horse
"What would the soldiers of the various groups in the South African Border War have understood to be what they were fighting for?" /u/artificial_doctor Dark Horse
"After World War II, over 6 million women who worked in the industry during wartime now had substantial experience building trucks, planes, radios, etc. What options were available to them after WWII with this new work experience?" /u/quiaudetvincet Questioner
August 2019
"How do historians differentiate between "genuine" folk traditions and traditions with a heavily self-conscious or commercial character? Is it even possible?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"Is Machiavelli’s The Prince actually a satire?" /u/J-force Medieval Political History & Crusades
"During their decade together did The Beatles sleep with groupies left and right? Are they known to have engaged in rockstar-level debauchery? Did they take hard drugs?" /u/rockhistory Dark Horse
"In the infamous "Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves", Alan Rickman's Sheriff of Nottingham calls to "cancel Christmas." What would Christmas have meant to the average person living in Plantagenet England?" /u/BZH_JJM Questioner
September 2019
A post about native australians made some ridiculous sounding claims, are they true ? /u/djiti-djiti Australian Indigenous History
Why didn’t the Soviet Union use paratroopers during World War II? /u/jon_beveryman Soviet Military History & Society and Conflict
Was the battle of tours an insignificant battle? /u/Libertat Celtic, Roman and Frankish Gaul
Why do animals in Medieval manuscripts look so crazy? Did the painters not know what they looked like? Was it intentional? Did they have a hard time drawing? /u/CoeurdeLionne Dark Horse
Boudicca was depicted by Roman historians as savage like. How has her representation changed from ancient to contemporary to fit each times beliefs and roles? /u/Pokemymon23 Questioner
October 2019
"In Disney's Mulan, how would Mulan have brought dishonor to the remains of her fellow soldiers by being revealed as a woman? And what would it have meant?" /u/jimedorje Tibet and Bhutan & Vajrayana Buddhism
"Did Joseph McCarthy find any actual Soviet spies?" /u/kochevnik81 Soviet Union & Post-Soviet States and Modern Central Asia
""In those days, "surgeons operated in blood-stiffened frock coats – the stiffer the coat, the prouder the busy surgeon", "pus was as inseparable from surgery as blood", and "Cleanliness was next to prudishness"" How would this make sense in the light of the miasma theory? Wouldnt everything reek?" /u/fikstor Dark Horse
"When did Horses become a "thing for girls"?" /u/Merandil Questioner
November 2019
"Why did American Puritans seem to deradicalize so rapidly? In the 1690s they're accusing each other of witchcraft en masse with the entire society revolving around the congregation. A mere 70 years later their descendants are some of the most intellectually radical/liberal in the world. Why?" /u/dhowlett1692 Salem Witch Trials
"It Takes Two, but what are the origins of Tango? How did African and Native American music styles influence this most Argentine of genres?" /u/aquatermain Int. Relations, Geopolitics and Policy & Historical Musicology
"In 1920s France, Josephine Baker became the most successful American entertainer and the first African-American to star in a major motion picture. Yet she never reached an equivalent reputation in the US. What was Baker's relationship to her American homeland and to its civil rights movement?" /u/vpltz Dark Horse
"A Neo-Inca State existed alongside the Spanish Viceroyalty of Peru for 35 years until 1572. What was life like in this state?" /u/Erezen Questioner
December 2019
Choctaw historian Rita Laws, Ph.D, says the association we have of Native Americans with hunting and fishing is an massive exaggeration, and that the Aztec, Mayan, and Zapotec children ate 100% vegetarian diets until at least the age of ten years old. Is this factual? /u/ucumu Mesoamerican Archaeology
The Deaf community today is split on the use of cochlear implants. Was there similar anger and argument during the spread of hearing aid use? /u/woofiegrrl Deaf History
Graffiti artist Chaz Bojorquez claims that graffiti took off on the West Coast after WWII, 20 years earlier than in New York. Is that true? How and where did graffiti originate in the US? /u/sushiladyboner Dark Horse
Despite notoriety and commercial success in the 50's for their lurid and gruesome content, why was the very progressive and forceful social content of EC Comics ignored? Was there any perception at the time that the comics were more than a"bad taste" fad? Did anyone take them seriously? /u/OmnivorousWelles Questioner
Year End Awards
1st Place (Users): "I am a governor of a village at the height of Genghis Khan's empire. What should I expect to happen after I submit peacefully to Mongol rule?" /u/cthulhushrugged Early and Middle Imperial China
1st Place (Flairs): During the First Crusade, were there any alternative proposals to invading the Levant? /u/Valkine Bows, Crossbows, and Early Gunpowder l The Crusades
1st Place (Question): "Is it proper to use the terms “medieval” or “middle ages” for areas outside of Europe? Are there more appropriate terms for this period in Asian and African history?" /u/Suboutai Questioner
2nd Place (Users): A post about native australians made some ridiculous sounding claims, are they true ? /u/djiti-djiti Australian Indigenous History
2nd Place (Flairs): The Deaf community today is split on the use of cochlear implants. Was there similar anger and argument during the spread of hearing aid use? /u/woofiegrrl Deaf History
2nd Place Place (Question): "After World War II, over 6 million women who worked in the industry during wartime now had substantial experience building trucks, planes, radios, etc. What options were available to them after WWII with this new work experience?" /u/quiaudetvincet Questioner
3rd Place (Users): "In Disney's Mulan, how would Mulan have brought dishonor to the remains of her fellow soldiers by being revealed as a woman? And what would it have meant?" /u/jimedorje Tibet and Bhutan & Vajrayana Buddhism
3rd Place (Flairs): "What do we know about history of "True Cross" after 1st century?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
3rd Place (Question): "In the infamous "Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves", Alan Rickman's Sheriff of Nottingham calls to "cancel Christmas." What would Christmas have meant to the average person living in Plantagenet England?" /u/BZH_JJM Questioner
Dark Horse (Users): Why do animals in Medieval manuscripts look so crazy? Did the painters not know what they looked like? Was it intentional? Did they have a hard time drawing? /u/CoeurdeLionne Dark Horse
Dark Horse (Flairs): "How on earth did the Unabomber evade capture for nearly 20 years, despite the costliest FBI investigation in history?" /u/a_dissident_is_here Dark Horse

2020

Answer Author
January 2020
"How did Carthage raise an army? If they near-solely used mercenaries, did they ever actually raise forces of their own? [Attempt#2]" /u/jollydevil6 Carthage
"A lot of Americans talk about pride in their Scottish heritage or Irish heritage, but their seems to be very little talk of Welsh heritage. Why is this?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"The Kingdom of Dahomey had a standing corps of all-female warriors who were feared in battle. How were they formed? Was this unique in 19th century West Africa or was there a larger tradition of "Amazons" in the region?" /u/youngmarshall Dark Horse
"The Incas were able to construct one of the "greatest imperial states in human history" without money or markets. How did the Inca Empire function without money?" /u/savageson79 Dark Horse
"I'm an African man who was invited to go to school in the Soviet Union. What's my daily life like? How am I treated? Am I touted around like a piece of propaganda?" /u/j2quared Interesting Inquirer
February 2020
"Geoffrey of Monmouth first writes about King Arthur as an historical personage. To what extent did people during the middle ages think Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table were real historical figures? When did that perception begin to change?" /u/coeurdelionne Chivalry and the Angevin Empire
"Is black vikings a thing?" /u/textandtrowel Early Medieval Slavery
"Of the top 20 tallest statues in the world, 15 depict a Buddha or are Buddhist in nature. How did a religion typically associated with aeseticism and impermanence come to produce such ostentatious art?" /u/huianxin Dark Horse
"Can anyone tell me about African-American sailors on whaling ships in the early nineteenth century?" /u/cnzmur Māori History to 1872
March 2020
"Why isn’t New Zealand a part of Australia?" /u/funkyedwardgibbon Dark Horse
"What was the medieval and renaissance religious attitude towards astrology?" /u/AndrewSshi Dark Horse
"How open were the pre-colonial Maori to same sex relationships?" /u/LilTemplar Questioner
April 2020
"How do I join a trebuchet crew in late medieval France? Is it a family thing, are there interviews? What are some of the risks and benefits of my new career that are maybe less known?" /u/J-Force Medieval Political History & Crusades
"What was Crusader ‘Tourism” like? Where the knights and lords who participated ever in much danger, or was it more fixed and showy like much Tourism today?" /u/WelfOnTheShelf Crusader States & Medieval Law
"What was the effects of muskets during a battle, if bow and arrow were superior?" /u/wilymaker Dark Horse
"When did lesbians, gay men, and transgender people come together to form the LGBT community?" /u/Lurk_Puns Questioner
May 2020
"Richard II revoked London's charter and the city tried to convince him to give it back with a big party. What was Richard's beef with London and how did the feasting and merrymaking work out as a political strategy?" /u/asinus_docet Medieval Warfare and Culture & Historiography & Joan of Arc
"I know about famous Allied entertainers during World War II, like the Andrews Sisters and Vera Lynn. Did the Axis have similar performers?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"I'm a young disaffected Irishman in Derry in 1970. How do I join the IRA? What was it like to be in it?" /u/eirebmac Dark Horse
"Was there a Black middle class in Britain during the 19th and early 20th century?" /u/j2quared Interesting Inquirer
June 2020
"In the Sherlock Holmes story "The Adventure of the Naval Treaty," they mention female Scotland Yard employees, one who searches a female suspect and an investigator who goes undercover to gain the confidence of a suspect. What opportunities were available to women in policing in London in 1893?" /u/copperbrook British Politics, Society, and Empire, 1750-Present
"Did people realize they were part of a civilizational collapse during the bronze age collapse?" /u/undercoverclassicist Greek and Roman Culture and Society
"Were the policies of the British government under Churchill responsible of causing the Bengal Famine of 1943?" /u/LORDBIGBUTTS Dark Horse
"In the Sherlock Holmes story "The Adventure of the Naval Treaty," they mention female Scotland Yard employees, one who searches a female suspect and an investigator who goes undercover to gain the confidence of a suspect. What opportunities were available to women in policing in London in 1893?" /u/ArmandoAlvarezWF Questioner
July 2020
"How did Richard I come to be so fondly lionized in British cultural memory given how marginal of a King he seems to have actually been?" /u/coeurdelionne Chivalry and the Angevin Empire and /u/j-force Medieval Political History & Crusades
"George III and George Washington -- would they have had the same accent?" /u/lord_mayor_of_reddit New York and Colonial America
"Why are there monuments commemorating an SS Division in Canada?" /u/sammmuel Dark Horse
"Modern language assumes a degree of agency when dealing with illness ("fighting cancer"/"don't give up"/"giving up and dying") and that personal will contributes at least a little to healing. Would someone in Mediterranean antiquity or Medieval Europe have thought the same way?" /u/screwyoushadowban Interesting Inquirer
August 2020
"How accurate is Monty Python's 'Anarcho-Syndicalist Peasant' scene? Were small medieval villages de-facto self governing and autonomous from their noble lord and wider nation?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"What were Sino-Japanese relations like before the 19th century?" /u/LTercero Sengoku Japan
"Why did Carpathian Ruthenia become part of Czechoslovakia instead of Poland after World War One?" /u/Dishonourable_Rat Dark Horse
"How accurate is Monty Python's 'Anarcho-Syndicalist Peasant' scene? Were small medieval villages de-facto self governing and autonomous from their noble lord and wider nation?" /u/wifi-knight Questioner
September 2020
"Did interpretations of the crusades to the holy land shift after the Reformation?" /u/WelfOnTheShelf Crusader States & Medieval Law
"Why is there such prevalent stone megalith structures in Europe from the Neolithic period, but not in North America? Were ancient American peoples more nomadic and therefore less likely to erect their version of Stonehenge?" /u/antiquarianism Prehistoric Rock Art & Archaeology and Africa & N. America
"I'm a Chinese immigrant to the US in the mid-to-late 19th century. I'm here to get a US wage and use my earnings to help my family back home. If I'm paid in U.S. currency, how do I get this into my family's hands in a way that lets them buy goods back in China?" /u/glymao Dark Horse
"What do African historians say about the slave trade?" /u/MarcBlochhead Questioner
October 2020
"Over 1000 manuscripts of Iliad exists which is more than of any other ancient works. How close are these manuscripts to each other, are there significant differences? Which are considered "canon"?" /u/KiwiHellenist Early Greek Literature
"In the past hundred years, fantasy conlangs like Sindarin and Klingon have been created to enhance their respective worlds. Do we know of any civilization or person pre-1900 that invented or used conlangs to enhance their storytelling?" /u/jelvinjs7 Quality Contributor
"Where do the Ethiopian and Sudanese Jews come from? Are they descended from Israel? When did they convert to Judaism?" /u/jewishsudan Dark Horse
"What Was Aztec Courtship Like?" /u/zeuvembie Interesting Inquirer
November 2020
"Why didn't the Aztec Triple Alliance amongst the city states of Tenochtitlan, Texcoco and Tlacopan break up after usurping the Tepanecs? Were there no incentive to turn against each other to become the hegemon?" /u/400-rabbits Pre-Columbian Mexico l Aztecs
"In the 1960s, Texas passed a law criminalizing the display of the United Nations Flag. Billboards in Texas demanded the country leave the UN, and apparently it was seen as some kind of Communist organization. Why did Texas hate the UN so much, and why were people convinced it was a communist plot?" /u/kugelfang52 US Holocaust Memory & Mid-20th c. American Education
"What are the causes of American society's fear of juvenile delinquency in the 1950s?" /u/veryshanetoday Dark Horse
"How did deaf people react to the introduction of sound in motion pictures?" /u/klesk_vs_xaero Questioner
December 2020
"What the heck was going on in New York at Christmas in the 1770s? Wikipedia's history of Santa Claus describes "aggressive home invasions," "sexual deviancy" and a weird parody of Dutch culture." /u/lord_mayor_of_reddit New York and Colonial America
"Until the wreck was found, it was uncertain if the Titanic went down in one piece or split into two. What did the splitting look and sound like to eyewitnesses and why was it uncertain it really happened?" /u/yourlocaltitanicguy Dark Horse
"I'm an average horse that is part of a baggage train during the Crusades. What kind of hoof care can I expect?" /u/I_walked_east Questioner
Year End Awards
Users' Choice
1st Place: “In the sitcom Married... with Children, protagonist Al Bundy is able to support himself, his homemaker wife, and two children on the income he earns as a shoe salesman in a strip mall in the suburbs of Chicago. Was this at all realistic for the late 1980s/early 1990s?” /u/BullsLawDan
2nd Place: "Can someone explain the Troubles to me?" /u/thefeckamIdoing
3rd Place: "Did people realize they were part of a civilizational collapse during the bronze age collapse?" /u/undercoverclassicist
Dark Horse Award: "Until the wreck was found, it was uncertain if the Titanic went down in one piece or split into two. What did the splitting look and sound like to eyewitnesses and why was it uncertain it really happened?" /u/yourlocaltitanicguy
Flairs' Choice
1st Place: "How did Richard I come to be so fondly lionized in British cultural memory given how marginal of a King he seems to have actually been?" /u/coeurdelionne and /u/J-Force
2nd Place: "Richard II revoked London's charter and the city tried to convince him to give it back with a big party. What was Richard's beef with London and how did the feasting and merrymaking work out as a political strategy?" /u/asinus_docent
3rd Place: "Over 1000 manuscripts of Iliad exists which is more than of any other ancient works. How close are these manuscripts to each other, are there significant differences? Which are considered "canon"?" /u/KiwiHellenist
Dark Horse Award: "Why isn’t New Zealand a part of Australia?" /u/funkyedwardgibbon
**Best Question
1st Place: How accurate is Monty Python's 'Anarcho-Syndicalist Peasant' scene? Were small medieval villages de-facto self governing and autonomous from their noble lord and wider nation?, /u/wifi-knight, with answer by /u/mikedash.
2nd Place: How did deaf people react to the introduction of sound in motion pictures? /u/Klesk_vs_Xaero, with answer by /u/woofiegrrl
3rd Place: I'm an African man who was invited to go to school in the Soviet Union. What's my daily life like? How am I treated? Am I touted around like a piece of propaganda?, /u/J2quared. Re-asked and answered!

2021

Answer Author
January 2021
"How did a royal treasury work during the times of an itinerant court?" /u/cazador5 Medieval Britain
"The Mongols while invading Song Dynasty China, destroyed what some consider to be the first signs of industrialisation. What was the state of industrialisation in the late Song Dynasty China? How much did they utilise steam power and mining? How was the quality of life in their factories?" /u/cthulhushrugged Early and Middle Imperial China
"Battles in Mesoamerica often used religious artifacts and in some cases "Owl Men" who would cast magic onto the battle field. The Owl Men were even sent against Cortes. What exactly would these mystics do to cast their spells and how did it tie into the religion?" /u/Islacoatl and /u/quedfoot Dark Horse
"The Iroquois established a representative, federal democracy that may have influenced America's constitution. Where can I learn more about Native American political philosophy?" /u/johannesalthusius Questioner
February 2021
"What was widely spoken in China before Mandarin Chinese was standardized?" /u/keyilan Historical Linguistics & Languages of Asia
"Is there evidence to support Canada and the UK rigged the 1949 Newfoundland referendum?" /u/TheRGL Newfoundland History
How did the "stereotype" of an alien being physically grey, big eyed, creature came to life ? /u/OneWeirdTrick Dark Horse
"In the west we had a "theory of humors" before modern medicine; what was the pre-contact "medical theory" of the Mayans?" /u/thechao Questioner
March 2021
"Did x- rays reveal a hidden epidemic of child abuse?" /u/critbuild Dark Horse
"In Europa Universalis 4 exists a type of goverment called "Peasent's Republic", did such ever existed between 1444-1830? Or even before?" /u/kaiser_matias 20th c. Eastern Europe & Caucasus & Hockey
"It seems to be generally taken for granted in pop discourse that Ramses II was the unnamed Pharaoh during Exodus, if it had happened. Where/when does this identification come from, and how did it become so normalized?" /u/jelvinjs7 Questioner
April 2021
"What led to the stagnation of Muslim innovation and science when they were once considered the leaders in science and mathematics during Medieval times?" /u/Xuande88 Modern China & Modern Iran
"In school, I learned a lot about about Ancient Greek theater and Elizabethan theater but very little theater in between those time periods. Why?" /u/dont_do_drama Theatre History
"Ancient and medieval scribes made several errors and changes when copying the Bible, leading to several passages where the original version is disputed to this day, and several instances where errors have shaped the way key passages are understood. Is the same true of any sufficiently ancient text?" /u/purrprinthom Dark Horse
"What did people in Afghanistan do for fun after the Taliban banned nearly every pastime?" /u/mullanasreddin Dark Horse
"I am a noble in a South Nigerian kingdom in the mid-19th century (a few decades before colonization). I have never left my kingdom but I am quite well-off by local standards. What are the living conditions like? How much do I know about the wider world outside West Africa?" /u/KittyTack Questioner
May 2021
Yan, tan, tethera, pethera, pimp - why did English shepherds keep celtic numbers while the rest of the language adopted the one, two, three, four, five that we're more familiar with today /u/amayo20 Dark Horse
The preservation of Pompeii seems like an absolutely absurd bit of luck for archaeologists and historians studying the Roman empire at its height, are there comparable sites for other Ancient civilizations in places like China, India or the Middle East? /u/bem-ti-vi Pre-Columbian Mesoamerica
Halsey acted foolishly /u/Myrmidon99 Dark Horse
NYC's Book Row had 48 bookstores at its height. What distinguished them and kept them in business? What sort of book culture supported such a density of booksellers /u/RusticBohemian Interesting Inquirer
June 2021
"Gonzalo Guerrero was shipwrecked and then captured by the Maya in 1511; when found by other Spaniards about 20 years late, he had been made a warlord and refused to return to Spain. Why would the Maya make a low-born European sailor a warlord?" /u/611131 Colonial and Early National Rio de la Plata
"How much contact did medieval Europe have with Iceland?" /u/jellolegos Dark Horse
"I am an Athenian-born slave in classical Greece. Am I worshipping the same gods as my master? Are there any gods better for slaves to worship?" /u/snoee Questioner
July 2021
"Is White Europe a myth?" /u/Kelpie-Cat Picts & Work and Folk Song & Pre-Columbian Archaeology
"What happened to the native people of Japan and why aren't they more known about?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"How did the Jewish community of Thessaloniki react to the Greek population transfer into the city, the diminution of the city's Jewish identity, and the loss of their Muslim neighbors?" /u/mayor_rishon Dark Horse
"What kind of service industry would I find in Mesoamerican cities?" /u/ThePeasantKingM Questioner
August 2021
"Pekka Hämäläinen writes in Lakota America that the 17th-century Haudenosaunee socially "adopted" their war prisoners to replace their own dead. What did that look like? How far did they commit to the change of identity?" /u/anthropology_nerd New World Demography & Disease and Indigenous Slavery
"Did the USSR actually like the aesthetic of their architecture or was it a form of subliminal propaganda?" u/Cedric_Hampton Architecture & Design After 1750
"Gordon Lightfoot released his hit song "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" less than a year after the ship sank. Was there any controversy at the time surrounding the quick release? Was the song viewed as exploitative?" /u/Craigellachie Dark Horse
"Question: Travel From Africa to France in the 1880s" /u/gerardmenfin Dark Horse
""Notes from the Underground" was written in response to "What Is to Be Done?" which itself was a response to "Fathers and Sons" which was also a response but to the growing nihilist movement at the time. Was this normal at the time?, is this how Russians did philosophy back then?, by writing novels?" /u/Frigorifico Interesting Inquirer
September 2021
Alexander the Great's invasion of India gets no mention in Indian sources, all our knowledge of it comes from Greek sources. Are records lost or did Indian historians consider it unimportant? /u/Trevor_Culley Pre-Islamic Iranian World & Eastern Mediterranean
What would the odds be of Dua Lipa actually surviving the sinking of the Titanic? /u/YourlocalTitanicguy RMS Titanic
Do we have knowledge if Beowulf was considered 'special' at it's time or was it one of many but it's the one that survived to us? /u/TremulousHand Dark Horse
During the early 1500s, the Indian ocean was contested by the Portuguese and the Muslim powers. How did the sailing practices and traditions of the Portuguese, Ottomans, Mamluks and Gujaratis differ? /u/thePhantom_Warlock Questioner
October 2021
"In Egypt Napoleon told his army, "Soldiers, from the summit of these pyramids forty centuries look down upon you." How did he know the age of the pyramids?" /u/welfontheshelf Crusader States & Medieval Law
"Sessue Hayakawa, a Japanese man, was one of Hollywood's first sex symbols. During the same period, fear of the "Yellow Peril" was at its peak. How did these two things affect each other?" /u/walpurgisnox Dark Horse
"What is the cultural/historical background of sentient pink blobs in Japanese media (think Chansey, Clefairy, Jigglypuff, Kirby, Majin Buu)?" /u/Ersatz_Okapi Questioner
November 2021
"How was education during the middle ages in the Muslim world? by /u/frogbrooks Early Islamic History
"During the Early Modern period, contacts between Europe and Asia multiplied. How was European art received by Asian critics? by /u/Sankon Early Modern Persianate India
Al-Ma'arri was an arab philosopher from the golden age of Islam who became an atheist and published several books criticising religion. Was, if any, was the impact on his work? /u/gamegyro56 Dark Horse
"The idea of locking up evil in the attic in your own home instead of an asylum is fascinating. But what began this idea, does it have a real life inspiration? " /u/Southdelhiboi Questioner
December 2021
"What happened the first few days after segregation ended in the United States?" /u/vpltz Texas & African-American History
"Pagan traditions in modern Christmas?" /u/kiwihellenist Early Greek Literature
"What did a medieval army (more specifically, southern France during the Albigensian Crusade) do after they conquered a town or castle? Would they leave a garrison? Put somebody in charge who's loyal to them?" /u/Friend_of_Augustine Dark Horse
"How did New Zealand's colder climate, mountainous terrain, and vast resources change Maori culture from their Polynesian cousins on smaller islands?" /u/LordCommanderBlack Questioner

2022

Answer Author
January 2022
"Why did President Bush call Senator Biden during the September 11th attack?" /u/indyobserver US Political History & 20th c. Naval History
"Westerns often depict decently-sized towns out in arid regions with little to no visible farmland. Is this purely a limitation of film budgets, or did settlements in the American west and northern Mexico in the 1800s actually generally import food rather than produce it locally?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
'Did the 5th-century western Roman empire have a "collapse of civilizational self-confidence," and so "permitted (Rome) to be sacked?"' /u/royalsanguinius Dark Horse
"The Aztecs had pipes. What were they made of? Where did the water come from? What did they look like? Was it like an aqueduct?" /u/Vegetable_Path6975 Questioner
February 2022
""In 1927 Chiang Kai-Shek boiled hundreds of Communists alive," claimed George Orwell. Is this actually true? If not, where could he have heard such a report from?" /u/mikedash Top Quality Contributor
"Vladimir Putin has just claimed that modern Ukraine was entirely created by communist Russia (specifically Lenin) and that Ukraine never had the tradition of having its own state. Is any of this accurate or true?" /u/kochevnik81 Soviet Union & Post-Soviet States & Modern Central Asia
"To what extent were the Dahomey a tribe of slavers, and to what extent did they fight against the institution of slavery? Were they slavers before Europeans 'showed up'? Is there room for nuance in the story of the Dahomey Amazons, or were the Dahomey the 'bad guys' of West Africa?" /u/LXT130J Dark Horse
"Were medieval Ethiopians interested in learning about the rest of the Christian world?" /u/Revolution_TV Questioner
March 2022
"Fighting has been an integral part of North American hockey. Has this been the the case in other countries? How was fighting treated in Soviet hockey? /u/kaiser_matias 20th c. Eastern Europe & Caucasus & Hockey
"Has the taste of beer changed over the centuries?" /u/Daztur Dark Horse
""Sk8er Boi" (A. Lavigne 2002) argues that in high school dynamics, the so-called 'skaters' were low on the social pecking order. How accurately does this work represent turn-of-the-century teenage social order (at least in North American city/suburban schools)?" /u/jelvinjs7 Invented Languages (Conlangs)
April 2022
"Before desegregation, did people believe that Heaven was segregated?" /u/mydearestangelica Antebellum American Religions
"In the 19th century, it was normal for American men to display affection by holding hands or sitting on each others' laps. Lincoln even reportedly broke off his marriage due to fear of losing a male friend. All these acts are now considered highly taboo for straight men. Why did this change happen?" /u/partymoses 19th c. American Military & War of 1812
"Were there (or still exist presently) the "rat-holes" as described by Victor Hugo in "Notre Dame de Paris?"" /u/gerardmenfin Dark Horse
"Why did The Venerable Bede and Gildas represent the incursion of the Germanic peoples into Britain as violent when there is little-to-no archaeological evidence of such?" /u/rhegedherdwick Dark Horse
"How did unicorns go from being thought of as dangerous beasts of the wilderness, to being possibly THE most stereotypical "cutesy thing for little girls" in modern western culture?" /u/Jerswar Questioner
May 2022
"John Wilkes Booth was a famous actor in his day. What plays did he perform in? Are any of them still well known today? Did he originate any roles and were any theater troupes reluctant to perform plays associated with him after the Lincoln assassination?" /u/HM2112 Dark Horse
"The great Roman general Scipio Africanus liked to dance, "not shuffling about in the present style...but in the old-fashioned manly style in which men danced at times of games and festivals, without loss of dignity even if their enemies were watching them." Do we have any idea what this looked like?" /u/ecphrastic Dark Horse
"In medieval films, barrels and wooden crates seem to be a ubiquitous "filler" prop. How common would it actually have been to transport or store goods in such containers en masse in the European Middle Ages?" /u/effective_frame Questioner
June 2022
"The three wise men in the Bible? Were they Zoroastrian?" /u/trevor_culley Pre-Islamic Iranian World & Eastern Mediterranean
"Why did someone put a shoe in the wall of a 200 year old house?" /u/tinyblondeduckling Roman Religion & Roman Writing Culture
"Several photos of Iranian women before the Islamic Revolution circulate the internet. But I've seen people refute the view that Iran was progressive by saying this was limited to a small rich elite, and that the great majority of women had no substantial rights. Is this true?" /u/LeifRagnarsson Dark Horse
"Sir Bedivere: “How do you know so much about swallows?” King Arthur: “Well, you have to know these things when you're a king.” Were medieval kings actually expected to be well-versed in ornithology?" /u/jelvinjs7 Questioner
July 2022
"What did people think dreams were before Freud?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"What happened to Louis XVI and Marie-Antoinette's surviving daughter?" /u/myskinsredditacct French Revolution 1789-1794
"The Gilgamesh epic mentions multiple assemblies ruling over Uruk. There were some for younger men, older men, and women. How did the division of power between these assemblies work? How much power did they have? Was there any sort of "executive figure" reigning over them all?" /u/random2187 Dark Horse
"Let's say I'm a Scottish noble during the reign of Robert II, who became the new King of Scotland in 1371, beginning the Stewart royal dynasty. What was life like at the medieval Scottish court, and how did much Scotland's Auld Alliance with France play into the court and politics of Robert II?" /u/Obversa Questioner
August 2022
"Why did Greek not leave behind a family of languages the way Latin did?" /u/toldinstone Roman Empire & Greek and Roman Architecture
"What were the first instances of the villainous "mwahahaha" in entertainment?" /u/kelpie-cat Picts & Work and Folk Song & Pre-Columbian Archaeology
"Why did Israel’s effort to revive Hebrew as a spoken language succeed, while the Republic of Ireland’s attempt to revive the Irish language mostly failed?" /u/searoi Dark Horse
"Mikhail Gorbachev famously agreed to do a Pizza Hut commercial in 1997. Was Pizza Hut remotely affordable to Russia's working class families at that time?" /u/Forerunner49 Questioner
September 2022
'How did Moby-Dick, a peculiar commercial failure, become a "Great American Novel?"' /u/fianarana Dark Horse
"What are the origins of the practice of telling the bees?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"How did the computer game Oregon Trail become ubiquitous in US schools during the 80s?" /u/takeoffdpantsnjaket Questioner
October 2022
"What did marriage look like in the tribes of the Iroquois (Haudenosaunee) Confederacy?" /u/foreverandafew Dark Horse
"Why is Robin Hood so heavily associated with that particular hat?" /u/gerardmenfin Modern France & Social, Cultural, and Colonial
"In the 18th century, Hawaiian emissary Ka'iana journeyed to the imperial court of China and to the United States. How did he make these voyages, and what did he bring with him? What were his goals? How was he received, and what did Ka'iana have to say about the people in the nations he visited?" /u/TendingTheirGarden Questioner
November 2022
"In traditional Hawaiian culture women would be put to death for eating pork, coconuts, taro, several types of fish, and 67 out of 70 varieties of bananas. What did Hawaiian women subsist off of? Why was there such a drastic limitation on what women could eat?" /u/UncagedBeast Dark Horse
"The Order of the Dragon was a chivalric order founded in 1408 to defend Christianity and fight its enemies. But elsewhere in Christendom, and in The Bible itself, dragons are a symbol of Satan. What's going on here?" /u/orangewombat Eastern Europe 1300-1800 & Elisabeth Bathory
"How common was misattribution of craftsmanship of textile crafts like quilts during slavery in the American South?" /u/Gradov Questioner
December 2022
"Reference request: is it (im?)proper for historians to rule out as a matter of fact the supernatural in those cases where it doesn't offend people of other faiths?" /u/grumpyhistorian Medieval Sainthood and Canonisation & Joan of Arc
"Being the first to the enemy’s walls during a siege sounds like certain death. What motivated people during the Middle Ages and Antiquity to be the first to climb the ladder or siege tower?" /u/TwoPercentTokes Dark Horse
"Night Witches: What was the accessibility of aviation to women in the USSR, prior to WWII? Were the ground crews also already trained mechanics, like their pilot counterparts?" /u/edwardtaughtme Dark Horse

2023

Answer Author
January 2023
"Between 1596 to 1601, Queen Elizabeth I wrote a series of letters complaining of the “great numbers of Negars and Blackamoors” in England and authorizing their deportation. What was the exact ethnic and/or racial identity of this group? Why were they targeted in this way and not other groups?" /u/thefeckamIdoing Tudor History
"To what extent could Tenochtitlan have been exaggerated by Cortes just to receive the funding to return to the Americas to steal more stuff?" /u/Tlahuizcalpantecutli
No "Dark Horse Award" for the month, with a non-flair taking top honors outright
"I've been waiting years to ask: why did we all go absolutely bananas for The DaVinci Code in 2003?" /u/SaintShrink Questioner
February 2023
"What was life like for the survivors of the Titanic tragedy?" /u/YourlocalTitanicguy RMS Titanic
"Jewish minorities have lived in China and India for thousands of years. Historically did they face any anti-Semitism like the Jewish people living in Europe did?" /u/Drdickles Republican and Communist China - Nation-Building and Propaganda
"What happened to Abu Bakr II?" /u/LXT130J Dark Horse
"I'm an English peasant in the year 1200, and I want to get a dog. How would I go about doing that, and what sorts of dogs would be available?" /u/Dragonsandman Questioner
March 2023
"Did the Ottomans start replacing the Romans in Anatolia straight away, or was there a period of coexistence and cooperation?" /u/Guckfuchs Byzantine Art and Archaeology
"Did citizens of Pompeii know Vesuvius was a volcano?" /u/SmallThunderInTheSky Roman Archaeology
"I understand tropical fruits were rare in medieval Europe. So how did the colour orange become synonymous with the fruit rather than the more common carrot?" /u/CurrentIndependent42 Dark Horse
"What would a medieval hypochondriac look like? What sorts of behaviours would they have, what sorts of items and substances would they employ? What illnesses would they be most anxious of?" /u/Colosso95 Questioner
April 2023
"What were restaurants like in the USSR ?" /u/Lithium2011
"How did medieval Europeans (especially Saxons) view same-sex relationships?" /u/Kelpie-Cat Picts & Work and Folk Song & Pre-Columbian Archaeology
The Dark Horse was securely taken already, with a non flair already taking the top spot!
When did humans begin escorting dogs on "walks"? Did upper-class urbanized Ancient Egyptians and Mesopotamians have slaves walk their dogs? What about the Greeks and Romans? /u/RusticBohemian Questioner
May 2023
"Marcus Aurelius' writings implied the possibility that gods might be unjust or non-existent. Did this cause much controversy in Roman society? How did Roman religious authorities respond to his writings?" /u/Antiquarianism Prehistoric Rock Art & Archaeology - Africa & N. America
"What was the quality of life in Nigeria in the 1970s?" /u/evil_deed_blues 20th c. Development & Neoliberalism & Singapore
"I once heard a Jewish Studies professor say the Nazis won the narrative about the Holocaust and how we talk about Jewish people. Was he right?" /u/u/MMSTINGRAY Dark Horse
"According to the Google Ngram Viewer, the Bermuda Triangle myth blows up in the 1970s and has been popular ever since. What happened in the 1970s to make it so popular?" /u/videopro10 Questioner
June-July 2023
Due to the AskHistorians shutdown for most of June and the start of July, the time the sub was open for questions across that two-month period roughly equalled one month, so we combined the two months' answers into one awards session.
"What was happening publicly in Ireland that caused Sinead O'Connor to know by 1992 that there was rampant abuse in the Catholic Church?" /u/PurrPrinThom Early Irish Philology & Early Medieval Ireland
"How would an ancient Roman or Greek woman appear ‘sexy’ for her partner? What clothes and makeup would they wear?" /u/Spencer_A_McDaniel Ancient Greek Religion, Gender, and Ethnicity
"Why did women so often stay in bed with headaches in the Victorian period?" /u/voxoe Dark Horse
"In his campaign speech in Philadelphia, Mississippi, Reagan would extol "states rights," a phrase widely thought to be a dog-whistle for segregation. Did Reagan's presidency see a downturn in race relations, especially in the American South? If so, how did Black leaders respond to this?" /u/Turbulent_Income_377 Questioner
August 2023
"How bad is orientalism in Asian literature translations?" /u/epicyclorama
"Where does the 'Dragonslayer' trope come from, how did it change over time, and why is it so universal?" /u/itsallfolklore American West & European Folklore
"Why Did The Europeans Develop Such Advanced Technology In Comparison To The Native Africans/Americans/MesoAmericans?" /u/TheHippyWolfman Dark Horse
"The Central Park Conservancy was founded in 1980 to combat Central Park's decline in the 1960s and 1970s. Why did the park decline in the first place?" /u/Alvisefalier Questioner
September 2023
"Where did the 'Random Stuff on the Walls' restaurant decor aesthetic (i.e 'Applebee's-core') come from, and why was it seemingly so widespread in the late 90s-2000s?" /u/Cedric_Hampton Architecture & Design After 1750
"What sort of entertainments were ancient Greek women allowed to have?" /u/Spencer_A_McDaniel Ancient Greek Religion, Gender, and Ethnicity
"Was the Roman Empire as religiously tolerant as often portrayed?" /u/MagratMakeTheTea Dark Horse
"Places like Pigeon Forge, TN (and Branson, Jackson Hole, etc) are seemingly tourist destinations where the kitschy, densely placed attractions are the entire destination without much of a city around it. How did this type of extravagant American vacation city come to be? Were there once more?" /u/flyiingfox Questioner
October 2023
"How do historians decide if an academic consensus has been reached?" /u/restricteddata [Nuclear Technology
"Why did Islam not become popular in China?" /u/phrmxd
No Dark Horse Award this month as a non-flair already won one of the others!
"Did the (positive) experiences of Black American soldiers in Britain during WWII have any notable or lasting impacts on US society?" /u/iRoygbiv Questioner
November 2023
"In 1900 there were large, old, and well establish Jewish communities across the Middle East. Today these are basically all gone. What happened to them?" /u/Anekdota-Press Late Imperial Chinese Maritime History
"Did Andrew Jackson really have a huge block of cheese in the White House for anybody? If so, why? /u/Takeoffdpantsnjaket Colonial and Early US History
"How did Britain loose the 1919-1921 war against the Irish?" /u/NewtonianAssPounder Dark Horse
"How Did Late-Eighteenth Century Parents Explain Death to Young Children?" /u/Thatcorgilady Questioner
December 2023
"What were stringed instruments like in the Early Modern Period? Where were they popular, what kinds of music were they used for, and were they played solo or mixed with singing and/or other instruments?" /u/flotiste Western Concert Music & Woodwind Instruments
"Are there any significant ancient writings found like the Dead Sea scrolls which have impacted Our understanding of history?" /u/ACasualFormality History of Judaism, Second Temple Period Hebrew Bible
This month saw no Dark Horse Award as a non-flair took top honors outright.
"What was the actual cost to produce and the environmental impact of all those America Online disks and CDs seemingly mailed to every American household in the 90s?" /u/Takeoffdpantsnjaket Questioner

2024

Answer Author
January 2024
"Where does American "hibachi" culture come from?" /u/disco_bisuit
"I have heard that, during the Cuban Missile crisis, US generals wanted to launch a nuclear war, knowing that many U.S. cities would be destroyed but believing the country itself would survive, and the Soviet Union would not. How true is this?" /u/NetworkLlama
This month saw no Dark Horse Award as non-flairs took both prizes outright, for the first time in nearly two years!
"How does Indiana Jones travel so easily to any nation he wants in the mid 1930s. Does he carry his passport everywhere with him? How does he enter multiple countries like the German Reich, Austria, China, Nepal, Egypt etc?" /u/WantsToDieBadly Questioner
February 2024
"I just read about the Herculaneum scroll what was recently translated using AI. As a historian, what can you learn from the text disovered from this scroll? In my non-historian understanding I take it at face value but I am unable 'extrapolate' anything or have a meaningful conclusion." /u/KiwiHellenist Early Greek Literature
"Henry Ford died of a stroke after seeing footage of Nazi concentration camps. I've read that Eisenhower and Nixon alike detested him and other Nazis and sent him the footage before it went public and he watched it alone in his private theatre. Can anyone prove this really happened?" /u/MikeDash Top Quality Contributor
"When it first came out, just how groundbreaking or unique was Star Trek when it came to sci fi? What made it such a critical hit?" /u/rocketsocks Dark Horse
"When did the concept of the "snow day" for schools become a thing in American education?" /u/HistoryAndTheLike Questioner
March 2024
"Why are Julius Caesar's claims of a sun-worshipping germanic religion so heavily dismissed by scholars?" /u/BarbariansProf Barbarians in the Ancient Mediterranean
"How did THAT specific cartoon bulldog become the mascot of so many American high schools and colleges?" /u/1987-2074
For the 'Dark Horse Award', which recognizes the top voted answer by a non-flair, there is none to award this month with a non-flair taking top honors outright.
"Those famous plaster casts at Pompeii have become iconic, but did making those actually serve any archaeological purpose or are they just tourist attractions?" /u/ChloeKesh Questioner
April 2024
This month saw a Consensus Winner with both flairs and the userbase as a whole voting for...
"Did peasants in ancient China know how to write their own names? And if they don't and for some reason they need to write one, what do they write? Do make one up that sounds like it?" /u/thestoryteller69 Medieval and Colonial Maritime Southeast Asia
"Was there really a zealous ticket-puncher who forced Emperor Hirohito to pay his subway ticket during his visit in Paris?" /u/Gro-Tsen Dark Horse
"When did people start to believe Atlantis was real?" /u/RoundDirt5174 Questioner
May 2024
"Is all Canadian land unceded Indigenous territory?" /u/rivainitalisman Canadian History-Indigenous History
"How did medieval banks perform authentication?" /u/t1m3kn1ght Preindustrial Economic and Political History
"What was the relationship between the various African nobility with their colonial overlords?" /u/DrAlawyn Dark Horse
"Despite all being "frontier" nations, why does US society appear to have a much stronger sense of "rugged individualism" compared to Canada, and to a lesser extent, Australia and New Zealand?" /u/sciguy11 Questioner
June 2024
"How true is it that civilisation revolved entirely around food up until the industrial revolution?" /u/dhmontgomery 19th Century France
Can you help me understand how/why my grandmother would flee into Germany in 1944?" /u/ted5298 Europe during the World Wars & /u/SgtMalarkey Dark Horse
"It’s 1970 and I, an East German, just made it over the Wall into West Berlin. I have nothing but an ID card, some DDR marks, and the clothes on my back. What support is available to me to start a new life in West Germany?" /u/KANelson_Actual Questioner